Quiz20

Geography notes

Notes · Geography

6. Industrial Location Theories – Weber, Isard, Smith, Hoover, Lösch, Pred

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

11 min read6 sections

6. Industrial Location Theories – Weber, Isard, Smith, Hoover, Lösch, Pred

🎯
Exam pointers: Weber 1909 least-cost theory, locational triangle, material index, ubiquitous vs localised, pure vs gross materials, isotims, isodapanes, critical isodapane, labour & agglomeration deviation · Isard's transformation line · D.M. Smith's spatial margins and most profitable location · Hoover, Lösch, Greenhut, Pred · the four Industrial Revolutions.

Introduction – Searching for Order in Industrial Location ⭐

  • Since the 1950s industrial geography moved from description of case studies to theory (quantitative revolution): theories explain present locations and predict good sites for the future.
  • Is industry random or ordered? It is ordered: factories cluster in certain latitudes and belts, and the same industry takes similar sites in different countries.
  • Geographers mostly worked inductively (from case studies to general conclusions); economists worked deductively (state assumptions → deduce conclusions).

Thompson's concentration theory – hierarchy of industrial concentrations

J.H. Thompson suggested that industrial clustering is so regular that a concentration theory can be built, with a hierarchy based on the amount and density of manufacturing, function and linkage:
  • Agglomeration theory: manufacturing in conurbations grows as a country develops, and very large urban systems grow larger – until the penalties of congestion balance the benefits and dispersal begins.
  • Typical locations: oil refineries on coastal / waterway sites (Western Europe, Japan), recently also inland, market-oriented, pipeline-fed sites (Germany). "Port industries" = flour milling, shipbuilding, sugar refining, vegetable-oil refining (imported bulky raw materials = break-of-bulk).

The optimum location concept ⭐

  • Each factory is assumed to have one "best" (optimum) location = the place of maximum profit (profit = revenue − cost). It rarely exists in a changing world but serves as a standard to measure reality.
  • Problems: (1) hard to find – long-term vs short-term profit may need different sites, and there are too many variables; (2) decisions may not be profit-maximising – governments pursue social goals (jobs), and people have non-money goals.
School
Holds constant
Varies
Optimum =
Main thinker
Least-cost
Revenue (demand, price)
Costs (transport + processing: labour, power, capital)
Lowest total cost
Weber
Maximum-revenue
Costs
Demand / revenue
Largest sales area
Hotelling, Lösch
Maximum-profit / margins
—
Both
Biggest gap between revenue and cost; any site within the margins is profitable
Greenhut, Isard, D.M. Smith
Behavioural
—
Information and ability of decision-makers
"Satisfactory" site
Pred
Note: a low-labour-cost area will not attract oil refining (small labour share); high wages + cheap power will not attract textiles (labour-heavy). Cost structure of the industry matters.

1. Weber's Least-Cost Theory ⭐⭐⭐

  • Alfred Weber (1868–1958), German economist (brother of sociologist Max Weber).
  • Über den Standort der Industrien (1909); English: Alfred Weber's Theory of the Location of Industries, translated by C.J. Friedrich (1929).
  • Called the least-cost (or least transport cost) theory; the most influential single work on industrial location.

Objectives

  1. Find the minimum-cost location.
  1. Show that transport cost is the main factor.
  1. Show that this holds whatever the social or political system (universal).

Assumptions

  1. Isolated, uniform country/region (isotropic) – same climate, culture, technology.
  1. Single product; market and raw-material locations are known and fixed.
  1. Labour is immobile, available in unlimited quantity at fixed wages at certain places.
  1. Transport cost depends only on weight and distance, same in all directions.
  1. Perfect competition; unlimited demand at a fixed price → least-cost site = most profitable.
  1. Producers are rational (economic men).

Classification of raw materials ⭐⭐

Basis
Type
Meaning
Example
Location pull
Availability
Ubiquitous
Found everywhere
Water, air, clay, sand
Pull to market
ㅤ
Localised
Found at particular places
Iron ore, coal, bauxite
Pull to source if weight-losing
Weight change
Pure
Whole weight enters the product
Cotton yarn for weaving, gold
Market or anywhere (footloose)
ㅤ
Gross / impure (weight-losing)
Loses weight in processing
Iron ore, coal, sugarcane, copper ore
Pull to raw material

Material Index and Locational Weight ⭐⭐⭐

MI
Meaning
Location
Example
MI > 1
Weight-losing
Raw-material site
Iron & steel, sugar, cement, copper smelting
MI < 1
Weight-gaining (ubiquities added)
Market
Soft drinks, bakery, beer, furniture
MI = 1
Pure material
Anywhere between (footloose)
Electronics assembly, cotton weaving from yarn

Three location factors

  1. Transport cost – general (regional) factor; the primary one.
  1. Labour cost – general (regional) factor; may deviate the site.
  1. Agglomeration / deglomeration – local factor; may deviate the site.

