Why this page matters: Who defined geography how, areal differentiation vs exceptionalism (Hartshorne vs Schaefer), idiographic vs nomothetic, spatial vs locational analysis, Fenneman's circumference model, "geography as science of …" (relationship, distribution, chorology, planet earth), and Freeman's six trends. These are favourite one-liner MCQs.
1. The word "Geography" ⭐
- Geo = earth + graphein = to write / describe (Greek). For Ptolemy, graphein meant drawing / mapping, not describing.
- Eratosthenes (3rd century BC) first used the word "geography" (Geographika). He is called the father of geography and measured the earth's circumference.
- Greeks credit Homer with the beginning of geographical writing (Homer = father of Greek geography / first geographer in literature).
- Earliest known map: Sumerians / Babylonians of Mesopotamia (Tigris–Euphrates, Iraq). The famous Babylonian clay-tablet map is about 2500 BC (Ga-Sur tablet); Babylonian world map about 600 BC.
- Geography is eclectic: it integrates subject matter from many fields; almost any subject can be studied "geographically".
2. Definitions of Geography (who said what) ⭐⭐
Thinker | Definition / view | Key word to remember |
Conventional | "Study of spatial variation on the earth's surface". Criticised: no stress on explanation or on the changing character of the surface | Spatial variation |
Strabo (17-volume Geographica) | A geographer is "the person who attempts to describe the parts of the earth" | Describe + parts → Regional geography |
Ptolemy (c. AD 150) | Geography gives "a view of the whole", like drawing the whole head; chorography describes parts "like drawing only an ear or eye" | Whole earth, mapping, mathematical/cartographic |
Varenius (Geographia Generalis, 1650) | Divided geography into General (universal) and Special (chorology) | Seed of systematic vs regional dualism |
Kant | Geography = description; classification by space (geography) vs time (history) | Chorological vs chronological science |
Hartshorne (The Nature of Geography, 1939; Perspective on the Nature of Geography, 1959) | "Geography is concerned to provide accurate, orderly and rational description and interpretation of the variable character of the earth surface" | Areal differentiation; best-known formal definition |
Schaefer (1953) | "Science concerned with the formulation of laws governing the spatial distribution of certain features on the earth's surface" | Laws, nomothetic, social science |
Haggett | Study of the earth's surface as the space within which the human population lives | Human space |
Yi-Fu Tuan (1991) – humanist | Study of the earth as the home of people | Humanism |
Ackerman | "Differentiation of the content of space on the earth's surface and the analysis of space within the same universe" | Consensus definition |
Sauer | If history is the science of "when", geography is the science of "where" | Distribution / chorology |
Volz | Geography teaches us to know the space – the surface of the earth | Space |
Vidal de la Blache | Study of places; man interested in the totality of conditions in an area. "Nature is never more than an advisor" | Regional, possibilism |
Burton | Theory "provides the sieve through which myriads of facts are sorted" | Theory |
Unwin (1981) | Spatial analysis = study of arrangement of points, lines, areas and surfaces on a map | Spatial analysis |
Bunge (Theoretical Geography, 1962) | Geography = "science of locations" | Geometry |
Memory trick – Hartshorne's definition = "A-O-R" of "V-C": Accurate, Orderly, Rational description of the Variable Character of the earth surface. Two key words: variable character (spatial variation of physical + cultural features at all scales) and earth surface (thin outer shell, ~1/1000 of earth's circumference, the human habitat).
3. Position of Geography
- Neither purely a natural science nor purely a social science – a bridge / synthesising discipline ("mother of all sciences").
- Chorology / chorography = study of areal differentiation of the earth's surface. First set by Hecataeus of Miletus (6th century BC); codified by Strabo.
- Strabo began with the chorography of Europe because it was "adapted to nature for excellence in man and government". His geography served social, political and military ends.
- Till the 17th century, Strabo (regional/special) and Ptolemy (general/mathematical) were the two models of European geography.
4. Essential Characteristics of Geography ⭐
- Emphasis on location – spatial variation of physical and human phenomena. Examples of location patterns: von Thünen model (1826) and Christaller's Central Place Theory (1933). Cartography makes accurate location possible.
- Ecological emphasis on society–land relations – man–environment relationship (impact both ways).
- Regional analysis – fuses spatial and ecological approaches; identifies homogeneous regions, their internal morphology and external relations.
→ Two approaches: Regional (region by region) and Systematic (theme traced over the whole earth).
Also: Welfare geography asks for more equitable patterns (inequality, social justice); economic geography asks for more efficient patterns.
