Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

8. Geopolitical Models – Heartland (Mackinder) & Rimland (Spykman)

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

4 min read4 sections

8. Geopolitical Models – Heartland (Mackinder) & Rimland (Spykman)

🎯
Exam pointers: Mackinder 1904 "The Geographical Pivot of History" (RGS); Pivot area / Heartland; inner (marginal) and outer (insular) crescents; World Island; the famous 1919 dictum; 1943 Midland Ocean & Lenaland; Spykman 1944 Rimland dictum; criticisms; Mahan, Haushofer, Seversky, Cohen.

1. Mackinder's Heartland Theory ⭐⭐⭐

  • Sir Halford John Mackinder (1861–1947), British geographer: first Reader in Geography at Oxford (1887), Director of the London School of Economics (1903–08), Member of Parliament. Founder of modern British geography and of geopolitics.
  • Paper: "The Geographical Pivot of History", read at the Royal Geographical Society, London, January 1904 (published in Geographical Journal).
  • Saw history as a struggle between land power and sea power; the Columbian epoch of sea power (last 400 years) was ending, and railways would give the advantage to land power.

World structure

  • World Island = Europe + Asia + Africa: about two-thirds of the world's land and seven-eighths of its population. The Americas, Australia, Britain and Japan = outlying islands.
Tier
Area
Features
1. Pivot Area / Heartland
Inner Eurasia – from the Volga to eastern Siberia, from the Himalaya–Hindu Kush–Elburz–Caucasus–Altai–Tien Shan to the Arctic
Interior and Arctic drainage – not reachable by sea power → a natural fortress. Weak only in the south-west – the East European steppe corridor between the Urals and the Caspian
2. Inner or Marginal Crescent
Europe west of the Urals, SW Asia outside Iran, South Asia, SE Asia, most of China
Coastlands draining into navigable seas
3. Outer or Insular Crescent
North & South America, Africa south of the Sahara, Australia, Britain, Japan
Fully insular, sea-based
Same world map, two readings: Mackinder makes the inner Heartland (entered through East Europe) the key; Spykman makes the surrounding coastal Rimland the key.
Same world map, two readings: Mackinder makes the inner Heartland (entered through East Europe) the key; Spykman makes the surrounding coastal Rimland the key.

The famous dictum (1919) ⭐⭐⭐

📜
Who rules East Europe commands the Heartland; Who rules the Heartland commands the World-Island; Who rules the World-Island commands the World.
💡
Memory chain: E → H → W-I → W (East Europe → Heartland → World-Island → World). Spykman's chain: R → E → W (Rimland → Eurasia → World).

Three versions

Year
Work
Changes
1904
"The Geographical Pivot of History"
Pivot area; World Island = Old World north of the Sahara
1919
Democratic Ideals and Reality
Renamed pivot as Heartland; enlarged into a "Strategic Heartland" (added Baltic, middle and lower Danube, Black Sea, Asia Minor, Armenia, Persia, Tibet, Mongolia); World Island now includes all of Africa; East Europe as the key → need for buffer states between Germany and Russia (Versailles)
1943
"The Round World and the Winning of the Peace" (Foreign Affairs)
Added the Midland Ocean (North Atlantic + eastern USA + western Europe) as a counterweight to the Heartland; excluded land east of the Yenisei (called Lenaland); a girdle of deserts and wilderness around the two power centres

Criticisms ⭐

  1. Deterministic – history is not merely land vs sea power.
  1. Equated area with power; over-rated the Heartland's resources – much of it is cold, dry wasteland with small population and arable land.
  1. Extreme climate and huge distances; under-estimated difficulties of building railways there.
  1. Ignored air power and later missiles and nuclear weapons – the "fortress" is open to air attack.
  1. Used the Mercator projection, which exaggerates the Arctic; in reality North America and Eurasia face each other across the Arctic – the "Mediterranean of modern times" (shortest air routes).
  1. Over-emphasised physical geography; ignored technology, economy, ideology, alliances.
  1. Yet the theory influenced the Cold War (USSR controlled the Heartland) and German Geopolitik (Haushofer). After WWII "geopolitics migrated from Germany to North America".

2. Spykman's Rimland Theory ⭐⭐⭐

  • Nicholas John Spykman (1893–1943), Dutch-American political scientist at Yale. Books: America's Strategy in World Politics (1942) and The Geography of the Peace (1944, published after his death).
  • Same map as Mackinder, but argued the Rimland (Mackinder's inner/marginal crescent) is more important than the Heartland.
  • Rimland = coastal Eurasia: Western Europe, Middle East, South Asia, South-East Asia, China and the Far East – has most of the population, resources, industry and both land and sea access (amphibious buffer zone).
📜
Who controls the Rimland rules Eurasia; Who rules Eurasia controls the destinies of the world.
  • Viewed from the USA: America is encircled by Eurasia and Africa; US policy must prevent any single power uniting the Rimland. Stressed sea power and maritime mobility, and a balance of power / collective security.
  • The Heartland is less important because the agricultural and industrial core of Russia lies west of the Urals, not in Siberia.
  • Basis of US containment policy (George Kennan, 1947): NATO (1949), SEATO (South-East Asia Treaty Organization, 1954), CENTO (Central Treaty Organization; Baghdad Pact, 1955), and the domino theory (if one Rimland country falls to communism, neighbours follow).
  • Criticisms: nuclear weapons, missiles and air power reduce the role of location; ignores the UN and international law; territorial expansion is no longer allowed; today's power is economic, not colonial; Ratzel's state-as-organism is outdated.

Heartland vs Rimland ⭐

ㅤ
Mackinder
Spykman
Key area
Heartland (inner Eurasia)
Rimland (coastal Eurasia)
Power stressed
Land power
Sea + land (amphibious)
Year
1904/1919/1943
1944
Viewpoint
British
American

3. Other Geopolitical Models (added)

Thinker
Year
Idea
Alfred T. Mahan
The Influence of Sea Power upon History, 1890
Sea power decides world power (navies, bases, merchant fleet)
Friedrich Ratzel
1897
State as a living organism; Lebensraum (living space)
Rudolf Kjellén
1899
Coined the word "geopolitics"
Karl Haushofer
1920s–30s, Zeitschrift für Geopolitik (1924)
German Geopolitik; pan-regions; misused by Nazis
Alexander de Seversky
Air Power: Key to Survival, 1950
Air power; polar (azimuthal) projection; area of decision
Saul B. Cohen
1963
Two geostrategic realms (Trade-dependent Maritime vs Eurasian Continental), geopolitical regions and shatterbelts (Middle East, SE Asia)

⚡ Quick Revision

  • "The Geographical Pivot of History" → Mackinder, 1904, RGS.
  • "Democratic Ideals and Reality" → 1919 (dictum).
  • Midland Ocean & Lenaland → 1943.
  • "The Geography of the Peace" → Spykman, 1944.
  • Rimland = Mackinder's inner/marginal crescent.
  • Sea power → Mahan; air power → Seversky; shatterbelts → Cohen.