Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

1. Models and Theories in Geography

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

8 min read8 sections

1. Models and Theories in Geography

🎯
Exam pointers: definitions of a model (Skilling, Ackoff, Haines-Young & Petch, Chorley–Haggett), types (descriptive vs normative; iconic/analogue/symbolic; scale, simulation, stochastic, mathematical, analogue, theoretical), Monte Carlo vs Markov chain, gravity model, rank-size rule, linear programming, five-storey framework, criticisms.

1. What is a Model? ⭐⭐

💡
Think of a model as a toy version of reality: a globe is a model of the earth, a map is a model of a city, an equation is a model of a process. It keeps the important parts and throws away the rest so that we can understand, explain and predict.
Scholar
Definition
Chorley & Haggett (Models in Geography, 1967)
"A simplified structuring of reality which presents supposedly significant features or relationships in a generalised form". Most post-war geographers: an idealised, simplified representation of reality
Skilling (1964)
A model is "either a theory, a law, a hypothesis or a structured idea"; it can be a role, a relation or an equation; it includes reasoning about the real world through relations in space or time
Ackoff
"A formal presentation of a theory or law using the tools of logic, set theory and mathematics"
Haines-Young & Petch
"Any device or mechanism which generates a prediction is a model"; modelling, like experiment and observation, lets theories be tested
Haggett
Geography = study of the earth's surface within which the human population lives; models help to find order in it

Hypothesis → Model → Theory → Law

Term
Meaning
Example
Hypothesis
A testable guess about a relationship
"Land rent falls with distance from market"
Model
Simplified structured representation
Von Thünen's rings
Theory
Set of connected, tested statements that explain
Central Place Theory
Law
Universal, repeatedly confirmed regularity
Tobler's First Law: "Everything is related to everything else, but near things are more related than distant things" (1970)

2. Significance / Utility of Models ⭐

The earth – the "real document" of geography – is complex, diverse and dynamic. Models make it manageable. Uses:
  1. Quantify the unobservable – estimation, forecasting, simulation, interpolation (population growth, migration, urbanisation, slums; weather, climate change, sea level, soil erosion, landform evolution).
  1. Describe, analyse and simplify a system (industrial location, agricultural zoning, landform stages).
  1. Organise enormous data by picking out patterns and correlations.
  1. Act as "laboratories" – surrogate observation; test "what if" changes; future scenarios.
  1. Explain causal mechanisms and micro–macro links.
  1. Give a framework to state theories and test them.
  1. Linguistic economy – say much in little.
  1. Help to test hypotheses and build theories and laws.

3. Features (Characteristics) of a Model ⭐

Mnemonic – "SAP-G": Selective, Analogy, Predictive, Generalising.
  1. Selective – "a highly selective attitude to information"; not all attributes are included.
  1. Gives prominence to some features, obscures or distorts others.
  1. Contains suggestions for generalisation → predictions possible.
  1. Is an analogy – different from the real world.
  1. Tempts us to form hypotheses and build theory.
  1. Shows reality in a familiar, simplified, observable, controllable form.
  1. Gives a framework to define, collect, tabulate and process data.
  1. Squeezes maximum information from data.
  1. Explains how a phenomenon came into being.
  1. Allows comparison with familiar phenomena.
  1. Lets us visualise phenomena too large or complex to grasp.
  1. Are stepping stones to theories and laws.

4. Types of Models ⭐⭐⭐

A. By function

Descriptive
Normative
Stylised description of what is
What ought to / might be under stated conditions
Organises empirical information: data, classificatory (taxonomic), experimental-design models
Uses a familiar situation as a model for a less familiar one (in time or space); strongly predictive
e.g. a land-use map
e.g. von Thünen, Weber, Christaller (all normative/ideal)

B. By the "stuff" they are made of (Chorley & Haggett) ⭐

Type
Meaning
Examples
Hardware / Physical / Experimental
Built of material
—
• Iconic
Same properties, only scale changed
Globe, map, relief model, river flume
• Analogue
Real properties shown by different properties
Hydraulic model of economy, electric circuit for flows, colours for heights
Symbolic / Mathematical / Theoretical
Verbal or mathematical assertions in logical terms
Gravity equation, rank-size rule

C. Other common classifications (for MCQs)

Pair
Meaning
Static vs Dynamic
Fixed state (relief model) vs changes over time (wave tank, Limits to Growth)
Deterministic vs Stochastic (probabilistic)
One certain outcome vs outcome governed by chance
A priori (deductive) vs A posteriori (inductive)
Built from theory first vs built from observed data
General vs Partial
Whole system vs part of it
Spatial vs Aspatial
Includes location/distance vs not

