Sub-topics: Swarajists vs No-Changers · Socialist/communist ideas, youth, trade unions, caste movements · Revolutionary activity 2nd phase — HRA/HSRA, Kakori, Bhagat Singh, Chittagong.
1. Swarajists and No-Changers (1922–30) ⭐⭐Decline of the SwarajistsAchievementsDrawbacksConstructive work of No-Changers2. New forces of the 1920sA. Marxist and socialist ideas ⭐B. Youth activismC. Peasant agitationsD. Trade unionismE. Caste movementsF. Revolutionary activity with a socialist turn (below)3. Revolutionary activity — second phase ⭐⭐Why it revived after NCMA. Punjab–UP–Bihar: HRA → HSRAB. BengalChittagong Armoury Raid — 18 April 1930 ⭐⭐C. Ideological rethinking — Bhagat Singh ⭐🧠 Memory box🎯 Exam traps
1. Swarajists and No-Changers (1922–30) ⭐⭐
After Gandhi’s arrest (March 1922) the movement was disorganised; debate on what to do in the passive phase.
ㅤ | Swarajists (pro-changers) | No-Changers |
Leaders | C.R. Das, Motilal Nehru, Hakim Ajmal Khan (also Vithalbhai Patel, N.C. Kelkar) | C. Rajagopalachari, Vallabhbhai Patel, Rajendra Prasad, M.A. Ansari (Kasturi Ranga Iyengar) |
Stand | End boycott; enter councils to “end or mend” them — expose them, obstruct if demands rejected | Oppose council entry; constructive work; continue boycott; prepare for civil disobedience |
Arguments | Council entry = continuing NCM by other means, a new front; keeps masses enthused in a vacuum; keeps undesirable elements out; councils as arenas of struggle (not for gradual reform) | Parliamentary work breeds neglect of constructive work, loss of zeal, corruption |
- Gaya session (Dec 1922) (president C.R. Das 🟣) rejected council entry → Das resigned as president, Motilal as secretary → formed the Congress-Khilafat Swarajya Party (Swaraj Party), 1 January 1923: Das president, Motilal a secretary.
- Both sides avoided a 1907-type split. Delhi special session (Sept 1923) (president Maulana Azad, youngest president) allowed Swarajists to contest elections as a group within Congress.
- Swarajist manifesto (Oct 1923): British rule was selfish; reforms a blind for exploitation; demand self-government in the councils; if refused, “uniform, continuous and consistent obstruction” to wreck councils from within.
- Nov 1923 elections: won 42 of 141 elected central seats; clear majority in the Central Provinces; with Liberals and independents (Jinnah, Malaviya) formed a majority bloc.
- Gandhi (released Feb 1924) initially opposed but reconciled: opposing them would backfire; they worked courageously; crackdown on Swarajists/revolutionaries (late 1924) made him show solidarity. Belgaum session (Dec 1924) — the only session Gandhi presided over — accepted Swarajists working in councils as an integral part of Congress.
Decline of the Swarajists
- Communal riots; split into Responsivists (Lajpat Rai, Madan Mohan Malaviya, N.C. Kelkar — cooperate, hold office, protect “Hindu interests”) and Non-responsivists; government divided militants from moderates, Hindus from Muslims.
- Lost Muslim support by not backing (mostly Muslim) tenants against zamindars in Bengal.
- C.R. Das died June 1925.
- Main leadership walked out of legislatures in March 1926; the 1926 elections went badly (40 seats at centre; routed in UP, CP, Punjab).
- Final walkout in 1930 after the Lahore Purna Swaraj resolution and CDM.
Achievements
- With allies, out-voted the government several times, incl. budget grants; passed adjournment motions.
- Powerful speeches on self-government, civil liberties, industrialisation.
- Vithalbhai Patel elected Speaker (President) of the Central Legislative Assembly, 1925.
- Defeated the Public Safety Bill (1928) (to deport “subversive” foreigners spreading communism).
- Filled the political vacuum; exposed the hollowness of Montford; showed councils could be used creatively.
Drawbacks
No coordination with mass struggle outside (relied on newspaper reports); limits of obstruction; conflicts with coalition partners; succumbed to perks of office; failed Bengal peasants.
Constructive work of No-Changers
- Ashrams among tribals and lower castes (Kheda, Bardoli); charkha and khadi.
- National schools and colleges.
- Hindu–Muslim unity, anti-untouchability, boycott of foreign cloth and liquor, flood relief.
- Constructive workers became the backbone of later civil disobedience.
- Critique: national education benefited mainly urban lower middle class and rich peasants; khadi costlier than imports; untouchability tackled socially, not economically (landless labourers).
2. New forces of the 1920s
The 1920s: masses entered the movement; major political currents crystallised, partly as reactions (positive or negative) to Gandhism; strong international influence.