5. Nature of Geography – Science or Art?
Geography as a Systematic / Natural Science
Scholar | View |
Julius Fröbel (student of Ritter) | Geography as Erdkunde (science of the earth) = natural science. Divided into (i) systematic geography (natural science, analytic method) and (ii) aesthetic / historical-philosophical / applied geography (synthetic method). Said human phenomena cannot be part of science |
Gerland (1887) | Quoted Kant: "physical geography – a general abstract of nature – is the foundation of history and all other geographies". Planned geography of (i) inorganic earth, (ii) plants, (iii) animals, (iv) man; but finally wanted plant, animal, human and regional geography excluded from scientific geography. Opposed Ratzel's "law" of mountains separating peoples (said it is psychology) |
Leighly | Geography as geophysics: landforms, weathering, meteorology, seismology, geodesy, hydrology. Science needs fixed laws; geography deals in "probabilities" |
Ratzel (Anthropogeographie, 1882 & 1891) | Opposed Fröbel–Gerland; founded systematic human geography and political geography. Gumplowicz: Ratzel's works contain more knowledge about the state than the last 100 years of political science |
6. Areal Differentiation ⭐⭐
- Definition: study of areal variation of human and physical phenomena as they relate to other spatially close and causally linked phenomena.
- Term coined/popularised by Richard Hartshorne in The Nature of Geography (1939), drawing from Hettner.
- Same as chorology. It is idiographic – concerned with the unique and particular.
- Hartshorne: geography interprets areal differentiation "not only in terms of differences in certain things from place to place, but also in terms of the total combination of phenomena in each place". Its purpose = synthesis.
- Geography : space :: History : time (close analogy).
Revival in the 1980s from three directions:
- Humanistic geography – human awareness, agency, creativity; iconographic method (reading symbolic landscapes).
- Uneven development / spatial division of labour – Marxist approach.
- Contextual theory – place/region mediates human agency and social structure (structuration).
Criticisms: difficult to draw neat boundaries (territoriality is dynamic); cannot lead to generalisation. Yet it helped rebuild regional geography: regions are unique but not "singular" (not isolated).
7. Exceptionalism in Geography ⭐⭐⭐
The great debate: Hartshorne vs Schaefer
Exceptionalism = the belief that geography (and history) are methodologically exceptional – different from other sciences – because they study unique places/periods and integrate heterogeneous phenomena.
- Father of exceptionalism: Immanuel Kant – claimed it for both geography and history. Followed by Humboldt, Ritter, Hettner, Hartshorne.
- Hettner: history and geography are both "chorological/integrating" sciences; history = Zeit-Wissenschaft (time science), geography = Raum-Wissenschaft (space science) – translated by Hartshorne.
- The term is identified with Fred K. Schaefer (economist; fled Nazi Germany; taught at University of Iowa). Paper: "Exceptionalism in Geography: A Methodological Examination", Annals of the AAG, 1953, Vol. 43. Published after his death; rallying point of the Quantitative Revolution.
- Hartshorne replied in "Exceptionalism in Geography Re-examined" (1955).
Point | Hartshorne | Schaefer |
Nature | Idiographic (unique regions) | Nomothetic (general laws) |
Core | Areal differentiation, regional synthesis | Laws of spatial arrangement ("morphological laws") |
Category | Integrating science, like history | Social science, like others – nothing "exceptional" |
Philosophy | Kantian, regional | Positivism (hypothesis → test → law) |
Influence | Regional geography | Quantitative revolution; first to teach Christaller, von Thünen, Lösch |
- Schaefer: "To explain the phenomena one has described means always to recognise them as instances of laws". Spatial arrangements, not the phenomena themselves, are the geographer's object.
- Note: Hartshorne actually never accepted a sharp idiographic–nomothetic split ("both present in all sciences").
- Kraft: geography seeks laws, is limited to earth's surface and is chorological – this alone makes it exceptional.
8. Spatial Analysis vs Locational Analysis ⭐
ㅤ | Spatial Analysis | Locational Analysis |
Meaning | Quantitative techniques used in locational analysis; arrangement of points, lines, areas, surfaces (Unwin 1981) | An approach to human geography focusing on spatial arrangement of phenomena |
Era / philosophy | Quantitative revolution; positivism | Positivism + empiricism; 1950s USA |
Goal | Accurate generalisations with predictive power | Building generalisations, models, theories (Berry & Marble, 1968) |
Key concepts | Direction, distance, connection (relative position) | Geometry as language of spatial form |
Problems | Spatial autocorrelation; spatial determinism; ignores cultural values | See criticisms below |
Key people of locational analysis:
- Bunge – Theoretical Geography (1962; 2nd ed. 1966): geography as "science of locations".
- Haggett – Locational Analysis in Human Geography (1965): adopt (1) systems approach, (2) models, (3) quantitative techniques.
