Exam pointers: definitions of a model (Skilling, Ackoff, Haines-Young & Petch, Chorley–Haggett), types (descriptive vs normative; iconic/analogue/symbolic; scale, simulation, stochastic, mathematical, analogue, theoretical), Monte Carlo vs Markov chain, gravity model, rank-size rule, linear programming, five-storey framework, criticisms.
1. What is a Model? ⭐⭐
Think of a model as a toy version of reality: a globe is a model of the earth, a map is a model of a city, an equation is a model of a process. It keeps the important parts and throws away the rest so that we can understand, explain and predict.
Scholar | Definition |
Chorley & Haggett (Models in Geography, 1967) | "A simplified structuring of reality which presents supposedly significant features or relationships in a generalised form". Most post-war geographers: an idealised, simplified representation of reality |
Skilling (1964) | A model is "either a theory, a law, a hypothesis or a structured idea"; it can be a role, a relation or an equation; it includes reasoning about the real world through relations in space or time |
Ackoff | "A formal presentation of a theory or law using the tools of logic, set theory and mathematics" |
Haines-Young & Petch | "Any device or mechanism which generates a prediction is a model"; modelling, like experiment and observation, lets theories be tested |
Haggett | Geography = study of the earth's surface within which the human population lives; models help to find order in it |
Hypothesis → Model → Theory → Law
Term | Meaning | Example |
Hypothesis | A testable guess about a relationship | "Land rent falls with distance from market" |
Model | Simplified structured representation | Von Thünen's rings |
Theory | Set of connected, tested statements that explain | Central Place Theory |
Law | Universal, repeatedly confirmed regularity | Tobler's First Law: "Everything is related to everything else, but near things are more related than distant things" (1970) |
2. Significance / Utility of Models ⭐
The earth – the "real document" of geography – is complex, diverse and dynamic. Models make it manageable. Uses:
- Quantify the unobservable – estimation, forecasting, simulation, interpolation (population growth, migration, urbanisation, slums; weather, climate change, sea level, soil erosion, landform evolution).
- Describe, analyse and simplify a system (industrial location, agricultural zoning, landform stages).
- Organise enormous data by picking out patterns and correlations.
- Act as "laboratories" – surrogate observation; test "what if" changes; future scenarios.
- Explain causal mechanisms and micro–macro links.
- Give a framework to state theories and test them.
- Linguistic economy – say much in little.
- Help to test hypotheses and build theories and laws.
3. Features (Characteristics) of a Model ⭐
Mnemonic – "SAP-G": Selective, Analogy, Predictive, Generalising.
- Selective – "a highly selective attitude to information"; not all attributes are included.
- Gives prominence to some features, obscures or distorts others.
- Contains suggestions for generalisation → predictions possible.
- Is an analogy – different from the real world.
- Tempts us to form hypotheses and build theory.
- Shows reality in a familiar, simplified, observable, controllable form.
- Gives a framework to define, collect, tabulate and process data.
- Squeezes maximum information from data.
- Explains how a phenomenon came into being.
- Allows comparison with familiar phenomena.
- Lets us visualise phenomena too large or complex to grasp.
- Are stepping stones to theories and laws.
4. Types of Models ⭐⭐⭐
A. By function
Descriptive | Normative |
Stylised description of what is | What ought to / might be under stated conditions |
Organises empirical information: data, classificatory (taxonomic), experimental-design models | Uses a familiar situation as a model for a less familiar one (in time or space); strongly predictive |
e.g. a land-use map | e.g. von Thünen, Weber, Christaller (all normative/ideal) |
B. By the "stuff" they are made of (Chorley & Haggett) ⭐
Type | Meaning | Examples |
Hardware / Physical / Experimental | Built of material | — |
• Iconic | Same properties, only scale changed | Globe, map, relief model, river flume |
• Analogue | Real properties shown by different properties | Hydraulic model of economy, electric circuit for flows, colours for heights |
Symbolic / Mathematical / Theoretical | Verbal or mathematical assertions in logical terms | Gravity equation, rank-size rule |
C. Other common classifications (for MCQs)
Pair | Meaning |
Static vs Dynamic | Fixed state (relief model) vs changes over time (wave tank, Limits to Growth) |
Deterministic vs Stochastic (probabilistic) | One certain outcome vs outcome governed by chance |
A priori (deductive) vs A posteriori (inductive) | Built from theory first vs built from observed data |
General vs Partial | Whole system vs part of it |
Spatial vs Aspatial | Includes location/distance vs not |
D. General (systematic) classification with examples ⭐⭐
(1) Scale (Hardware) Models
- Direct reproductions of reality, usually smaller.
- Static: relief or geological models. Dynamic: wave tank, river flume (more useful).
- Advantage: processes can be controlled – hold two variables constant and vary the third. In a wave tank, the effect of material size, wavelength and wave steepness on beach slope can be measured.
- Scale problem: if sand is scaled up it becomes cobbles; if scaled down it becomes silt or clay – they behave differently.
- Engineers use them before dams, canals, river works, harbours, flood forecasting; geomorphologists for weathering, rivers, glaciers, wind, coasts, groundwater.
(2) Maps – the most familiar model
- A special scale model that becomes more abstract (symbolic) as scale gets smaller.
- Spectrum: stereo-pair vertical air photo (almost a true scale model, but static) → large-scale map → small-scale symbolic map.
- Maps show relief (contours, hill-shading, hachures) and a large area at once.
- Diagrammatic maps / cartograms – area scaled to population or another variable.
