Notes · History

15 · Swarajists, New Forces & Revolutionaries of the 1920s

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

9 min read5 sections

15 · Swarajists, New Forces & Revolutionaries of the 1920s

📌
Sub-topics: Swarajists vs No-Changers · Socialist/communist ideas, youth, trade unions, caste movements · Revolutionary activity 2nd phase — HRA/HSRA, Kakori, Bhagat Singh, Chittagong.

1. Swarajists and No-Changers (1922–30) ⭐⭐

After Gandhi’s arrest (March 1922) the movement was disorganised; debate on what to do in the passive phase.
ㅤ
Swarajists (pro-changers)
No-Changers
Leaders
C.R. Das, Motilal Nehru, Hakim Ajmal Khan (also Vithalbhai Patel, N.C. Kelkar)
C. Rajagopalachari, Vallabhbhai Patel, Rajendra Prasad, M.A. Ansari (Kasturi Ranga Iyengar)
Stand
End boycott; enter councils to “end or mend” them — expose them, obstruct if demands rejected
Oppose council entry; constructive work; continue boycott; prepare for civil disobedience
Arguments
Council entry = continuing NCM by other means, a new front; keeps masses enthused in a vacuum; keeps undesirable elements out; councils as arenas of struggle (not for gradual reform)
Parliamentary work breeds neglect of constructive work, loss of zeal, corruption
  • Gaya session (Dec 1922) (president C.R. Das 🟣) rejected council entry → Das resigned as president, Motilal as secretary → formed the Congress-Khilafat Swarajya Party (Swaraj Party), 1 January 1923: Das president, Motilal a secretary.
  • Both sides avoided a 1907-type split. Delhi special session (Sept 1923) (president Maulana Azad, youngest president) allowed Swarajists to contest elections as a group within Congress.
  • Swarajist manifesto (Oct 1923): British rule was selfish; reforms a blind for exploitation; demand self-government in the councils; if refused, “uniform, continuous and consistent obstruction” to wreck councils from within.
  • Nov 1923 elections: won 42 of 141 elected central seats; clear majority in the Central Provinces; with Liberals and independents (Jinnah, Malaviya) formed a majority bloc.
  • Gandhi (released Feb 1924) initially opposed but reconciled: opposing them would backfire; they worked courageously; crackdown on Swarajists/revolutionaries (late 1924) made him show solidarity. Belgaum session (Dec 1924) — the only session Gandhi presided over — accepted Swarajists working in councils as an integral part of Congress.

Decline of the Swarajists

  • Communal riots; split into Responsivists (Lajpat Rai, Madan Mohan Malaviya, N.C. Kelkar — cooperate, hold office, protect “Hindu interests”) and Non-responsivists; government divided militants from moderates, Hindus from Muslims.
  • Lost Muslim support by not backing (mostly Muslim) tenants against zamindars in Bengal.
  • C.R. Das died June 1925.
  • Main leadership walked out of legislatures in March 1926; the 1926 elections went badly (40 seats at centre; routed in UP, CP, Punjab).
  • Final walkout in 1930 after the Lahore Purna Swaraj resolution and CDM.

Achievements

  1. With allies, out-voted the government several times, incl. budget grants; passed adjournment motions.
  1. Powerful speeches on self-government, civil liberties, industrialisation.
  1. Vithalbhai Patel elected Speaker (President) of the Central Legislative Assembly, 1925.
  1. Defeated the Public Safety Bill (1928) (to deport “subversive” foreigners spreading communism).
  1. Filled the political vacuum; exposed the hollowness of Montford; showed councils could be used creatively.

Drawbacks

No coordination with mass struggle outside (relied on newspaper reports); limits of obstruction; conflicts with coalition partners; succumbed to perks of office; failed Bengal peasants.

Constructive work of No-Changers

  • Ashrams among tribals and lower castes (Kheda, Bardoli); charkha and khadi.
  • National schools and colleges.
  • Hindu–Muslim unity, anti-untouchability, boycott of foreign cloth and liquor, flood relief.
  • Constructive workers became the backbone of later civil disobedience.
  • Critique: national education benefited mainly urban lower middle class and rich peasants; khadi costlier than imports; untouchability tackled socially, not economically (landless labourers).

2. New forces of the 1920s

The 1920s: masses entered the movement; major political currents crystallised, partly as reactions (positive or negative) to Gandhism; strong international influence.

A. Marxist and socialist ideas ⭐

  • Rise of a left wing in Congress — Jawaharlal Nehru and Subhas Bose: critical of both Swarajists and No-Changers; demanded Purna Swaraj; linked nationalism with social justice and class oppression by capitalists and landlords.
  • Communist Party of India:
    • 1920, Tashkent — founded by M.N. Roy, Abani Mukherji and others after the 2nd Comintern Congress (M.N. Roy first Indian in Comintern leadership).
    • 1924 — Kanpur Bolshevik Conspiracy Case: S.A. Dange, Muzaffar Ahmed, Shaukat Usmani, Nalini Gupta jailed.
    • 1925 — Indian Communist Conference, Kanpur formally founded the CPI (Satyabhakta).
    • 1929 — Meerut Conspiracy Case: 31 communists, trade unionists, leftists arrested.
  • Workers’ and Peasants’ Parties spread Marxism; communists stayed part of the national movement working with Congress.

