Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

3. Population Theories – Malthus, Marx, Demographic Transition, Optimum

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

6 min read5 sections

3. Population Theories – Malthus, Marx, Demographic Transition, Optimum

🎯
Exam pointers: Malthus (1798, GP vs AP, 25-year doubling, positive vs preventive checks, 256 : 9), Marx (surplus value, industrial reserve army, "each mode of production has its own law of population"), DTT (Thompson 1929, Notestein 1945, stages and examples), Optimum population (Cannan, Dalton's formula), Boserup (counter to Malthus).

1. Malthusian Theory (1798) ⭐⭐⭐

  • Thomas Robert Malthus (1766–1834), English clergyman-economist. Book: An Essay on the Principle of Population (1798); revised 2nd edition 1803 added "moral restraint".
  • Based on the experience of West European countries (empirical). Motive humanitarian.

Two postulates

  1. Food is necessary for human existence.
  1. Passion between the sexes is necessary and will remain nearly constant.

Core propositions

Population
Food (subsistence)
Increases in geometric progression: 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32, 64, 128, 256
Increases in arithmetic progression: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9
Doubles every 25 years (if unchecked)
Limited by law of diminishing returns on land
  • After 2 centuries ratio = 256 : 9; after 3 centuries = 4096 : 13; after 2000 years "almost incalculable".
Population doubles every 25 years (1, 2, 4 … 256) while food rises by a fixed amount (1, 2, 3 … 9); the widening gap is closed by positive checks unless preventive checks act first.
Population doubles every 25 years (1, 2, 4 … 256) while food rises by a fixed amount (1, 2, 3 … 9); the widening gap is closed by positive checks unless preventive checks act first.

Checks ⭐

Positive checks (raise death rate – nature's way)
Preventive checks (lower birth rate – man's way)
Wars, famine, diseases/epidemics, floods, droughts, poverty, lack of food
Moral restraint (late marriage, celibacy) and "vice" (adultery, birth control, abortion)
  • Malthus opposed contraception (it would reduce the drive to work hard); preferred postponement of marriage. Wanted the poor to be better paid and educated.
💡
Memory trick: "Positive = Pain (death)"; "Preventive = Prevent birth".

Criticisms

  1. Too pessimistic; ignored technology – Agricultural Revolution, Green Revolution, fertilisers, HYVs raised food faster than population.
  1. Population has rarely doubled every 25 years; doubling time varies with economy and technology.
  1. Confused the desire for sex (biological) with the desire for children (social).
  1. Calamities occur in under-populated areas too – no causal link with overpopulation.
  1. Mixed moral and scientific approaches; a poor prophet – no European country (except perhaps Ireland, potato famine 1845–49) followed his prediction; birth rates fell first in France and Sweden.
  1. Marx: poverty comes from capitalism, not population growth.
  1. Ester Boserup (The Conditions of Agricultural Growth, 1965): population pressure stimulates agricultural intensification – "necessity is the mother of invention" (anti-Malthusian).
Merit: first to link population growth with socio-economic change; started theory-building in population studies. Revived as Neo-Malthusianism (Ehrlich's The Population Bomb, 1968; Club of Rome's Limits to Growth, 1972).

2. Marxian Theory of Population ⭐⭐

  • Karl Marx (1818–1883); Das Kapital Vol. I (1867); with Engels, Communist Manifesto (1848). Philosophy: dialectical / historical materialism.
  • Marx gave no separate population theory; his ideas come from his critique of capitalism.

Key ideas

  1. History = change in modes of production (primitive communism → slavery → feudalism → capitalism → socialism), driven by class struggle between owners (haves) and workers (have-nots).
  1. Employer pays less than the value produced; the difference = surplus value (exchange value − wages) → capital accumulation.
  1. Better machines + growing workers → relative surplus population = "industrial reserve army" of unemployed and underemployed → keeps wages low.
  1. Low wages → high birth and death rates among the poor.
  1. "Every special historic mode of production has its own special laws of population" – so there is no universal (natural) law of population (direct attack on Malthus).
  1. Poverty and misery are not natural but "gifts" of capitalism. Remedy: abolish private property in means of production; under communism all can be employed regardless of population growth.
Malthus
Marx
Overpopulation causes poverty
Capitalism causes poverty and "overpopulation"
Universal natural law
Law varies with mode of production
Remedy: moral restraint
Remedy: socialism / communism

Criticisms

  1. Modern population growth is due mainly to falling death rates (medicine, health care), not low wages.
  1. Population growth does not automatically lower real wages.
  1. Ignores religion, culture, education, attitudes – some rich groups have high fertility.
  1. Over-blames private property.
  1. Relevant mainly to capitalist societies.
  1. Gave little weight to the physical environment.
  1. Arsene Dumont: "social capillarity" – desire to climb the social ladder leads to smaller families. Herbert Spencer: individuation vs reproduction.