- A curved 3-D earth cannot be shown correctly on a 2-D plane (projection distortions). Globes are true but of little practical use.
(3) Simulation and Stochastic Models
- Simulation = imitating a process with an analogous situation. Stochastic = randomly determined: can be analysed statistically but not predicted precisely. Used for dynamic situations.
- Random-walk drainage model: grid squares, random stream sources, random flow direction (4 choices) → a network like a natural one ⇒ natural drainage has an element of chance (Leopold & Langbein).
- Coastal spit model: each wave process is allotted a range of random numbers; if the simulated spit looks real, the proportions are right and it can predict.
- Human geography: spatial diffusion of diseases (malaria, smallpox, AIDS, COVID-19) and innovations (tractors, fertilisers, HYV seeds), with barriers of varying permeability.
Monte Carlo model | Markov chain model |
Chance alone decides each move | Each move is partly determined by the previous move (memory of one step) |
e.g. Hägerstrand's innovation diffusion (1953) | e.g. random-walk drainage model, migration/land-use change |
(4) Mathematical Models
- More reliable but difficult to build; obscure human values, attitudes, customs.
- Logic example: A > B, B > C ∴ A > C – valid at all times (ahistorical) and everywhere (aspatial).
- Classified by probability into deterministic and stochastic.
- J.F. Nye's glacier-flow model: rectangular (U-shaped) bed of uniform size and roughness; ice perfectly plastic; differential equations predict flow and profile; checked in the field; then used for parts that cannot be measured (e.g. basal flow). Also rivers moving load, coastal waves. → Best suited to physical geography.
- Human geography: empirical relations, e.g. rank-size rule – few large towns, many small; straight line on a double-log graph.
- Economic geography: linear programming – finds the optimum location that satisfies all constraints (labour, capital, raw material, transport, market) plotted as straight lines.
(5) Analogue Models
- Study a feature by comparing it with a better-known, different one. Use the positive analogy (common elements); ignore negative (dissimilar) and neutral (irrelevant) analogies.
- James Hutton (1795): circulation of blood ↔ circulation of matter in landscapes (and the hydrological cycle).
- Davis's cycle of erosion (youth–maturity–old age) and Ratzel's state as an organism → organic analogies.
- Metals under stress ↔ ice.
- Kinematic waves: traffic on crowded roads, stones and flood waves in rivers, surges at glacier snouts (all one-dimensional flows).
- Gravity model (from Newton): interaction between two places I = k × (P1 × P2) / d². Assumes no barriers (border, language). Also magnetic fields and the second law of thermodynamics (entropy) (Leopold & Langbein, Wilson's entropy-maximising model).
(6) Theoretical Models
- (a) Conceptual: deduce consequences of a theory and match with reality. Example: with waves as the only process, an erosion limit of about 13 m (~40 ft) and a limiting platform gradient → only a slowly rising sea level produces a very wide wave-cut platform. Similar models for slope-profile evolution.
- (b) Theory as the framework of the whole discipline – must be flexible; models common to all branches give geography unity.
5. Five-Storey Framework of Geographical Methodology ⭐⭐
Each storey is supported by the one below and supports the one above.
6. Critical Evaluation – Criticisms of Modelling ⭐
- Badly made: over-simplification misleads and gives bad predictions; under-simplification explains nothing.
- Wrong focus: techniques like principal component analysis, stepwise regression, Q-analysis may give models more complex than the data.
- Not everywhere suitable: human, regional, cultural, historical geography get distorted; generalisation from few cases.
- Outright rejection (humanists): models cannot handle beliefs, values, emotions, hopes, fears.
- Generalisation itself may be futile where free will and unique cases matter.
- Mathematical difficulty – few geographers, students, policymakers are comfortable with symbols.
- No model is adequate by itself – constant revision needed. Feyerabend (1975): knowledge is "an ever-increasing ocean of mutually incompatible alternatives… Nothing is ever settled". Growth of knowledge has crises and breaks (Kuhn).
- Data poverty in developing countries → distorted, exaggerated predictions.
- Western bias: built on ~100 years of European/North American data; applying them blindly to developing countries can be "disastrous". There is no universal agricultural, industrial or urban geography.
7. Key Books (for author–title MCQs)
Book | Author | Year |
Models in Geography | Chorley & Haggett | 1967 |
Integrated Models in Geography | Chorley & Haggett | 1969 |
Frontiers in Geographical Teaching | Chorley & Haggett | 1965 |
Locational Analysis in Human Geography | Haggett | 1965 |
Explanation in Geography | David Harvey | 1969 |
Theoretical Geography | William Bunge | 1962 |
Quantitative Geography | Cole & King | 1968 |
Scientific Explanation | R.B. Braithwaite | 1953 |
Models and Analogies in Science | Mary Hesse | 1966 |
The Structure of Scientific Revolutions | T.S. Kuhn | 1962 |
⚡ Quick Revision
- "Any device which generates a prediction is a model" → Haines-Young & Petch.
- "Theory, law, hypothesis or structured idea" → Skilling (1964).
- Formal presentation using logic, set theory, mathematics → Ackoff.
- Chance alone → Monte Carlo; previous step matters → Markov chain.
- Glacier-flow mathematical model → J.F. Nye.
- Blood circulation analogy → James Hutton (1795).
- Gravity model is an analogue model borrowed from physics (Newton).
- Wave tank / river flume → dynamic scale (hardware) model.
- Map = most familiar iconic/scale model.