Step 1 – Least transport cost point: the Locational Triangle ⭐

Each corner of the triangle pulls the factory in proportion to the weight to be carried from or to it; the balance point P is the least transport cost location. The material index decides which pull wins.
Each corner of the triangle pulls the factory in proportion to the weight to be carried from or to it; the balance point P is the least transport cost location. The material index decides which pull wins.
  • Linear case (one raw material + market): factory at the market, at the source, or in between, depending on weight loss.
  • Non-linear case (two localised materials M1, M2 + market C) = Weber's locational triangle. Each corner exerts a "pull" equal to the weight to be moved (Varignon's frame / mechanical model). The least transport cost point (P) is where the total ton-km is minimum.
  • If one material is ubiquitous and the other localised and impure → factory at the localised material. If both are pure → at the market.
Worked example (equilateral triangle, 100 km sides; 2 t of each material per 1 t of product; Rs 1 per t-km):
Factory at
Calculation
Total
Raw material 1
(2 × 100) + (1 × 100)
Rs 300
Raw material 2
(2 × 100) + (1 × 100)
Rs 300
Market
(2 × 100) + (2 × 100)
Rs 400
Intermediate point I (midway between M1 and M2)
(2 × 50) + (2 × 50) + (1 × 86.6)
Rs 286.6 ← least
Weight-losing vs weight-gaining in the triangle:
  • Weight-losing (e.g. iron smelting): 2 t of M1 + 2 t of M2 → 1 t of product → P is pulled towards the raw-material corners.
  • Weight-gaining (e.g. baking): 1 t of M1 + 1 t of M2 → 2 t of product (water, a ubiquity, is added) → P is pulled to the market.
  • Only localised materials pull; ubiquitous ones have no locational effect.

Step 2 – Labour deviation: Isotims and Isodapanes ⭐⭐⭐

Isotims are circles of equal cost around each source; isodapanes join points of equal extra total cost. A cheap-labour site inside the critical isodapane is worth moving to; one outside is not.
Isotims are circles of equal cost around each source; isodapanes join points of equal extra total cost. A cheap-labour site inside the critical isodapane is worth moving to; one outside is not.
Term
Meaning
Isotim
Line joining places of equal transport cost of one raw material (or of the product) from its source/market (concentric circles)
Isodapane
Line joining places of equal total transport cost (all materials + product), i.e. equal additional cost over the least transport cost point
Critical isodapane
The isodapane where the extra transport cost = the saving in labour cost. A cheap-labour site inside it is worth moving to; outside it is not
  • Industries may deviate from the least transport cost point to a cheap-labour site if labour saving > extra transport cost. Isodapanes measure that extra cost.
  • Example: least transport point cost Rs 400 + labour Rs 500 = Rs 900; cheap-labour site: transport Rs 400 + extra Rs 120 + labour Rs 250 = Rs 770 → move.
  • Labour coefficient = labour cost per unit of locational weight; high coefficient → labour orientation.
  • Weber expected labour to grow in importance: better transport makes transport cost per km cheaper, so isodapanes spread farther apart, while wages rise relative to other costs → more industries can afford to move to cheap labour.

Step 3 – Agglomeration

  • Firms gain external economies (shared services, skilled labour, suppliers) by clustering. If several firms' critical isodapanes overlap, they can all move to the overlap area and save (e.g. Re 1 per unit) as long as extra transport cost is less than the saving.
  • Deglomeration: high land rent, congestion push firms out.

Criticisms of Weber

  1. Ignores demand; assumes fixed price and unlimited market (Lösch criticised this).
  1. Transport cost is not proportional to distance (tapering freight rates, terminal costs); finished goods cost more to carry than raw materials.
  1. Labour is mobile, wages are not fixed.
  1. Ignores land cost/rent in agglomerations, historical inertia, government policy, subsidies, entrepreneurs' personal choice.
  1. Perfect competition is unreal.
  1. Fits 19th-century heavy industry; less valid for footloose, high-tech industries.
Support: Isard's study of the US steel industry and Wilfred Smith's study of weight-losing industries in Britain (1955) supported many of Weber's conclusions.