- Morrill – The Spatial Organization of Society (1970): people seek to maximise spatial interaction at minimum cost, so societies are "surprisingly alike".
- Others: McCarty, Chorley, Cox, Harvey, Johnston, Sack, D.M. Smith, Garrison, Berry.
Criticisms of locational analysis (by behaviouralists, humanists, Marxists):
- Ignores normative questions and cultural values.
- Does not reflect real decision-making.
- Models conceal real-world complexity.
- Global interdependence makes local environmental dependence less meaningful.
- Serves capitalism: rich richer, poor poorer; profit maximisation.
- Leads to over-production and over-industrialisation.
- Treats people as "dots on a map", numbers in an equation.
→ These led to behaviouralism and humanism. Haggett (1990, The Geographer's Art) still promoted "scientific generalisation".
9. Idiographic vs Nomothetic ⭐⭐
Idiographic | Nomothetic |
Describes the unique / particular | Seeks general laws |
Regional geography | Systematic geography |
Kant, Hettner, Hartshorne | Humboldt, Sauer (partly), Schaefer, Bunge, Haggett |
For Kant, geography = description; for Hartshorne a "naive science" | After WW II: diffusion models, location theory, gravity models |
- Preston E. James: there is no such thing as a "real region"; a region is only an intellectual concept for a purpose.
- Word origin (Windelband, 1894): idios = own/private; nomos = law.
10. Geography as a Discipline of Synthesis – Fenneman's Model ⭐
- N.M. Fenneman (1919): "The Circumference of Geography" – a circle diagram in which geography sits at the centre and overlaps with geology, meteorology, biology, sociology, economics, history, etc. Each overlapping zone = a systematic branch of geography (geomorphology, climatology, biogeography, social geography …).
- The core is regional geography – the synthesis.
- Geography studies the overall interaction of biotic and abiotic phenomena in time and space with an anthropocentric view, where lithosphere, hydrosphere, atmosphere and biosphere converge.
- Before the quantitative revolution geography was "short on theory and long on fact".
11. The Geographic Continuum
- A line with physical/life sciences on the left (physical geography: geomorphology, climatology, biogeography, soil geography…) and human/cultural sciences on the right (economic, population, political, urban, behavioural geography…); synthesis at the centre.
- Reflects the physical vs human duality. Modern problems need a move to the centre (holistic view): ozone depletion, global warming, air pollution, natural hazards, deforestation, biodiversity loss, disasters (Chernobyl 1986, Exxon Valdez oil spill 1989), natural-resource accounting.
12. "Geography as the Science of …" ⭐⭐
Science of … | Supporters | Key idea | Criticism |
Relationship (man–environment) | Ratzel, Semple, Huntington, Brunhes, Vidal, Febvre, Barrows, Herbertson, Taylor | Ratzel: "similar locations lead to similar modes of life" (Britain & Japan). Barrows (1922): geography as human ecology – man's adjustment to environment. Huntington: climate → civilisation, "pulsations"; best climate in NW Europe | Positivists: similar locations do not give similar history |
Distribution | Varenius, Kant period; Sauer, Marthe ("the where of things"), De Geer | Sauer: history = "when", geography = "where" | Hettner (1905): every science maps its own objects; geography is more than description of distributions |
Chorology (regions) | Strabo, Richthofen, Hettner, Hartshorne, Vidal, Sauer | Curiosity about other places; "home geography" as necessary as current history | Hard to generalise |
Planet earth / earth's surface | Gerland, Richthofen (Leipzig address 1883: outer shell), Lehmann, Penck | Domain = outer shell where litho-, hydro-, atmo- and biosphere meet. "There is geography but no Mars-geography" | Hettner called Richthofen's limit illogical |
Space / spatial organisation | Schaefer, Bunge, Haggett, Morrill | Laws of spatial arrangement | Spatial fetishism |
13. Possibilism vs Determinism (quick link)
- Environmental determinism: environment controls human action; man passive. Roots in Darwin (On the Origin of Species, 1859) → Davis (cycle of erosion), Ratzel (Lebensraum, state as organism), Semple (Influences of Geographic Environment, 1911), Huntington.
- Possibilism (French): nature offers options; options grow with technology. Lucien Febvre (historian) coined the term and said: "There are no necessities, but everywhere possibilities, and man as master of these possibilities is the judge of their use". Vidal: "nature is never more than an advisor". Concept of pays; genre de vie.
