Exam pointers: Christaller 1933, Southern Germany (Bavaria), range vs threshold, why hexagons, K = 3 / 4 / 7 (marketing / transport / administrative) and their number sequences, assumptions, Lösch 1940 differences (150 goods, city-rich & city-poor sectors, profit maximisation).
1. Basics ⭐⭐
- Walter Christaller (German geographer), Die zentralen Orte in Süddeutschland (1933); English: Central Places in Southern Germany by C.W. Baskin (1966). Data from southern Germany (Bavaria).
- Explains the number, size, spacing and functions of settlements that act as service (market) centres.
- It is a normative (ideal) and deductive theory; like the rank-size rule, it shows an inverse relation between the size of settlements and their number. Applies to tertiary (service) functions only.
Everyday picture: you buy milk from the shop next door (low order, short range), shoes from the town market (middle order), and a car or heart surgery from a big city (high order, long range). Fewer big cities, many small villages – that's the hierarchy.
2. Fundamental Principles
- Principle of centralisation – everything has a core and periphery (sun in solar system, nucleus in a cell, temple/chaupal in a village). Centralisation is a relationship, not a geometric centre.
- Principle of hierarchy – phenomena are arranged in tiers (state capital → district HQ → tehsil HQ).
3. Six Derived Concepts ⭐⭐
Concept | Meaning |
Central place | Settlement that provides goods and services to surrounding areas. A fair, a weekly market, or a purely mining/manufacturing town is not a central place |
Complementary area (hinterland / market area) | Area served by a central place; larger for higher-order centres |
Central goods and services | Tertiary goods offered at central places (grocery → jewellery, hospitals, universities) |
Range of a good ⭐ | Maximum distance a consumer will travel to buy a good → outer limit of the market area |
Threshold ⭐ | Minimum population / sales needed for a shop selling that good to be viable → inner limit |
Centrality | Importance of a place as a centre = surplus of services it gives to the outside. Christaller measured it by telephones: Z = Tz − Ez (Tg / Eg), where Tz, Ez = telephones and population of the town, Tg, Eg = of the region |
- A good is offered only if range ≥ threshold. Low-order goods: small range, small threshold, bought often (bread, milk). High-order goods: large range, large threshold, bought rarely (jewellery, cars).
- Distance decay: demand falls with distance (e.g. kerosene range ~9 km, cloth ~13 km, radio ~19 km in a classic Indian study).
4. Assumptions ⭐
- Isotropic surface – flat, uniform plain with equal fertility and resources.
- Evenly distributed population with equal purchasing power.
- Equal ease of transport in all directions; cost proportional to distance; one type of transport.
- Consumers buy from the nearest centre (minimise distance); sellers maximise profit (economic man, perfect knowledge).
- No area unserved, none served twice.
Why hexagons? ⭐
- Circles either leave gaps (unserved areas) or overlap (wasteful competition).
- Hexagon is the regular figure closest to a circle that fills the plane without gaps or overlaps (triangles and squares also tile but are farther from a circle and give longer distances).
- Settlements form an equilateral triangular lattice (hamlets about 7 km apart in Christaller's scheme).
5. Three Principles (K-values) ⭐⭐⭐
K = number of lower-order market areas (or centres) served by one higher-order centre, counting itself.
Principle | K | Placement of lower-order centres | Calculation | Number of market areas | New centres at each level | Example |
Marketing | 3 | At the corners (vertices) of the higher hexagon; each shared by 3 higher centres | 1 + 6 × ⅓ = 3 | 1, 3, 9, 27, 81 … | 1, 2, 6, 18, 54, 162, 486 | Rural farming areas; maximises number of centres for consumers (minimum travel) |
Transport (traffic) | 4 | At the mid-points of sides, on main roads; each shared by 2 | 1 + 6 × ½ = 4 | 1, 4, 16, 64 … | 1, 3, 12, 48, 192, 768 | Densely settled areas; minimises road length – most places on straight routes |
Administrative (political) | 7 | Entirely inside the higher hexagon; not shared | 1 + 6 × 1 = 7 | 1, 7, 49, 343 … | 1, 6, 42, 294, 2058, 14406, 1,00,842 | Clear control: India's state → district → tehsil boundaries; sparsely populated areas |
Tip: "Number of market areas" grows as powers of K (K¹, K², K³…); "new centres" at each level = market areas of that level − those of the level above (e.g. K = 4: 4 − 1 = 3, 16 − 4 = 12, 64 − 16 = 48).