3. Demographic Transition Theory (DTT) ⭐⭐⭐

  • Proposed by Warren S. Thompson (1929); named and developed by Frank W. Notestein (1945); C.P. Blacker (1947) gave five stages. Based on Europe, Anglo-America, Australia.
  • Society moves from rural-agrarian-illiterate (high BR, high DR) to urban-industrial-literate (low BR, low DR).
Three hypotheses: (i) mortality falls before fertility; (ii) fertility eventually falls to match mortality; (iii) socio-economic transformation goes along with demographic transformation.
Trewartha: countries are at different stages because of the dual nature of man – biologically same, culturally different.
Stage
Name
Birth rate
Death rate
Growth
Features
Examples (now)
I
High stationary / pre-industrial
High (35+)
High (35+), fluctuating (famine, epidemics)
Very slow
Agrarian, illiterate, large families an asset
No country now; Europe before 1750; a few isolated tribes
II
Early expanding
High (30+)
Falls rapidly
Rapid – population explosion
Health, sanitation, vaccines
Niger, Chad, Mali, Somalia, DR Congo, Afghanistan
III
Late expanding
Falls
Low
Growth slows
Urbanisation, industry, female literacy, family planning
India, Bangladesh, Egypt, Mexico, Indonesia
IV
Low stationary
Low
Low
Very slow / stable
Industrial-urban, high literacy
USA, UK, France, Australia, Sweden
V
Declining
Below death rate
Low but rising (ageing)
Negative
Ageing, below-replacement fertility
Japan, Italy, Germany, South Korea, China (since 2022)
Death rate falls first (stage II), birth rate follows (stage III); the gap between them is natural increase, so total population rises steeply in stages II–III and levels off or falls in IV–V.
Death rate falls first (stage II), birth rate follows (stage III); the gap between them is natural increase, so total population rises steeply in stages II–III and levels off or falls in IV–V.
Present status:
  • India: TFR has fallen to about 2.0 (NFHS-5, 2019–21), i.e. below replacement (2.1); CBR about 19 and CDR about 7 per 1000 (SRS 2021) → late stage III moving towards IV. India became the world's most populous country in 2023 (UN).
  • China: population began declining in 2022; one-child policy ended in 2015 (two-child 2016, three-child 2021).
  • South Korea has the world's lowest TFR (about 0.7).
  • World population crossed 8 billion on 15 Nov 2022 (UN).
  • Stage V = birth rate below death rate → population decline.

Criticisms

  1. Based on Western experience; developing countries differ (faster mortality decline due to imported medicine).
  1. Not predictive; stages are neither sequential nor inevitable (Loschky & Wilcox). China jumped ahead due to its one-child policy (1979).
  1. Does not give the time each stage takes.
  1. Ignores migration; ignores the role of government policy and culture/religion.
  1. Still the best macro-level description of world demographic history.

4. Theory of Optimum Population ⭐

  • Given by Edwin Cannan (1888; Wealth, 1914); developed by Carr-Saunders, Hugh Dalton, Robbins, Sauvy.
  • Optimum population = the size of population at which, with given resources and technology, per capita income/output is maximum.
  • Below optimum → under-population (resources under-used; e.g. Brazil, Kazakhstan, Siberia, Australia, Canada). Above optimum → over-population (law of diminishing returns; per capita output falls).
  • It is dynamic: changes with technology. Pre-colonial Brazil was not under-populated because indigenous people used fewer resources; medieval Central Asian pastoralists over-strained their resources → waves of migration and invasion.
  • Dalton's measure of maladjustment: M = (A − O) / O, where A = actual, O = optimum population. M positive → over-population; negative → under-population; zero → optimum.
  • Link to resources: Zimmermann (1933) – "Resources are not, they become".
  • Criticism: optimum is hard to measure; per capita income is not the only welfare measure; ignores distribution.

⚡ Quick Revision

  • Essay on the Principle of Population → 1798; doubling time → 25 years; 2 centuries → 256 : 9.
  • Moral restraint = preventive check; famine/war = positive check.
  • "Industrial reserve army" and "surplus value" → Marx.
  • "Social capillarity" → Arsene Dumont.
  • DTT → Thompson (1929), Notestein (1945); 5 stages → Blacker (1947).
  • Optimum population → Edwin Cannan; formula → Dalton.
  • Population pressure drives farm innovation → Boserup (1965).