Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

2. Systems Analysis & General System Theory

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

6 min read9 sections

2. Systems Analysis & General System Theory

🎯
Exam pointers: definition of system; open vs closed vs isolated; earth = open for energy, closed for matter; Bertalanffy (GST); cybernetics (Wiener); elements–links–environment; series, parallel, feedback relations; negative (morphostatic/homeostatic) vs positive (morphogenetic) feedback; Chorley's systems in geomorphology; criticisms.

1. What is a System? ⭐

  • Definition: any ordered, interrelated set of things and their attributes, separated from the environment by a boundary, within which energy and matter are transformed, stored and retrieved.
  • P.E. James: "a whole (a person, a state, a culture, a business) which functions as a whole because of the interdependence of its parts".
  • Everyday systems: hydrological system, weather system, cooling system, grading system.
  • System analysis began with 19th-century studies of energy and temperature (thermodynamics), developed further during World War II (operations research, control engineering).
  • System analysis = a mathematical approach that uses techniques from control engineering to study how systems respond to inputs: Input → Throughput (transformation + storage) → Output.
💡
Easy picture: a pressure cooker – inputs (water, rice, heat) → transformation (cooking) + storage (steam) → outputs (cooked rice, whistle = feedback that tells you to lower the heat).

2. Types of Systems ⭐⭐

Type
Exchanges energy?
Exchanges matter?
Example
Isolated
No
No
Only theoretical (whole universe)
Closed
Yes
No
Earth with respect to matter
Open
Yes
Yes
River basin, city, landscape, human body; all real geographical systems are open
  • Earth: an open system for energy (receives solar radiation, re-radiates to space – energy equilibrium) but nearly a closed system for matter (only meteorites, cosmic dust, rare comets come in). ⇒ Resources are finite → need for recycling (about half a landfill – glass, paper, aluminium – is economically recoverable).
  • To be analysed, a system must be treated as closed (we draw a boundary and ignore outside links) – Harvey's example of a firm: we treat the economy around it as unchanging.

Chorley & Kennedy's classification (Physical Geography: A Systems Approach, 1971) – added

Type
Meaning
Example
Morphological
Relationships of form/structure only
Slope angle vs soil depth
Cascading
Chain of subsystems; output of one = input of next
Hydrological cycle, sediment cascade
Process–response
Morphological + cascading linked
Beach profile responding to waves
Control
Human intervention controls key valves
Dam regulating a river

3. General System Theory (GST) ⭐⭐

  • Developed by biologist Ludwig von Bertalanffy (ideas from the 1920s–30s; formal paper 1950; book General System Theory, 1968).
  • An organism must be studied as a system of associated parts; the same idea applies to non-biological systems → a "theory of general models" that unifies the sciences (interdisciplinary).
  • Mesarović: GST is concerned not only with isomorphism and analogy but with a general theory from which properties of various systems can be deduced.
  • In geography: Chorley (1962) – "Geomorphology and General Systems Theory" (open systems in geomorphology); Berry & Chorley urged GST as a basic tool. Leopold & Langbein – entropy and steady state in fluvial systems; B.J.L. Berry (1964) – "Cities as systems within systems of cities"; Woldenberg & Berry – central places and river patterns; Curry – settlements; Haggett (1965) – locational systems; Harvey (1969) – Explanation in Geography; Stoddart (1965) – ecosystem as a geographical principle.
Chorley's (1962) four advantages of system analysis:
  1. Need to study systems rather than isolated phenomena.
  1. Need to identify basic principles governing systems.
  1. Value in arguing from analogies.
  1. Need for general principles covering many systems.

Cybernetics

  • Coined by Norbert Wiener (1948), from Greek kybernetes = steersman/helmsman.
  • Study of regulating and self-regulating mechanisms in nature and technology (e.g. body temperature, thermostat).
  • Stresses interaction between components rather than one-way cause and effect: an impulse travels around the system and returns to its origin. Regulation is precise in nature but defective in human society.

4. Structure of a System

A system = (1) set of elements + (2) set of links between them + (3) links with the environment.
  • Structure = elements + connections; Function = flows along connections; Development = change in structure and function over time.
  • Mathematically: A = {a1, a2 … an}; add the environment a0 → B = {a0, a1 … an}.
  • Element depends on scale: for the world monetary system, countries are elements; for an economy, firms; for a firm, departments; for a department, people (Blalock & Blalock, 1959). A car is an element of the traffic system but is itself a system.
  • Elements are best treated as attributes (variables) of individuals, not the individuals themselves.

5. Links (Relations) between Elements ⭐⭐

Five kinds (Klír & Valach, 1967): series, parallel, feedback, simple compound, complex compound.
Relation
Meaning
Example
Series
A → B, irreversible; classic cause and effect
Irrigation → rice in Punjab (not the reverse); black soil → cotton in the Deccan
Parallel
Two or more elements affect a third, or one affects several
Rainfall and temperature → vegetation
Feedback
An element influences itself, directly or via a chain
Legumes add nitrogen → better legume crops
Compound
Combinations of the above – a "wiring system"
Real landscapes

Feedback types

Negative feedback
Positive feedback
Self-regulating, keeps a steady state (dynamic equilibrium)
Self-reinforcing, change snowballs
Homeostatic / morphostatic
Morphogenetic (system changes form)
e.g. spatial competition reduces excess profits until equilibrium; predator–prey
e.g. technology → population → more industry (exponential growth); ice–albedo feedback; cumulative causation
Scientists fear that suppressing natural negative feedbacks and promoting positive feedbacks (technology-led exponential growth) may lead to crises of pollution, hunger and resource shortage (→ Limits to Growth).

6. Geographical System

  • A system in which one or more important variables are spatial (location, distance, extent, density).
  • Static or adaptive systems are easy to build; dynamic ones are hard because time and space must be combined (time-space models of the Lund school, Hägerstrand).
  • Controlled systems are useful in planning: we can control fertiliser input but not temperature and rainfall → partially controlled systems.
  • Example: world iron ore trade – elements = producing and consuming centres; links = trade routes; function = tonnage moved; development = maps over time.

7. Systems Models in Physical Geography

Hydrological cycle, water balance, surface energy budget, earthquakes and faulting, glacier mass budget, soil profiles, ecosystems, General Circulation Models (GCMs). NASA's GISS GCM correctly predicted ~0.5 °C global cooling after Mt Pinatubo (1991).
NASA's Earth Observing System (EOS) became operational with Terra (1999), Aqua (2002), Aura (2004); today Earth-system models feed IPCC reports (AR6, 2021–23).

8. Criticisms of Systems Analysis & GST

  1. Tied to positivism – ignores normative questions (values, beliefs, attitudes, hopes, fears).
  1. Technically demanding (mathematics) → few active researchers.
  1. Drawing boundaries and identifying elements (especially continuous ones like rainfall) is difficult.
  1. Real systems are open; treating them as closed simplifies too much.
  1. Often more descriptive (a language) than explanatory.

⚡ Quick Revision

  • Father of GST → Ludwig von Bertalanffy (biologist).
  • Cybernetics → Norbert Wiener (1948); meaning "steersman".
  • Earth → open for energy, closed for matter.
  • Negative feedback → homeostatic / morphostatic; positive → morphogenetic.
  • "Cities as systems within systems of cities" → Berry (1964).
  • Systems in geomorphology → Chorley (1962); four system types → Chorley & Kennedy (1971).
  • Irreversible cause-and-effect link → series relation.