14. History & Evolution – Fast Timeline
Period | Milestones |
Ancient Greek | Thales (6th c. BC), Hecataeus (father of geography by some; Ges Periodos), Herodotus (5th c. BC, father of history), Aristotle (earth as sphere, 4th c. BC), Eratosthenes (circumference), Hipparchus of Rhodes (2nd c. BC) – system of lines → latitude/longitude |
Roman | Strabo (c. 64 BC – AD 24): 17-volume Geographica, father of regional geography; Ptolemy (c. AD 90–168): 8-volume Guide to Geography (Geographike Hyphegesis), places by lat/long, geocentric view |
Dark Age (Europe) | Geography forgotten; pilgrim itineraries (Helena, AD 326; Silvia of Aquitaine – one of the first women geographers) |
Arab (8th–14th c.) | Baghdad (762), Bait-ul-Hikma under Harun-al-Rashid; Ibn Hawqal, Al-Masudi, Al-Biruni, Al-Idrisi (12th c., climatic classification, map for Roger II), Ibn Battuta (14th c., disproved Aristotle's uninhabitable torrid zone), Ibn Khaldun (Muqaddimah) |
Age of Discovery | Prince Henry the Navigator – centre at Sagres (1418); Marco Polo (1254–1324); Columbus 1492; Vasco da Gama 1498; Waldseemüller 1507 map (name "America"); Magellan's circumnavigation 1519–22; Mercator projection 1569; heliocentric view (Copernicus, Galileo) |
Pre-classical | Varenius (1622–1650), Geographia Generalis 1650; Kant (1724–1804) – physical geography lectures at Königsberg |
Classical (1800–1859) | Humboldt (1769–1859) – Kosmos, physical & plant geography; Ritter (1779–1859) – Erdkunde, human/regional. Both died 1859 → end of classical period |
Modern (1874–1945) | First university geography departments in Germany, 1874 (P.E. James). Peschel, Richthofen, Ratzel, Hettner, Penck; Davis (geomorphology, USA); Arnold Guyot – first chair of geography in USA (Princeton) |
Contemporary (after 1945) | Quantitative revolution (term by I. Burton, 1963), then behavioural, humanistic, welfare, radical, postmodern approaches |
15. Freeman's Six Trends in Geographical Literature ⭐
Mnemonic: "E-E-C-G-P-S" → "Every Educated Colonial Geographer Prefers Specialisation"
- Encyclopaedic – collecting information about little-known lands (Africa = terra incognita).
- Educational – opening university departments; curricula.
- Colonial – information for running empires (esp. Britain).
- Generalising – using the collected facts to generalise; early paradigms.
- Political – Isaiah Bowman advised Woodrow Wilson at the Paris Peace Conference (1919); Haushofer's geopolitics → Nazi Lebensraum.
- Specialisation – growth of knowledge forces specialisation.
16. Shifting Viewpoint after 1859
- After Ritter's death: shift to historical/regional emphasis; Peschel shifted German geography to landform morphology; Richthofen, Penck (a geologist) also stressed geomorphology → physical vs human dualism.
- Richthofen: systematic and regional geography differ in method, not material; systematic studies lead to causal principles applied in chorology.
- Mackinder sought the unity of geography in natural regions (idea owed to Herbertson, who gave the natural regions scheme, 1905).
- Sauer: modern geography is "the modern expression of the most ancient geography" – chorology.
⚡ Quick Revision (one-liners)
- First used the term geography → Eratosthenes.
- Father of regional geography → Strabo; of general/systematic dualism → Varenius.
- Father of exceptionalism → Kant; term identified with → Schaefer (1953).
- "Areal differentiation" → Hartshorne (1939).
- "Time science vs space science" → Hettner.
- "Science of where" → Sauer.
- "Circumference of Geography" model → Fenneman (1919).
- "Science of locations" → Bunge.
- Locational Analysis in Human Geography → Haggett (1965).
- "Quantitative revolution" term → Ian Burton (1963).
- "Geography as human ecology" → H.H. Barrows (1922/23).
- "There are no necessities, but everywhere possibilities" → Febvre.
- "Nature is never more than an advisor" → Vidal de la Blache.
- "Similar locations lead to similar modes of life" → Ratzel.
- Six trends of geography → Freeman.
- First geography departments in universities → Germany, 1874.
📝 Practice MCQs
- "Exceptionalism in Geography: A Methodological Examination" was written by – (a) Hartshorne (b) Schaefer ✅ (c) Bunge (d) Haggett
- Who is regarded as the father of exceptionalism? – Kant
- Hettner called geography – (a) time science (b) space science ✅
- Who said there is no "real region"? – Preston James
- Which is NOT a basic concept of spatial analysis? – direction, distance, connection, culture ✅
- Who limited the field of geography to the earth's surface (outer shell) in his Leipzig address, 1883? – Richthofen