Sub-topics: Post-war upsurge · Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms / GoI Act 1919 · Gandhi in South Africa · Champaran, Ahmedabad, Kheda · Rowlatt Act & Satyagraha · Jallianwala Bagh · Hunter Committee. 🟣 Champaran is the single most-asked BPSC topic.
1. Why a nationalist resurgence after WWI2. Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms → Government of India Act, 1919 ⭐⭐Provinces — Dyarchy (rule of two)Centre — still no responsible governmentDrawbacks3. The making of Gandhi — South Africa (1893–1914)Moderate phase (1894–1906)Satyagraha phase (1906–14)Technique of Satyagraha4. Gandhi in India (1915–18)A. Champaran Satyagraha (1917) — first civil disobedience ⭐⭐⭐ 🟣B. Ahmedabad Mill Strike (March 1918) — first hunger strike ⭐C. Kheda Satyagraha (1918) — first non-cooperation ⭐5. Rowlatt Act and Satyagraha (1919) ⭐⭐6. Jallianwala Bagh Massacre — 📅 13 April 1919 ⭐⭐⭐Hunter Committee (Disorders Inquiry Committee)🧠 Memory box🎯 Exam traps
1. Why a nationalist resurgence after WWI
- Post-war economic hardship — India paid in men and money:
- Industry: price rise then recession + foreign investment → demanded protection and aid.
- Workers & artisans: unemployment, high prices.
- Peasants: high taxes and poverty — waiting for a lead.
- Returning soldiers spread their experiences in villages; found a poorer, less free India.
- Educated urban classes: unemployment and racism.
- Expectation of political reward for war cooperation (Gandhi even helped recruit).
- Disillusionment with imperialism worldwide — Allies had promised democracy and self-determination; the Paris Peace Conference instead divided the losers’ colonies. Upsurge in Turkey, Egypt, Ireland, Iran, Afghanistan, Burma, Malaya, Philippines, Indonesia, Indo-China, China, Korea.
- Russian Revolution (7 Nov 1917) — Lenin’s Bolsheviks founded the first socialist state; renounced Tsarist imperial rights in Asia, granted self-determination — showed that organised masses can topple tyrants.
2. Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms → Government of India Act, 1919 ⭐⭐
“Carrot” = Montford Reforms; “stick” = Rowlatt Act. Report published July 1918; Act passed 1919 (Viceroy Chelmsford, Secretary of State Montagu); came into force 1921.
Provinces — Dyarchy (rule of two)
Executive:
- Governor = executive head.
- Subjects split into:
- Reserved — law and order, finance, land revenue, irrigation, police, justice, press → Governor + Executive Council (bureaucrats), not responsible to the legislature.
- Transferred — education, health, local government, industry, agriculture, excise → ministers chosen from elected members, responsible to the legislature (must resign on a no-confidence vote).
- On breakdown, the Governor could take over transferred subjects too.
- Secretary of State and GG could interfere freely in reserved subjects, less in transferred.
Legislature:
- Provincial councils expanded; 70% elected.
- Communal and class electorates consolidated (extended to Sikhs, Indian Christians, Anglo-Indians, Europeans).
- Women given the right to vote (limited, by property qualification — provinces could decide).
- Could initiate legislation (Governor’s assent needed; veto and ordinances); could reject the budget (Governor could restore it); freedom of speech.
Centre — still no responsible government
- GG chief executive; two lists — central and provincial (devolution).
- 3 Indians in the Viceroy’s Executive Council of 8.
- GG could restore cuts, certify rejected bills, issue ordinances.
- Bicameral legislature:
- Central Legislative Assembly (lower): 145 members (41 nominated, 104 elected — 52 general, 30 Muslim, 2 Sikh, 20 special); term 3 years.
- Council of State (upper): 60 members (26 nominated, 34 elected); term 5 years; only men.
- Could ask questions and supplementaries, move adjournment motions, vote part of the budget — 75% non-votable.
- Secretary of State to be paid from the British exchequer.
Drawbacks
- Franchise tiny: ~1.5 million voters for the centre out of ~260 million.
- No control of the legislature over the Viceroy and his council.
