Exam pointers: Weber 1909 least-cost theory, locational triangle, material index, ubiquitous vs localised, pure vs gross materials, isotims, isodapanes, critical isodapane, labour & agglomeration deviation · Isard's transformation line · D.M. Smith's spatial margins and most profitable location · Hoover, Lösch, Greenhut, Pred · the four Industrial Revolutions.
Introduction – Searching for Order in Industrial Location ⭐
- Since the 1950s industrial geography moved from description of case studies to theory (quantitative revolution): theories explain present locations and predict good sites for the future.
- Is industry random or ordered? It is ordered: factories cluster in certain latitudes and belts, and the same industry takes similar sites in different countries.
- Geographers mostly worked inductively (from case studies to general conclusions); economists worked deductively (state assumptions → deduce conclusions).
Thompson's concentration theory – hierarchy of industrial concentrations
J.H. Thompson suggested that industrial clustering is so regular that a concentration theory can be built, with a hierarchy based on the amount and density of manufacturing, function and linkage:
- Agglomeration theory: manufacturing in conurbations grows as a country develops, and very large urban systems grow larger – until the penalties of congestion balance the benefits and dispersal begins.
- Typical locations: oil refineries on coastal / waterway sites (Western Europe, Japan), recently also inland, market-oriented, pipeline-fed sites (Germany). "Port industries" = flour milling, shipbuilding, sugar refining, vegetable-oil refining (imported bulky raw materials = break-of-bulk).
The optimum location concept ⭐
- Each factory is assumed to have one "best" (optimum) location = the place of maximum profit (profit = revenue − cost). It rarely exists in a changing world but serves as a standard to measure reality.
- Problems: (1) hard to find – long-term vs short-term profit may need different sites, and there are too many variables; (2) decisions may not be profit-maximising – governments pursue social goals (jobs), and people have non-money goals.
School | Holds constant | Varies | Optimum = | Main thinker |
Least-cost | Revenue (demand, price) | Costs (transport + processing: labour, power, capital) | Lowest total cost | Weber |
Maximum-revenue | Costs | Demand / revenue | Largest sales area | Hotelling, Lösch |
Maximum-profit / margins | — | Both | Biggest gap between revenue and cost; any site within the margins is profitable | Greenhut, Isard, D.M. Smith |
Behavioural | — | Information and ability of decision-makers | "Satisfactory" site | Pred |
Note: a low-labour-cost area will not attract oil refining (small labour share); high wages + cheap power will not attract textiles (labour-heavy). Cost structure of the industry matters.
1. Weber's Least-Cost Theory ⭐⭐⭐
- Alfred Weber (1868–1958), German economist (brother of sociologist Max Weber).
- Über den Standort der Industrien (1909); English: Alfred Weber's Theory of the Location of Industries, translated by C.J. Friedrich (1929).
- Called the least-cost (or least transport cost) theory; the most influential single work on industrial location.
Objectives
- Find the minimum-cost location.
- Show that transport cost is the main factor.
- Show that this holds whatever the social or political system (universal).
Assumptions
- Isolated, uniform country/region (isotropic) – same climate, culture, technology.
- Single product; market and raw-material locations are known and fixed.
- Labour is immobile, available in unlimited quantity at fixed wages at certain places.
- Transport cost depends only on weight and distance, same in all directions.
- Perfect competition; unlimited demand at a fixed price → least-cost site = most profitable.
- Producers are rational (economic men).
Classification of raw materials ⭐⭐
Basis | Type | Meaning | Example | Location pull |
Availability | Ubiquitous | Found everywhere | Water, air, clay, sand | Pull to market |
ㅤ | Localised | Found at particular places | Iron ore, coal, bauxite | Pull to source if weight-losing |
Weight change | Pure | Whole weight enters the product | Cotton yarn for weaving, gold | Market or anywhere (footloose) |
ㅤ | Gross / impure (weight-losing) | Loses weight in processing | Iron ore, coal, sugarcane, copper ore | Pull to raw material |
Material Index and Locational Weight ⭐⭐⭐
MI | Meaning | Location | Example |
MI > 1 | Weight-losing | Raw-material site | Iron & steel, sugar, cement, copper smelting |
MI < 1 | Weight-gaining (ubiquities added) | Market | Soft drinks, bakery, beer, furniture |
MI = 1 | Pure material | Anywhere between (footloose) | Electronics assembly, cotton weaving from yarn |
Three location factors
- Transport cost – general (regional) factor; the primary one.