Memory trick – "M-T-A = 3-4-7": Market 3, Transport 4, Administration 7. ("My Tea At 3-4-7")
- Christaller's seven orders (smallest to largest): Marktort (M) → Amtsort (A) → Kreisstadt (K) → Bezirksstadt (B) → Gaustadt (G) → Provinzhauptstadt (P) → Landeshauptstadt (L). Spacing grows by √3 for K = 3 (about 7, 12, 21, 36, 62, 108, 186 km).
- Higher-order centres provide all the functions of lower-order ones plus extra ones (nested hierarchy).
- India has a six-level administrative hierarchy: national capital → state capital → district HQ → tehsil town → block HQ → gram panchayat centre (K = 7 roughly).
6. Criticisms ⭐
- Isotropic surface rarely exists.
- Consumers and sellers are not always rational; people are satisficers (behavioural school) and do multi-purpose trips.
- Perfect hexagonal patterns are rarely seen (approximations in Iowa, East Anglia, Bihar plains).
- Fits mainly agricultural regions; modern transport, internet/e-commerce, malls, mobile phones have reduced distance friction.
- Fixed K for the whole system is unrealistic.
- Ignores industry, mining, tourism and other non-central functions; gives a stepped (discrete) city-size distribution, unlike the real continuous one.
- Static; ignores history.
Applications: planning of the Dutch IJsselmeer polders (Noordoostpolder), Lachish region (Israel), Nazi plans in occupied Poland (Christaller himself worked on them); regional planning and service-centre planning in India.
7. Lösch's Location Model (Economic Landscape) ⭐⭐
- August Lösch (German economist), Die räumliche Ordnung der Wirtschaft (1940); English The Economics of Location (1954, Yale).
- First general location theory with emphasis on demand; aim = profit maximisation (largest revenue), not cost minimisation.
How it works
- Flat uniform plain; supply held constant; demand falls as price rises; since price rises with transport cost, demand falls with distance → rotate the demand curve around the producer → a demand cone → circular market area.
- Competition from new producers → circles become hexagons (no overlap, no gaps) and smaller as excess profits are competed away.
- Each good has its own threshold and range → its own hexagon size. Lösch used about 150 goods, giving many networks (the 10 smallest: K = 3, 4, 7, 9, 12, 13, 16, 19, 21, 25).
- Superimpose all nets on one common centre (metropolis) and rotate them to get maximum coincidence → 6 city-rich sectors and 6 city-poor sectors alternating around the metropolis ("Löschian landscape").
Christaller vs Lösch ⭐⭐
Point | Christaller | Lösch |
Year | 1933 | 1940 |
Area | Southern Germany (Bavaria) | Whole Germany (and USA data) |
Approach | Supply side; top-down (from highest order) | Demand side; bottom-up (from lowest order); profit maximisation |
K-value | Fixed (3, 4 or 7) for the system | Variable K; all nets coexist |
Functions | Bundled into orders; higher-order places have all lower functions | Each function separate; a large place need not have all lower functions (specialisation) |
Activities | Only tertiary | Tertiary + manufacturing |
City-size distribution | Stepped hierarchy | Continuous – close to the rank-size rule |
Pattern | Simple nested hexagons | City-rich and city-poor sectors |
Criticisms of Lösch: highly abstract; ignores locational interdependence of factories; over-emphasises demand; overlapping networks are hard to map and understand.
⚡ Quick Revision
- CPT → Christaller, 1933, southern Germany; English 1966 (Baskin).
- Maximum travel distance → range; minimum demand → threshold.
- K = 3 marketing; K = 4 transport; K = 7 administrative.
- K = 4 minimises road length; K = 7 → lower areas wholly within one higher area.
- Lösch → 1940, demand-based, city-rich and city-poor sectors.
- Hexagon → fills space without gaps or overlap; closest to a circle.