- Unsatisfactory division of subjects; seat allocation by provinces’ “importance” (Punjab military, Bombay commercial).
- Dyarchy irrational: ministers had no control over finance or bureaucrats; often not consulted; could be overruled.
Reactions: Special Congress session, Bombay, Aug 1918 (president Hasan Imam 🟣 of Bihar) — “disappointing and unsatisfactory”. Tilak: “unworthy and disappointing — a sunless dawn”. Annie Besant: “unworthy of England to offer and India to accept”. (Moderates under Surendranath accepted them and formed the Indian Liberal Federation, 1918/19.) Curzon: “ultimate self-government” probably meant 500 years. Subhas Bose: “forged fresh fetters”.
3. The making of Gandhi — South Africa (1893–1914)
- Born 2 October 1869, Porbandar (Kathiawar); father a diwan. Studied law in England. Went to South Africa in 1893 for client Dada Abdullah; experienced racism (thrown off the train at Pietermaritzburg).
- Indians there: (1) indentured labour (mostly south Indian) on sugar plantations; (2) merchants (mostly Meman Muslims); (3) ex-indentured settlers. Denied vote, confined to ghettos, curfew after 9 p.m., barred from footpaths.
Moderate phase (1894–1906)
Petitions and memorials; founded the Natal Indian Congress (1894) and the paper Indian Opinion (1903).
Satyagraha phase (1906–14)
- Against registration certificates (1906) — compulsory certificates with fingerprints (“Black Act”, Transvaal); Passive Resistance Association; jail; public burning of certificates; compromise. Satyagraha born.
- Against restrictions on Indian migration — crossing provincial borders without licences.
- Against poll tax (£3) on ex-indentured Indians (who earned <10 shillings a month) and the Supreme Court ruling invalidating non-Christian marriages — drew women in.
- Against the Transvaal Immigration Act — illegal crossing from Natal; miners and plantation workers struck. Gokhale toured India for support; Viceroy Hardinge condemned repression.
- Settlement (Gandhi, Hardinge, C.F. Andrews, General Smuts) — poll tax, registration, Indian marriages conceded; immigration to be treated sympathetically.
- Phoenix Farm (1904, Natal) — inspired by Ruskin’s Unto This Last; Tolstoy Farm (1910) — named by Hermann Kallenbach; manual work + education; co-education.
Lessons: masses can sacrifice for a cause; Indians of all religions, classes and both sexes can be united; leaders must sometimes take unpopular decisions; Gandhi evolved his own style.
Technique of Satyagraha
Based on truth and non-violence; drew on Indian tradition, Christ’s “turn the other cheek” and Tolstoy.
- Never submit to wrong; stay truthful, non-violent, fearless.
- Withdrawal of cooperation and boycott; non-payment of taxes; renouncing honours and posts.
- Willingly accept suffering; no hatred for the wrongdoer.
- Only for the brave — even violence preferable to cowardice; ends do not justify means.
4. Gandhi in India (1915–18)
- Returned 9 January 1915 (celebrated as Pravasi Bharatiya Divas); on Gokhale’s advice toured India for a year, taking no political stand; disagreed with Moderate methods and with Home Rule agitation during the war; would join no organisation that did not accept non-violent satyagraha.
- Set up Sabarmati Ashram (Kochrab 1915 → Sabarmati 1917).
A. Champaran Satyagraha (1917) — first civil disobedience ⭐⭐⭐ 🟣
Problem:
- European indigo planters forced peasants to grow indigo on 3/20 of their land — the tinkathia system (3 kathas per bigha of 20 kathas).
- When German synthetic dyes killed the indigo market (late 19th c.), planters demanded enhanced rent (sharahbeshi) and illegal dues (tawan, abwabs) to release peasants from indigo, and forced sales at fixed prices.
Events:
- Rajkumar Shukla, a local cultivator, persuaded Gandhi (met him at the Lucknow Congress, Dec 1916) to come.
- Gandhi reached Motihari (April 1917) with Rajendra Prasad, Mazhar-ul-Haq, Mahadev Desai, Narhari Parikh, J.B. Kripalani; also Brajkishore Prasad, Anugrah Narayan Sinha, Ramnavami Prasad, Shambhusharan Varma.
