Exam pointers: W.W. Rostow, The Stages of Economic Growth: A Non-Communist Manifesto (1960), five stages in order, take-off (investment 5% → 10%+, ~20 years, "great watershed"), drive to maturity (10–20% investment), criticisms (linear, Eurocentric, capitalist bias).
1. Basics ⭐⭐
- Walt Whitman Rostow (1916–2003), American economic historian and adviser to Presidents Kennedy and Johnson.
- Book: The Stages of Economic Growth: A Non-Communist Manifesto (1960). He later added a sixth stage, "search for quality", in Politics and the Stages of Growth (1971).
- A linear modernisation model: every society passes through five stages of development. Written deliberately against Marx's stages (hence "non-communist manifesto"). Based on data from about 15 countries.
Aeroplane analogy: the plane is parked (traditional), refuels and taxis (preconditions), takes off on the runway, climbs to cruising height (drive to maturity), and then passengers relax and enjoy the snacks (high mass consumption).
Mnemonic: "T-P-T-D-H" → "The Plane Takes Delhi High".
2. The Five Stages ⭐⭐⭐
Stage | Key features | Examples given |
I. Traditional society | Pre-Newtonian, primitive technology; agriculture-dominated; rigid, hierarchical, custom-bound society; low productivity – a ceiling on output; basic needs only; exports raw materials | Pre-industrial Europe, medieval China, many colonies |
II. Preconditions for take-off | Transitional; outside stimulus (colonialism, trade, new ideas); rise in productive investment; infrastructure (roads, railways, ports, banks); new entrepreneurial elite; effective centralised national state; agricultural improvement | Britain in the 18th century; many developing countries in the 1950s |
III. Take-off ⭐ | "The great watershed in the life of modern societies"; short period of about 20 years (10–30); rate of productive investment rises from about 5% to over 10% of national income; one or more leading sectors of manufacturing grow fast; political/social framework supports growth; urbanisation, literacy, income rise | Britain 1783–1802, France 1830–60, USA 1843–60, Germany 1850–73, Japan 1878–1900, Russia 1890–1914, India and China from ~1952 |
IV. Drive to maturity | About 60 years after take-off; diversification – economy can make almost anything; investment 10–20% of national income; imports fall; technology spreads to all sectors | Britain ~1850, USA ~1900, Japan ~1940 |
V. Age of high mass consumption | Shift to durable consumer goods (cars, appliances) and services; welfare state; near 100% literacy, high longevity and income | USA 1920s and after 1946, Western Europe and Japan in the 1950s |
(VI. Search for quality – 1971) | Concern with quality of life, environment, leisure | Post-industrial societies |
3. Significance
- Put growth in a wider historical and social context; recognised uneven sectoral development ("leading sectors").
- Influenced development planning and Western aid policy in the Cold War (e.g. India's Five-Year Plans aimed at investment-led take-off).
4. Criticisms ⭐
- Linear and unilinear – assumes all countries follow one path; stages may overlap or be skipped (e.g. Gulf states, East Asian tigers).
- Eurocentric / Western bias – based on Western history and only ~15 countries.
- Teleological and mechanical – the end (stage 5) is known at the start; the motor of change between stages is not explained; the terminology is vague; stages are hard to identify empirically (Kuznets).
- Capitalist bias – implies "there is no alternative" to capitalism; socialist societies treated as an arrested stage. Hides the social relations of production.
- Ignores colonial exploitation and global dependency – dependency theorists (A.G. Frank, "development of underdevelopment") and Wallerstein's world-systems theory argue poor countries are kept poor by the core.
- Ignores environmental limits and the costs of mass consumption.
- Take-off investment threshold (10%) not supported by data in many cases.
5. Marx vs Rostow (quick)
Marx | Rostow |
Stages by mode of production and class relations | Stages by investment and consumption |
End: socialism/communism | End: high mass consumption (capitalism) |
Historical materialism: "life is not determined by consciousness, but consciousness by life" | Modernisation theory |
⚡ Quick Revision
- Rostow's book → 1960, "A Non-Communist Manifesto".
- Third stage → take-off; investment 5% → >10%; ~20 years.
- Fourth → drive to maturity; fifth → high mass consumption.
- Sixth stage "search for quality" → added in 1971.