Key points: definitions by major geographers; nature and scope; environmental determinism, possibilism and neo-determinism; naturalisation of humans and humanisation of nature; phases and approaches (regional, spatial, behavioural, welfare/radical, humanistic, post-modern); fields and sub-fields of human geography.
1. Definitions ⭐⭐⭐
Geographer | Definition (in essence) |
Friedrich Ratzel (German; founder of modern human geography – Anthropogeographie, 1882–91) | Human geography is the synthetic study of the relationship between human societies and the earth's surface |
Ellen Churchill Semple (American student of Ratzel) | Human geography is the study of the changing relationship between unresting man and the unstable earth |
Paul Vidal de la Blache (French; father of possibilism) | Human geography offers a new conception of the interrelationships between earth and human beings – a more synthetic knowledge of the physical laws governing our earth and of the relations between the living beings that inhabit it |
Jean Brunhes (French) | Human geography studies all facts in which human activity takes part – occupation of land, houses, roads, fields, mines |
Huntington | Human geography studies the nature and distribution of relationships between geographical environment and human activities |
Memory: Ratzel = Relationship (synthetic study). Semple = Stormy (unresting man, unstable earth). Vidal = View of inter-relationships.
2. Nature of Human Geography
- Studies the inter-relationship between the physical environment and the socio-cultural environment created by humans through mutual interaction.
- Physical elements: landforms, soils, climate, water, natural vegetation, fauna. Human (cultural) elements: houses, villages, cities, roads, railways, industries, farms, ports, items of daily use – the cultural landscape.
- Highly interdisciplinary: links with sociology, anthropology, economics, political science, history, demography, urban planning.
- It is dynamic: the relationship changes with technology.
3. Human–Environment Relationship ⭐⭐⭐
Environmental determinism (naturalisation of humans)
- In early stages of technology, humans adapted to and were controlled by nature: the physical environment was the "Mother Nature" that dictated life, food, dress, houses and even culture.
- Proponents: Hippocrates, Aristotle, Strabo (ancient); Ibn Khaldun (Arab); Montesquieu; Humboldt, Ritter; Ratzel, Ellen Semple (Influences of Geographic Environment, 1911), Ellsworth Huntington (Civilization and Climate, 1915 – climate determines civilisation).
- NCERT example: Benda, a member of the Abujh Maria tribe of Bastar (Chhattisgarh), lives in harmony with the forest, river and animals – naturalisation of humans.
Possibilism (humanisation of nature)
- With better technology, humans create possibilities; nature offers opportunities and humans choose. Signs of humanisation: health resorts on highlands, harbours, sea routes, satellites, fields, orchards, pastures.
- Founder: Vidal de la Blache; developed by Lucien Febvre (who coined the term "possibilism"), Jean Brunhes, Isaiah Bowman, Carl Sauer (cultural landscape).
- Febvre: "There are no necessities, but everywhere possibilities; and man, as master of these possibilities, is the judge of their use."
- NCERT example: Trondheim (Norway) – a town where winters are harsh, but people use technology to live comfortably – humanisation of nature.
Neo-determinism (stop-and-go determinism)
- Given by Griffith Taylor (Australian geographer, 1920s).
- A middle path: humans can conquer nature by obeying it; they can go ahead when nature permits (green signal), slow down (amber) and stop (red signal) – like a traffic light. Humans should not exceed the limits set by nature.
- Basis for today's sustainable development.
Approach | Main idea | Key thinkers |
Determinism | Nature controls humans | Ratzel, Semple, Huntington, Ritter |
Possibilism | Humans choose among possibilities | Vidal de la Blache, Febvre, Brunhes |
Neo-determinism | "Stop-and-go"; middle path | Griffith Taylor |
Probabilism | Some outcomes are more probable than others in a given environment | O. H. K. Spate |
4. Phases and Approaches in Human Geography ⭐⭐
Period | Approach | Broad features |
Early colonial period | Exploration and description | Imperial and trade interests led to discovery of new areas; encyclopaedic descriptions |
Later colonial period | Regional analysis | Detailed descriptions of regions; idea that all regions are parts of a whole |
1930s (inter-war) | Areal differentiation (Richard Hartshorne) | Identifying the uniqueness of each region and how it differs from others |
Late 1950s–1960s | Spatial organisation (Quantitative revolution) | Use of computers, statistical tools, laws of physics to map and analyse human phenomena; models and theories (Schaefer's critique of exceptionalism, 1953) |
1970s | Emergence of humanistic, radical and behavioural schools | Discontent with quantitative revolution's dehumanised approach |
1990s | Post-modernism in geography | Grand generalisations questioned; importance of local context |
Schools of the 1970s
School | Focus | Thinkers |
Welfare / humanistic | Social well-being of people: housing, health, education | (Welfare: David M. Smith); Humanistic: Yi-Fu Tuan (topophilia), Anne Buttimer, Edward Relph – human awareness, agency, consciousness and creativity |
Radical | Uses Marxian theory to explain poverty, deprivation and social inequality; capitalism as cause | David Harvey (Social Justice and the City, 1973), Richard Peet, William Bunge |
Behavioural | Lived experience, perception of space by social categories (ethnicity, race, religion); decision-making | Kirk, Wolpert, Kates, Julian Wolpert; mental maps (Peter Gould) |
5. Fields and Sub-fields of Human Geography
Field | Sub-fields | Allied disciplines |
Social geography | Behavioural, geography of social well-being, geography of leisure, cultural geography, gender geography, historical geography, medical geography | Psychology, welfare economics, sociology, anthropology, women's studies, history, epidemiology |
Urban geography | – | Urban studies and planning |
Political geography | Electoral geography, military geography | Political science, psephology, military science |
Population geography | – | Demography |
Settlement geography | – | Urban and rural planning |
Economic geography | Geography of resources, agriculture, industries, marketing, tourism, international trade | Resource economics, agricultural science, industrial economics, business studies, tourism and travel management, international trade |
⚡ Quick Revision
- Ratzel = father of human geography (Anthropogeographie); Semple = "unresting man and unstable earth".
- Determinism (Ratzel, Semple, Huntington) → possibilism (Vidal de la Blache; term by Febvre) → neo-determinism (Griffith Taylor, stop-and-go) → probabilism (Spate).
- Benda (Abujh Maria) = naturalisation of humans; Trondheim = humanisation of nature.
- Quantitative revolution: late 1950s–60s; humanistic, radical, behavioural: 1970s; post-modernism: 1990s.
- Radical = Marxian (David Harvey); humanistic = Yi-Fu Tuan; areal differentiation = Hartshorne.
📝 Practice MCQs
- Who defined human geography as "the synthetic study of the relationship between human societies and the earth's surface"? (a) Semple (b) Ratzel (c) Vidal de la Blache (d) Huntington
Answer
(b) Ratzel
- "Stop-and-go determinism" was proposed by – (a) Ellen Semple (b) Griffith Taylor (c) Lucien Febvre (d) Carl Sauer
Answer
(b) Griffith Taylor
- The radical school of human geography is based on – (a) positivism (b) Marxian theory (c) phenomenology (d) behaviourism
Answer
(b) Marxian theory
- The term "possibilism" was coined by – (a) Vidal de la Blache (b) Lucien Febvre (c) Jean Brunhes (d) Hartshorne
Answer
(b) Lucien Febvre
- The quantitative revolution in geography took place during – (a) 1920s–30s (b) late 1950s–60s (c) 1970s (d) 1990s
Answer
(b) Late 1950s to the 1960s
- Electoral geography is a sub-field of – (a) social geography (b) political geography (c) economic geography (d) population geography
Answer
(b) Political geography