- Labour cost – general (regional) factor; may deviate the site.
- Agglomeration / deglomeration – local factor; may deviate the site.
Step 1 – Least transport cost point: the Locational Triangle ⭐
- Linear case (one raw material + market): factory at the market, at the source, or in between, depending on weight loss.
- Non-linear case (two localised materials M1, M2 + market C) = Weber's locational triangle. Each corner exerts a "pull" equal to the weight to be moved (Varignon's frame / mechanical model). The least transport cost point (P) is where the total ton-km is minimum.
- If one material is ubiquitous and the other localised and impure → factory at the localised material. If both are pure → at the market.
Worked example (equilateral triangle, 100 km sides; 2 t of each material per 1 t of product; Rs 1 per t-km):
Factory at | Calculation | Total |
Raw material 1 | (2 × 100) + (1 × 100) | Rs 300 |
Raw material 2 | (2 × 100) + (1 × 100) | Rs 300 |
Market | (2 × 100) + (2 × 100) | Rs 400 |
Intermediate point I (midway between M1 and M2) | (2 × 50) + (2 × 50) + (1 × 86.6) | Rs 286.6 ← least |
Weight-losing vs weight-gaining in the triangle:
- Weight-losing (e.g. iron smelting): 2 t of M1 + 2 t of M2 → 1 t of product → P is pulled towards the raw-material corners.
- Weight-gaining (e.g. baking): 1 t of M1 + 1 t of M2 → 2 t of product (water, a ubiquity, is added) → P is pulled to the market.
- Only localised materials pull; ubiquitous ones have no locational effect.
Step 2 – Labour deviation: Isotims and Isodapanes ⭐⭐⭐
Term | Meaning |
Isotim | Line joining places of equal transport cost of one raw material (or of the product) from its source/market (concentric circles) |
Isodapane | Line joining places of equal total transport cost (all materials + product), i.e. equal additional cost over the least transport cost point |
Critical isodapane | The isodapane where the extra transport cost = the saving in labour cost. A cheap-labour site inside it is worth moving to; outside it is not |
- Industries may deviate from the least transport cost point to a cheap-labour site if labour saving > extra transport cost. Isodapanes measure that extra cost.
- Example: least transport point cost Rs 400 + labour Rs 500 = Rs 900; cheap-labour site: transport Rs 400 + extra Rs 120 + labour Rs 250 = Rs 770 → move.
- Labour coefficient = labour cost per unit of locational weight; high coefficient → labour orientation.
- Weber expected labour to grow in importance: better transport makes transport cost per km cheaper, so isodapanes spread farther apart, while wages rise relative to other costs → more industries can afford to move to cheap labour.
Step 3 – Agglomeration
- Firms gain external economies (shared services, skilled labour, suppliers) by clustering. If several firms' critical isodapanes overlap, they can all move to the overlap area and save (e.g. Re 1 per unit) as long as extra transport cost is less than the saving.
- Deglomeration: high land rent, congestion push firms out.
Criticisms of Weber
- Ignores demand; assumes fixed price and unlimited market (Lösch criticised this).
- Transport cost is not proportional to distance (tapering freight rates, terminal costs); finished goods cost more to carry than raw materials.
- Labour is mobile, wages are not fixed.
- Ignores land cost/rent in agglomerations, historical inertia, government policy, subsidies, entrepreneurs' personal choice.
- Perfect competition is unreal.
- Fits 19th-century heavy industry; less valid for footloose, high-tech industries.
Support: Isard's study of the US steel industry and Wilfred Smith's study of weight-losing industries in Britain (1955) supported many of Weber's conclusions.