B. Youth activism

Students’ leagues and conferences; Nehru presided over the All Bengal Students’ Conference (1928).

C. Peasant agitations

UP (tenancy law revision, lower rents, protection from eviction, debt relief); Rampa (Andhra); Rajasthan; ryotwari areas of Bombay and Madras; Bardoli Satyagraha (1928) under Vallabhbhai Patel (see page 26).

D. Trade unionism

  • AITUC founded 1920 — first president Lala Lajpat Rai, general secretary Dewan Chaman Lal; Tilak a moving spirit (N.M. Joshi a founder).
  • Strikes: Kharagpur railway workshops, TISCO Jamshedpur 🟣, Bombay textile mills (1,50,000 workers, 5 months), Buckingham & Carnatic Mills. 1928: strikes involving 5 lakh workers.
  • First May Day in India: Madras, 1923 (Singaravelu Chettiar).

E. Caste movements

Justice Party (Madras); Self-Respect Movement (1925) — Periyar; Satyashodhak activists (Satara); Bhaskar Rao Jadhav; Mahars under Ambedkar; radical Ezhavas (K. Aiyappan, C. Kesavan); Yadavs in Bihar 🟣 (Triveni Sangh later); Unionist Party — Fazl-i-Hussain (Punjab).

F. Revolutionary activity with a socialist turn (below)


3. Revolutionary activity — second phase ⭐⭐

Why it revived after NCM

  • Revolutionaries released under the 1920 amnesty (for Montford); Gandhi and C.R. Das persuaded many to join or suspend activity for NCM.
  • Sudden withdrawal of NCM disillusioned them; they rejected both parliamentary work and slow constructive work → turned to violence.
  • Most leaders had been NCM participants: Jogesh Chandra Chatterjee, Surya Sen, Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev, Chandrashekhar Azad, Shiv Verma, Bhagwati Charan Vohra, Jaidev Kapur, Jatin Das.
Influences: post-war working-class upsurge; Russian Revolution; new communist groups; journals extolling sacrifice (Atmasakti, Sarathi, Bijoli); books — Sachin Sanyal’s Bandi Jiwan, Sarat Chandra Chatterjee’s Pather Dabi (banned, hence more popular).

A. Punjab–UP–Bihar: HRA → HSRA

Date
Event
Oct 1924
Hindustan Republican Association/Army (HRA) founded at Kanpur by Ram Prasad Bismil, Jogesh Chandra Chatterjee, Sachin Sanyal; aim: armed revolution to set up a Federal Republic of the United States of India based on adult franchise. Manifesto (1925): abolish exploitation of man by man; organ Revolutionary proposed nationalising railways, steel, shipbuilding
9 Aug 1925
Kakori train robbery — 8-Down train looted near Lucknow. Bismil, Ashfaqullah Khan, Roshan Singh, Rajendra Lahiri hanged (Dec 1927); 4 transported for life, 17 jailed — a setback
1926
Bhagat Singh helped found the Naujawan Bharat Sabha (Lahore) — open wing among youth, peasants, workers; also the Lahore Students’ Union
Sept 1928
Meeting at Ferozeshah Kotla ruins, Delhi — under Chandrashekhar Azad, renamed Hindustan Socialist Republican Association (HSRA); collective leadership; socialism the official goal. Members: Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev, Bhagwati Charan Vohra (Punjab); Bejoy Kumar Sinha, Shiv Verma, Jaidev Kapur (UP); Bihar wing 🟣 — Yogendra Shukla, Baikunth Shukla
Oct 1928
Lala Lajpat Rai fatally injured in a lathi charge on the anti-Simon procession at Lahore (died 17 Nov 1928)
17 Dec 1928
Saunders’ murder (Lahore) — Bhagat Singh and Rajguru shot ASP John P. Saunders, mistaking him for SP James A. Scott (responsible for the lathi charge); Azad shot a pursuing constable. Justified as avenging a national insult
8 April 1929
Bomb in the Central Legislative Assembly — Bhagat Singh and Batukeshwar Dutt threw harmless bombs to protest the Public Safety Bill and Trade Disputes Bill — “to make the deaf hear”; courted arrest to use the trial for propaganda
1929
Lahore Conspiracy Case; hunger strike for political-prisoner status — Jatin Das died on the 63rd day (13 Sept 1929); Congress organised defence
Dec 1929
Azad’s bid to blow up Viceroy Irwin’s train near Delhi; 26 violent actions in Punjab in 1930
27 Feb 1931
Chandrashekhar Azad betrayed, surrounded at Alfred Park, Allahabad; shot himself rather than be captured (his Colt pistol in Allahabad Museum)
23 March 1931
Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev, Rajguru hanged (Lahore) for Saunders’ murder — now Shaheed Diwas; slogans “Inquilab Zindabad”, “Down with Imperialism”
🟣
Bihar & HSRA: Phanindranath Ghosh turned approver in the Lahore case; he was killed in Bettiah (1932) by Baikunth Shukla, who was hanged at Gaya jail (1934). Yogendra Shukla was a founder member of HSRA in Bihar.