- District authorities ordered him to leave; he refused and was ready to face punishment — civil disobedience of an unjust order, a novel method. The case was withdrawn; he was allowed to inquire (recorded ~8,000 peasant statements).
- Government set up the Champaran Agrarian Committee (June 1917) (chairman F.G. Sly) with Gandhi as a member.
- Result: tinkathia abolished; peasants compensated for illegal dues — Gandhi agreed to 25% refund as a compromise (critics wondered why; Gandhi said the principle mattered). Enacted as the Champaran Agrarian Act, 1918. Within a decade planters left.
- Batak Mian (Ansari), a cook, refused the planter Irwin’s order to poison Gandhi’s milk at Motihari — saving Gandhi’s life (BPSC repeat question).
- Gandhi set up schools (e.g., Bhitiharwa), and the title “Mahatma” gained wide currency; Rajendra Prasad wrote Satyagraha in Champaran.
B. Ahmedabad Mill Strike (March 1918) — first hunger strike ⭐
- Dispute between mill owners and workers over withdrawal of the plague bonus; workers wanted 50% wage rise (wartime inflation doubled prices); owners offered 20%; strike, dismissals, plan to bring weavers from Bombay.
- Workers turned to Anusuya Sarabhai (sister of mill-owner Ambalal Sarabhai, president of the Ahmedabad Mill Owners Association); she brought in Gandhi (Ambalal’s friend).
- Gandhi asked workers to demand 35% and stay non-violent; when talks stalled he went on his first fast unto death.
- Owners agreed to a tribunal, which awarded 35%. (Anusuya later formed the Ahmedabad Textile Labour Association, 1920.)
C. Kheda Satyagraha (1918) — first non-cooperation ⭐
- Drought (1918) → crop failure in Kheda (Gujarat). Revenue Code allowed remission if yield < ¼ of normal. The Gujarat Sabha petitioned for suspension; government threatened to seize property.
- Gandhi advised non-payment (spiritual head); real organisers: Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, Narhari Parikh, Mohanlal Pandya, Ravi Shankar Vyas (and Indulal Yagnik).
- Discipline held despite confiscations; buyers of seized land ostracised.
- Settlement: tax suspended for that year and the next; rate increase reduced; confiscated property returned. Peasants realised only independence would end exploitation.
Gains of the three struggles: proved satyagraha works; Gandhi understood the masses; won the respect of youth; brought in a new team (Rajendra Prasad, Patel, Kripalani, Mahadev Desai).
5. Rowlatt Act and Satyagraha (1919) ⭐⭐
- Rowlatt Committee (Sedition Committee, 1917–18), headed by Justice Sir Sidney Rowlatt, recommended detention without trial for 2 years and that possessing seditious papers be proof of guilt.
- Of two bills, one passed in March 1919 — the Anarchical and Revolutionary Crimes Act, i.e., the Rowlatt Act — replacing the wartime Defence of India Act with a permanent law.
- All elected Indian members opposed; Jinnah, Madan Mohan Malaviya, Mazhar-ul-Haq 🟣 resigned.
- Provisions: trial without jury; imprisonment without trial; arrest without warrant on suspicion; secret trials without legal help; a panel of 3 High Court judges with no appeal; evidence not admissible under the Evidence Act accepted; suspension of habeas corpus — “no vakil, no daleel, no appeal”.
- Gandhi called it the “Black Act”; formed the Satyagraha Sabha (Feb 1919) with young Home Rulers and Pan-Islamists. Methods: nationwide hartal with fasting and prayer, civil disobedience of specific laws, courting arrest — first all-India mass strike.
- Significance: masses could now act; peasants, artisans, urban poor entered politics; the movement turned permanently to the masses.
- Satyagraha set for 6 April 1919 (Delhi hartal on 30 March, led by Swami Shraddhanand); violent outbreaks in Calcutta, Bombay, Delhi, Ahmedabad; Punjab most explosive (wartime repression, forced recruitment, disease) — army called in; Lt-Governor Michael O’Dwyer reportedly used aircraft strafing. Biggest anti-British upsurge since 1857.