D. General (systematic) classification with examples ⭐⭐

(1) Scale (Hardware) Models
  • Direct reproductions of reality, usually smaller.
  • Static: relief or geological models. Dynamic: wave tank, river flume (more useful).
  • Advantage: processes can be controlled – hold two variables constant and vary the third. In a wave tank, the effect of material size, wavelength and wave steepness on beach slope can be measured.
  • Scale problem: if sand is scaled up it becomes cobbles; if scaled down it becomes silt or clay – they behave differently.
  • Engineers use them before dams, canals, river works, harbours, flood forecasting; geomorphologists for weathering, rivers, glaciers, wind, coasts, groundwater.
(2) Maps – the most familiar model
  • A special scale model that becomes more abstract (symbolic) as scale gets smaller.
  • Spectrum: stereo-pair vertical air photo (almost a true scale model, but static) → large-scale map → small-scale symbolic map.
  • Maps show relief (contours, hill-shading, hachures) and a large area at once.
  • Diagrammatic maps / cartograms – area scaled to population or another variable.
  • A curved 3-D earth cannot be shown correctly on a 2-D plane (projection distortions). Globes are true but of little practical use.
(3) Simulation and Stochastic Models
  • Simulation = imitating a process with an analogous situation. Stochastic = randomly determined: can be analysed statistically but not predicted precisely. Used for dynamic situations.
  • Random-walk drainage model: grid squares, random stream sources, random flow direction (4 choices) → a network like a natural one ⇒ natural drainage has an element of chance (Leopold & Langbein).
  • Coastal spit model: each wave process is allotted a range of random numbers; if the simulated spit looks real, the proportions are right and it can predict.
  • Human geography: spatial diffusion of diseases (malaria, smallpox, AIDS, COVID-19) and innovations (tractors, fertilisers, HYV seeds), with barriers of varying permeability.
Monte Carlo model
Markov chain model
Chance alone decides each move
Each move is partly determined by the previous move (memory of one step)
e.g. Hägerstrand's innovation diffusion (1953)
e.g. random-walk drainage model, migration/land-use change
(4) Mathematical Models
  • More reliable but difficult to build; obscure human values, attitudes, customs.
  • Logic example: A > B, B > C ∴ A > C – valid at all times (ahistorical) and everywhere (aspatial).
  • Classified by probability into deterministic and stochastic.
  • J.F. Nye's glacier-flow model: rectangular (U-shaped) bed of uniform size and roughness; ice perfectly plastic; differential equations predict flow and profile; checked in the field; then used for parts that cannot be measured (e.g. basal flow). Also rivers moving load, coastal waves. → Best suited to physical geography.
  • Human geography: empirical relations, e.g. rank-size rule – few large towns, many small; straight line on a double-log graph.
  • Economic geography: linear programming – finds the optimum location that satisfies all constraints (labour, capital, raw material, transport, market) plotted as straight lines.
(5) Analogue Models
  • Study a feature by comparing it with a better-known, different one. Use the positive analogy (common elements); ignore negative (dissimilar) and neutral (irrelevant) analogies.
  • James Hutton (1795): circulation of blood ↔ circulation of matter in landscapes (and the hydrological cycle).
  • Davis's cycle of erosion (youth–maturity–old age) and Ratzel's state as an organism → organic analogies.
  • Metals under stress ↔ ice.
  • Kinematic waves: traffic on crowded roads, stones and flood waves in rivers, surges at glacier snouts (all one-dimensional flows).
  • Gravity model (from Newton): interaction between two places I = k × (P1 × P2) / d². Assumes no barriers (border, language). Also magnetic fields and the second law of thermodynamics (entropy) (Leopold & Langbein, Wilson's entropy-maximising model).
(6) Theoretical Models
  • (a) Conceptual: deduce consequences of a theory and match with reality. Example: with waves as the only process, an erosion limit of about 13 m (~40 ft) and a limiting platform gradient → only a slowly rising sea level produces a very wide wave-cut platform. Similar models for slope-profile evolution.
  • (b) Theory as the framework of the whole discipline – must be flexible; models common to all branches give geography unity.

5. Five-Storey Framework of Geographical Methodology ⭐⭐

Each storey is supported by the one below and supports the one above.

6. Critical Evaluation – Criticisms of Modelling ⭐

  1. Badly made: over-simplification misleads and gives bad predictions; under-simplification explains nothing.
  1. Wrong focus: techniques like principal component analysis, stepwise regression, Q-analysis may give models more complex than the data.
  1. Not everywhere suitable: human, regional, cultural, historical geography get distorted; generalisation from few cases.
  1. Outright rejection (humanists): models cannot handle beliefs, values, emotions, hopes, fears.
  1. Generalisation itself may be futile where free will and unique cases matter.
  1. Mathematical difficulty – few geographers, students, policymakers are comfortable with symbols.
  1. No model is adequate by itself – constant revision needed. Feyerabend (1975): knowledge is "an ever-increasing ocean of mutually incompatible alternatives… Nothing is ever settled". Growth of knowledge has crises and breaks (Kuhn).
  1. Data poverty in developing countries → distorted, exaggerated predictions.
  1. Western bias: built on ~100 years of European/North American data; applying them blindly to developing countries can be "disastrous". There is no universal agricultural, industrial or urban geography.

7. Key Books (for author–title MCQs)

Book
Author
Year
Models in Geography
Chorley & Haggett
1967
Integrated Models in Geography
Chorley & Haggett
1969
Frontiers in Geographical Teaching
Chorley & Haggett
1965
Locational Analysis in Human Geography
Haggett
1965
Explanation in Geography
David Harvey
1969
Theoretical Geography
William Bunge
1962
Quantitative Geography
Cole & King
1968
Scientific Explanation
R.B. Braithwaite
1953
Models and Analogies in Science
Mary Hesse
1966
The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
T.S. Kuhn
1962

⚡ Quick Revision

  • "Any device which generates a prediction is a model" → Haines-Young & Petch.
  • "Theory, law, hypothesis or structured idea" → Skilling (1964).
  • Formal presentation using logic, set theory, mathematics → Ackoff.
  • Chance alone → Monte Carlo; previous step matters → Markov chain.
  • Glacier-flow mathematical model → J.F. Nye.
  • Blood circulation analogy → James Hutton (1795).
  • Gravity model is an analogue model borrowed from physics (Newton).
  • Wave tank / river flume → dynamic scale (hardware) model.
  • Map = most familiar iconic/scale model.