B. Bengal

  • Many revolutionaries worked within Congress (helped C.R. Das). After Das (1925), Bengal Congress split: J.M. Sengupta (backed by Anushilan) vs Subhas Bose (backed by Yugantar).
  • 1924: Gopinath Saha tried to kill Calcutta Police Commissioner Charles Tegart (killed a man named Day instead); hanged. New ordinance; Subhas Bose arrested.
Chittagong Armoury Raid — 18 April 1930 ⭐⭐
  • Surya Sen (‘Masterda’) — NCM participant, national-school teacher, jailed 1926–28, secretary of Chittagong District Congress; “Humanism is a special virtue of a revolutionary”; admirer of Tagore and Nazrul Islam.
  • With Anant Singh, Ganesh Ghosh, Lokenath Baul — 65 activists of the Indian Republican Army – Chittagong Branch seized two armouries, cut telephone/telegraph and rail links; Sen hoisted the national flag and proclaimed a provisional revolutionary government; then guerrilla raids (Jalalabad Hill battle).
  • Surya Sen arrested Feb 1933, hanged January 1934.
New features in Bengal:
  • Large-scale participation of young women: Pritilata Waddedar (died leading a raid on the Pahartali European Club, 1932); Kalpana Dutt (life sentence with Surya Sen); Santi Ghosh and Suniti Chaudhury (Comilla schoolgirls, shot the District Magistrate, Dec 1931); Bina Das (fired at the Governor at the Calcutta University convocation, Feb 1932).
  • Group action against organs of the state instead of individual action.
  • Hindu religiosity shed (no oath rituals) → Muslims joined (Satar, Mir Ahmed, Fakir Ahmed Mian, Tunu Mian).
  • Drawbacks: some conservatism; no broader socio-economic goals; did not support Muslim peasants against zamindars.
  • Repression: ~20 repressive acts; villages burnt in Chittagong; Nehru jailed 2 years (1933) for praising revolutionaries.

C. Ideological rethinking — Bhagat Singh ⭐

  • Moved from individual heroism to Marxism and mass politics: revolution “by the masses, for the masses”; “real revolutionary armies are in villages and factories”.
  • Individual action still used as “propaganda by deed” and the courtroom as a platform, because ideas spread slowly.
  • Court statement: revolution “is not the cult of bomb and pistol” — it means the unjust order must change; aim: national liberation + a socialist order ending exploitation of man by man.
  • Class approach: peasants must be free of landlords and capitalists too; the struggle continues whether exploiters are British or Indian.
  • Thoroughly secular: Naujawan Bharat Sabha rules — no link with communal bodies; religion a personal matter; wrote Why I am an Atheist.
  • Bismil in his last days urged youth to give up pistols, join open movements, unite under Congress, and affirmed faith in communism.
  • The Philosophy of the Bomb — by Bhagwati Charan Vohra (reply to Gandhi’s The Cult of the Bomb).
  • Bhagat Singh: force used aggressively is violence; used for a legitimate cause it has moral justification.

🧠 Memory box

  • Swaraj Party: Gaya Dec 1922 → founded 1 Jan 1923 → Delhi Sept 1923 compromise → Nov 1923 polls (42/141) → Belgaum Dec 1924 (Gandhi presides) → Vithalbhai Speaker 1925 → Das dies 1925 → walkout Mar 1926 → out 1930.
  • HRA/HSRA: 1924 HRA (Kanpur) → 1925 Kakori → 1928 HSRA (Ferozeshah Kotla) → 1928 Saunders → 1929 Assembly bomb → 1929 Jatin Das (63 days) → 1931 Azad (27 Feb) → 1931 Bhagat-Sukhdev-Rajguru (23 Mar).
  • CPI: Tashkent 1920 → Kanpur case 1924 → Kanpur conference 1925 → Meerut case 1929.
  • Kakori four hanged: “B-A-R-R” = Bismil, Ashfaqullah, Roshan Singh, Rajendra Lahiri.

🎯 Exam traps

  • ⚠️ The Swaraj Party was formed after the Gaya session (1922), whose president was C.R. Das himself.
  • ⚠️ Gandhi presided over only one Congress session — Belgaum 1924.
  • ⚠️ Saunders was killed by mistake for Scott.
  • ⚠️ The Assembly bombs (8 April 1929) were thrown by Bhagat Singh and B.K. Dutt, not Rajguru; the three hanged were for Saunders’ murder.
  • ⚠️ AITUC first president = Lala Lajpat Rai (1920).
  • ⚠️ HRA founded at Kanpur (1924); renamed HSRA at Delhi (1928).