2. Other Industrial Location Theories ⭐⭐

Theorist
Work
Key idea
Tord Palander
1935
Refined isodapanes, competition and market areas
Edgar M. Hoover
Location Theory and the Shoe and Leather Industries (1937); The Location of Economic Activity (1948)
Transport costs = terminal (fixed) + line-haul costs → tapering freight rates; break-of-bulk / transhipment points (ports) are cheap locations; procurement vs distribution costs
August Lösch
1940 / 1954
Profit (revenue) maximisation; demand cones; hexagonal market areas
Melvin Greenhut
Plant Location in Theory and Practice (1956)
Combines cost and demand; adds personal factors
Walter Isard ⭐
Location and Space-Economy (1956); father of Regional Science
Substitution principle – location is chosen by substituting among transport inputs. Transformation line = all combinations of distances from two sources (or transport inputs between two locations) for a given output – shows the spatial trade-off / substitution possibilities; its tangency with the lowest iso-outlay line gives the optimum
E.M. Rawstron
1958
Introduced spatial margins of profitability
David M. Smith ⭐
1966 paper; Industrial Location: An Economic Geographical Analysis (1971)
Space-cost curve • space-revenue curve. Where total cost = total revenue are the spatial margins of profitability; any site inside is profitable (allows sub-optimal, behavioural choices). The most profitable (optimum) location = where total revenue exceeds total cost by the greatest amount
Allan Pred
Behaviour and Location (1967, 1969)
Behavioural matrix: decision depends on quantity/quality of information × ability to use it; most firms are satisficers, not optimisers
Smith's "simplified real-world model"
1971
Cost and revenue both vary over space; profit = TR − TC
💡
One-line ladder: Weber = least cost → Lösch = max revenue → Greenhut/Smith = max profit (cost + revenue) → Pred = behaviour (information) → Isard = substitution (regional science).

Maximum-revenue school: Hotelling's ice-cream sellers ⭐

  • Weber held demand constant; to bring demand in, the maximum-revenue school studies locational interdependence – one firm's location affects, and is affected by, its competitors'.
  • Harold Hotelling (1929): two ice-cream sellers on a 1-mile beach, same product and price, buyers evenly spread and going to the nearest seller.
Starting at the quartiles, each seller moves inward to capture the other's customers until both stand back to back at the centre.
Starting at the quartiles, each seller moves inward to capture the other's customers until both stand back to back at the centre.
  1. Best for buyers: sellers at the quartiles (¼ and ¾ mile) – each gets half the beach.
  1. But A moves towards the middle to steal B's customers; B does the same → the stable result is both back to back at the centre → explains clustering of competing firms ("Hotelling's law" / principle of minimum differentiation).
  1. If buyers will not walk more than ¼ mile, the quartiles stay stable (demand is elastic with distance).
  1. With different brands, the well-known brand wins more; the unknown one must cut price at the centre or move back to a quartile.
→ Maximum revenue depends on price, transport cost and substitution, which decide concentration or dispersal.
Lösch's demand cone: demand falls as price (= transport cost) rises with distance; rotating the demand curve around the production point gives a cone, whose volume = total sales; competition turns circles into smaller hexagons (see the central place page). Criticised for over-stressing demand and ignoring interdependence of plants; attempts to combine cost and demand by Greenhut and Isard were only partly successful – there is still no single accepted location theory.

Smith's spatial margins – three cases ⭐⭐

(a) Price flat, cost V-shaped: optimum at least cost. (b) Cost flat, revenue Λ-shaped: optimum at maximum revenue. (c) Both vary: the maximum profit can lie at the least-cost point even though revenue peaks elsewhere.
(a) Price flat, cost V-shaped: optimum at least cost. (b) Cost flat, revenue Λ-shaped: optimum at maximum revenue. (c) Both vary: the maximum profit can lie at the least-cost point even though revenue peaks elsewhere.
Case
Held constant
Curve
Optimum O
(a)
Demand → price equal everywhere
V-shaped space-cost curve
Least-cost point
(b)
Costs
Λ-shaped space-revenue curve
Maximum-revenue point
(c)
Nothing (real world)
Both vary
Point of greatest (revenue − cost)
  • Ma–Mb = spatial margins to profitability: profit is possible anywhere between them.
  • Steep curves → narrow margins → industry must concentrate; gentle curves → wide margins → industry can disperse.
  • Only one firm can occupy the maximum-profit point, so most real firms are in sub-optimal but still profitable locations → this led to behavioural studies.