6. Jallianwala Bagh Massacre — 📅 13 April 1919 ⭐⭐⭐
- 9 April: Dr Saifuddin Kitchlew and Dr Satyapal arrested in Amritsar and taken away.
- 10 April: protest; police firing killed some; riot — 5 Englishmen killed; missionary Marcella Sherwood assaulted.
- Brig.-General Reginald Dyer imposed control; on 13 April (Baisakhi) he banned leaving the city without a pass and assemblies of more than three.
- ~20,000 people (many villagers celebrating Baisakhi, unaware of the order) gathered at Jallianwala Bagh; resolutions passed for Rowlatt repeal and condemning the 10 April firing.
- Dyer blocked the only exit and fired without warning; 1,650 rounds. Official toll 379 dead, ~1,100 wounded; Congress estimate ~1,000 dead, 1,500+ injured.
- Martial law in Punjab; public floggings; Indians forced to crawl on the street where Sherwood was assaulted.
- Rabindranath Tagore renounced his knighthood; Gandhi returned the Kaiser-i-Hind medal (for Boer War work); Gandhi withdrew the satyagraha on 18 April 1919 due to violence (“Himalayan miscalculation”).
- Gandhi: cooperation with a “satanic regime” impossible → path to Non-Cooperation. Historian A.J.P. Taylor: the “decisive moment when Indians were alienated from British rule”.
- Udham Singh (alias Ram Mohammad Singh Azad) shot Michael O’Dwyer in London (13 March 1940); hanged 1940; ashes returned 1974.
Hunter Committee (Disorders Inquiry Committee)
- Announced 14 October 1919; chairman Lord William Hunter; 3 Indian members — Sir Chimanlal Setalvad, Pandit Jagat Narayan, Sultan Ahmad Khan.
- Dyer told it he could have dispersed the crowd without firing but they would have “laughed” at him; he wanted to strike terror; didn’t think helping the wounded was his job.
- Report (March 1920): unanimously condemned Dyer (no warning, prolonged firing, wrong motive, overstepped authority; no conspiracy existed). Indian minority report: “inhuman and un-British”. But no penal action; an Indemnity Act (“white-washing bill”) had already protected officers.
- Dyer relieved of command (March 1920), retired on half pay. Churchill called the massacre “monstrous”; Asquith “one of the worst outrages”. But the House of Lords supported Dyer; the Morning Post raised £26,000 for him (Rudyard Kipling contributed); Golden Temple clergy (under Arur Singh) honoured him — which spurred the Gurdwara Reform (Akali) movement.
- Congress’s own inquiry committee: Motilal Nehru, C.R. Das, Abbas Tyabji, M.R. Jayakar, Gandhi.
🧠 Memory box
- “Firsts of Gandhi”: Champaran 1917 = first civil disobedience · Ahmedabad 1918 = first hunger strike · Kheda 1918 = first non-cooperation · Rowlatt 1919 = first all-India mass strike/hartal.
- April 1919: 6 hartal → 9 Kitchlew & Satyapal arrested → 10 firing → 13 Jallianwala → 18 satyagraha withdrawn.
- Champaran team 🟣: Rajkumar Shukla (invited), Rajendra Prasad, Brajkishore Prasad, Anugrah Narayan Sinha, Mazhar-ul-Haq, J.B. Kripalani, Mahadev Desai, Narhari Parikh; saviour cook Batak Mian; committee chairman F.G. Sly; refund 25%.
- Montford: Reserved vs Transferred; Assembly 145, Council of State 60; 3 Indians in Executive Council of 8.
🎯 Exam traps
- ⚠️ Tinkathia = 3/20 of land under indigo.
- ⚠️ Champaran compensation = 25% of illegal dues, not full refund.
- ⚠️ Gandhi’s first fast in India was at Ahmedabad (1918); Kheda was led on the ground by Patel.
- ⚠️ Rowlatt Act: passed March 1919; formal name Anarchical and Revolutionary Crimes Act.
- ⚠️ Udham Singh killed Michael O’Dwyer (Lt-Governor), not General Dyer (who died in 1927).
- ⚠️ Tagore renounced knighthood; Gandhi returned Kaiser-i-Hind.
- ⚠️ Women first got (limited) voting rights under the 1919 Act; dyarchy was only in provinces.