2. Other Industrial Location Theories ⭐⭐
Theorist | Work | Key idea |
Tord Palander | 1935 | Refined isodapanes, competition and market areas |
Edgar M. Hoover | Location Theory and the Shoe and Leather Industries (1937); The Location of Economic Activity (1948) | Transport costs = terminal (fixed) + line-haul costs → tapering freight rates; break-of-bulk / transhipment points (ports) are cheap locations; procurement vs distribution costs |
August Lösch | 1940 / 1954 | Profit (revenue) maximisation; demand cones; hexagonal market areas |
Melvin Greenhut | Plant Location in Theory and Practice (1956) | Combines cost and demand; adds personal factors |
Walter Isard ⭐ | Location and Space-Economy (1956); father of Regional Science | Substitution principle – location is chosen by substituting among transport inputs. Transformation line = all combinations of distances from two sources (or transport inputs between two locations) for a given output – shows the spatial trade-off / substitution possibilities; its tangency with the lowest iso-outlay line gives the optimum |
E.M. Rawstron | 1958 | Introduced spatial margins of profitability |
David M. Smith ⭐ | 1966 paper; Industrial Location: An Economic Geographical Analysis (1971) | Space-cost curve • space-revenue curve. Where total cost = total revenue are the spatial margins of profitability; any site inside is profitable (allows sub-optimal, behavioural choices). The most profitable (optimum) location = where total revenue exceeds total cost by the greatest amount |
Allan Pred | Behaviour and Location (1967, 1969) | Behavioural matrix: decision depends on quantity/quality of information × ability to use it; most firms are satisficers, not optimisers |
Smith's "simplified real-world model" | 1971 | Cost and revenue both vary over space; profit = TR − TC |
One-line ladder: Weber = least cost → Lösch = max revenue → Greenhut/Smith = max profit (cost + revenue) → Pred = behaviour (information) → Isard = substitution (regional science).
Maximum-revenue school: Hotelling's ice-cream sellers ⭐
- Weber held demand constant; to bring demand in, the maximum-revenue school studies locational interdependence – one firm's location affects, and is affected by, its competitors'.
- Harold Hotelling (1929): two ice-cream sellers on a 1-mile beach, same product and price, buyers evenly spread and going to the nearest seller.
- Best for buyers: sellers at the quartiles (¼ and ¾ mile) – each gets half the beach.
- But A moves towards the middle to steal B's customers; B does the same → the stable result is both back to back at the centre → explains clustering of competing firms ("Hotelling's law" / principle of minimum differentiation).
- If buyers will not walk more than ¼ mile, the quartiles stay stable (demand is elastic with distance).
- With different brands, the well-known brand wins more; the unknown one must cut price at the centre or move back to a quartile.
→ Maximum revenue depends on price, transport cost and substitution, which decide concentration or dispersal.
Lösch's demand cone: demand falls as price (= transport cost) rises with distance; rotating the demand curve around the production point gives a cone, whose volume = total sales; competition turns circles into smaller hexagons (see the central place page). Criticised for over-stressing demand and ignoring interdependence of plants; attempts to combine cost and demand by Greenhut and Isard were only partly successful – there is still no single accepted location theory.
Smith's spatial margins – three cases ⭐⭐
Case | Held constant | Curve | Optimum O |
(a) | Demand → price equal everywhere | V-shaped space-cost curve | Least-cost point |
(b) | Costs | Λ-shaped space-revenue curve | Maximum-revenue point |
(c) | Nothing (real world) | Both vary | Point of greatest (revenue − cost) |
- Ma–Mb = spatial margins to profitability: profit is possible anywhere between them.
- Steep curves → narrow margins → industry must concentrate; gentle curves → wide margins → industry can disperse.
- Only one firm can occupy the maximum-profit point, so most real firms are in sub-optimal but still profitable locations → this led to behavioural studies.