Behavioural approach: sub-optimal locations ⭐⭐

Real decision-makers are not "economic men" with perfect knowledge. Two explanations:
(1) Man is an optimiser with limits – explained by Allan Pred's behavioural matrix (1967): position depends on the quantity and quality of information and the ability to use it.
Firms with good information and ability end up near the optimum; others may end up near it by luck, inside the margins with lower profit, or outside the margins and fail.
Firms with good information and ability end up near the optimum; others may end up near it by luck, inside the margins with lower profit, or outside the margins and fail.
Industrialist
Information
Ability
Result
1
Good
Good
At the optimum – right decision
2
Poor
Poor
Near an optimum by luck
3
Poor
Poor
Unlucky – outside the margin, loss, will close
4
Good
Poor
Profit, but less than possible
5
Poor
Good
Profit, but less than possible
6
Average
Average
Steady profit
(2) Man is a satisficer – accepts a satisfactory site, not the maximum-profit one (H.A. Simon's idea):
  • Maximum profit cannot be measured in advance; firms are happy to beat competitors → profit is relative.
  • People want non-money rewards → psychic income (pleasant climate, living and working conditions) – e.g. growth of industry in the sunny south-western USA (Sun Belt) after 1945; firms' reluctance to go to northern England despite subsidies.
  • Counter-view: satisficers may simply be imperfect optimisers with several goals (psychic income is another form of profit).
Other influences: corporate decisions by large multi-plant firms (best for the company network, not for one plant); governments choose sub-optimal sites for social, political or strategic reasons (defence relocation of US aircraft plants; reducing unemployment in UK regions); in planned economies, ideology vs profit; cost–benefit analysis weighs social gains and losses, not just money.
Conclusion: emphasis has shifted from finding the single optimum point to finding the margins of profitable location and explaining deviations through decision-making behaviour.

Diagrams: Smith and Isard

Where the revenue curve lies above the cost curve, a firm makes profit; the two crossing points are the spatial margins of profitability, and the optimum is where the gap is widest.
Where the revenue curve lies above the cost curve, a firm makes profit; the two crossing points are the spatial margins of profitability, and the optimum is where the gap is widest.
The transformation line shows the trade-off: moving nearer one source means moving away from the other. The optimum is where it touches the lowest iso-outlay line.
The transformation line shows the trade-off: moving nearer one source means moving away from the other. The optimum is where it touches the lowest iso-outlay line.

3. Industrial Revolutions ⭐

Revolution
Period
Feature
1st
~1760–1840 (Britain)
Water and steam power for mechanisation; textiles, iron, coal
2nd
~1870–1914
Electric power, steel, oil, mass production, assembly line (Ford 1913)
3rd
1960s/70s–2000s
Electronics, IT, computers, automation (digital revolution)
4th (Industry 4.0)
2010s– (term by Klaus Schwab, WEF, 2016)
Fusion of digital, physical and biological systems – AI, IoT, robotics, 3-D printing, biotech
Industry 5.0
EU concept, 2021
Human-centric, sustainable, resilient industry

4. Major Industrial Regions often linked with location theory

  • Ruhr (Germany) – coal → iron & steel (raw-material orientation). Lorraine (France) – iron ore (minette). Pittsburgh – coal-based steel; Lake Michigan region – Chicago, Gary (steel at break-of-bulk point where ore by lake meets coal by rail – Hoover's principle).
  • Manchurian (NE China) triangle – Anshan (steel), Fushun (coal), Shenyang/Mukden.
  • India: Jamshedpur, Bhilai, Rourkela, Bokaro – near coal and iron ore (MI > 1).
  • Aluminium – highly energy-intensive, so it locates near cheap power (hydro-electricity: Norway, Canada, Iceland; Hirakud, Renukoot in India).

⚡ Quick Revision

  • Least-cost theory → Alfred Weber, 1909; English 1929.
  • MI > 1 → raw material; MI < 1 → market; = 1 → footloose.
  • Equal cost of one material → isotim; equal total cost → isodapane; transport loss = labour gain → critical isodapane.
  • Transformation line → Isard (1956).
  • Spatial margins of profitability → Rawstron (1958), D.M. Smith (1966/71); optimum = max (TR − TC).
  • Behavioural matrix → Pred (1967).
  • Tapering freight rates, break-of-bulk → Hoover.
  • 4th Industrial Revolution term → Klaus Schwab (WEF).
  • Hierarchy of industrial concentrations (plant → district → central place → urban system → zone → belt) → J.H. Thompson.
  • Ice-cream sellers on a beach (locational interdependence) → Hotelling (1929); stable result = back to back at the centre.
  • V-shaped space-cost curve (demand constant) and Λ-shaped space-revenue curve (cost constant) → D.M. Smith.
  • Psychic income, satisficer → behavioural school; Sun Belt example.
  • Port industries → flour milling, shipbuilding, sugar and vegetable-oil refining.