Behavioural approach: sub-optimal locations ⭐⭐
Real decision-makers are not "economic men" with perfect knowledge. Two explanations:
(1) Man is an optimiser with limits – explained by Allan Pred's behavioural matrix (1967): position depends on the quantity and quality of information and the ability to use it.
Industrialist | Information | Ability | Result |
1 | Good | Good | At the optimum – right decision |
2 | Poor | Poor | Near an optimum by luck |
3 | Poor | Poor | Unlucky – outside the margin, loss, will close |
4 | Good | Poor | Profit, but less than possible |
5 | Poor | Good | Profit, but less than possible |
6 | Average | Average | Steady profit |
(2) Man is a satisficer – accepts a satisfactory site, not the maximum-profit one (H.A. Simon's idea):
- Maximum profit cannot be measured in advance; firms are happy to beat competitors → profit is relative.
- People want non-money rewards → psychic income (pleasant climate, living and working conditions) – e.g. growth of industry in the sunny south-western USA (Sun Belt) after 1945; firms' reluctance to go to northern England despite subsidies.
- Counter-view: satisficers may simply be imperfect optimisers with several goals (psychic income is another form of profit).
Other influences: corporate decisions by large multi-plant firms (best for the company network, not for one plant); governments choose sub-optimal sites for social, political or strategic reasons (defence relocation of US aircraft plants; reducing unemployment in UK regions); in planned economies, ideology vs profit; cost–benefit analysis weighs social gains and losses, not just money.
Conclusion: emphasis has shifted from finding the single optimum point to finding the margins of profitable location and explaining deviations through decision-making behaviour.
Diagrams: Smith and Isard
3. Industrial Revolutions ⭐
Revolution | Period | Feature |
1st | ~1760–1840 (Britain) | Water and steam power for mechanisation; textiles, iron, coal |
2nd | ~1870–1914 | Electric power, steel, oil, mass production, assembly line (Ford 1913) |
3rd | 1960s/70s–2000s | Electronics, IT, computers, automation (digital revolution) |
4th (Industry 4.0) | 2010s– (term by Klaus Schwab, WEF, 2016) | Fusion of digital, physical and biological systems – AI, IoT, robotics, 3-D printing, biotech |
Industry 5.0 | EU concept, 2021 | Human-centric, sustainable, resilient industry |
4. Major Industrial Regions often linked with location theory
- Ruhr (Germany) – coal → iron & steel (raw-material orientation). Lorraine (France) – iron ore (minette). Pittsburgh – coal-based steel; Lake Michigan region – Chicago, Gary (steel at break-of-bulk point where ore by lake meets coal by rail – Hoover's principle).
- Manchurian (NE China) triangle – Anshan (steel), Fushun (coal), Shenyang/Mukden.
- India: Jamshedpur, Bhilai, Rourkela, Bokaro – near coal and iron ore (MI > 1).
- Aluminium – highly energy-intensive, so it locates near cheap power (hydro-electricity: Norway, Canada, Iceland; Hirakud, Renukoot in India).
⚡ Quick Revision
- Least-cost theory → Alfred Weber, 1909; English 1929.
- MI > 1 → raw material; MI < 1 → market; = 1 → footloose.
- Equal cost of one material → isotim; equal total cost → isodapane; transport loss = labour gain → critical isodapane.
- Transformation line → Isard (1956).
- Spatial margins of profitability → Rawstron (1958), D.M. Smith (1966/71); optimum = max (TR − TC).
- Behavioural matrix → Pred (1967).
- Tapering freight rates, break-of-bulk → Hoover.
- 4th Industrial Revolution term → Klaus Schwab (WEF).
- Hierarchy of industrial concentrations (plant → district → central place → urban system → zone → belt) → J.H. Thompson.
- Ice-cream sellers on a beach (locational interdependence) → Hotelling (1929); stable result = back to back at the centre.
- V-shaped space-cost curve (demand constant) and Λ-shaped space-revenue curve (cost constant) → D.M. Smith.
- Psychic income, satisficer → behavioural school; Sun Belt example.
- Port industries → flour milling, shipbuilding, sugar and vegetable-oil refining.