A. Marxist and socialist ideas ⭐
- Rise of a left wing in Congress — Jawaharlal Nehru and Subhas Bose: critical of both Swarajists and No-Changers; demanded Purna Swaraj; linked nationalism with social justice and class oppression by capitalists and landlords.
- Communist Party of India:
- 1920, Tashkent — founded by M.N. Roy, Abani Mukherji and others after the 2nd Comintern Congress (M.N. Roy first Indian in Comintern leadership).
- 1924 — Kanpur Bolshevik Conspiracy Case: S.A. Dange, Muzaffar Ahmed, Shaukat Usmani, Nalini Gupta jailed.
- 1925 — Indian Communist Conference, Kanpur formally founded the CPI (Satyabhakta).
- 1929 — Meerut Conspiracy Case: 31 communists, trade unionists, leftists arrested.
- Workers’ and Peasants’ Parties spread Marxism; communists stayed part of the national movement working with Congress.
B. Youth activism
Students’ leagues and conferences; Nehru presided over the All Bengal Students’ Conference (1928).
C. Peasant agitations
UP (tenancy law revision, lower rents, protection from eviction, debt relief); Rampa (Andhra); Rajasthan; ryotwari areas of Bombay and Madras; Bardoli Satyagraha (1928) under Vallabhbhai Patel (see page 26).
D. Trade unionism
- AITUC founded 1920 — first president Lala Lajpat Rai, general secretary Dewan Chaman Lal; Tilak a moving spirit (N.M. Joshi a founder).
- Strikes: Kharagpur railway workshops, TISCO Jamshedpur 🟣, Bombay textile mills (1,50,000 workers, 5 months), Buckingham & Carnatic Mills. 1928: strikes involving 5 lakh workers.
- First May Day in India: Madras, 1923 (Singaravelu Chettiar).
E. Caste movements
Justice Party (Madras); Self-Respect Movement (1925) — Periyar; Satyashodhak activists (Satara); Bhaskar Rao Jadhav; Mahars under Ambedkar; radical Ezhavas (K. Aiyappan, C. Kesavan); Yadavs in Bihar 🟣 (Triveni Sangh later); Unionist Party — Fazl-i-Hussain (Punjab).
F. Revolutionary activity with a socialist turn (below)
3. Revolutionary activity — second phase ⭐⭐
Why it revived after NCM
- Revolutionaries released under the 1920 amnesty (for Montford); Gandhi and C.R. Das persuaded many to join or suspend activity for NCM.
- Sudden withdrawal of NCM disillusioned them; they rejected both parliamentary work and slow constructive work → turned to violence.
- Most leaders had been NCM participants: Jogesh Chandra Chatterjee, Surya Sen, Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev, Chandrashekhar Azad, Shiv Verma, Bhagwati Charan Vohra, Jaidev Kapur, Jatin Das.
Influences: post-war working-class upsurge; Russian Revolution; new communist groups; journals extolling sacrifice (Atmasakti, Sarathi, Bijoli); books — Sachin Sanyal’s Bandi Jiwan, Sarat Chandra Chatterjee’s Pather Dabi (banned, hence more popular).
A. Punjab–UP–Bihar: HRA → HSRA
Date | Event |
Oct 1924 | Hindustan Republican Association/Army (HRA) founded at Kanpur by Ram Prasad Bismil, Jogesh Chandra Chatterjee, Sachin Sanyal; aim: armed revolution to set up a Federal Republic of the United States of India based on adult franchise. Manifesto (1925): abolish exploitation of man by man; organ Revolutionary proposed nationalising railways, steel, shipbuilding |
9 Aug 1925 | Kakori train robbery — 8-Down train looted near Lucknow. Bismil, Ashfaqullah Khan, Roshan Singh, Rajendra Lahiri hanged (Dec 1927); 4 transported for life, 17 jailed — a setback |
1926 | Bhagat Singh helped found the Naujawan Bharat Sabha (Lahore) — open wing among youth, peasants, workers; also the Lahore Students’ Union |
Sept 1928 | Meeting at Ferozeshah Kotla ruins, Delhi — under Chandrashekhar Azad, renamed Hindustan Socialist Republican Association (HSRA); collective leadership; socialism the official goal. Members: Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev, Bhagwati Charan Vohra (Punjab); Bejoy Kumar Sinha, Shiv Verma, Jaidev Kapur (UP); Bihar wing 🟣 — Yogendra Shukla, Baikunth Shukla |
Oct 1928 | Lala Lajpat Rai fatally injured in a lathi charge on the anti-Simon procession at Lahore (died 17 Nov 1928) |
17 Dec 1928 | Saunders’ murder (Lahore) — Bhagat Singh and Rajguru shot ASP John P. Saunders, mistaking him for SP James A. Scott (responsible for the lathi charge); Azad shot a pursuing constable. Justified as avenging a national insult |
8 April 1929 | Bomb in the Central Legislative Assembly — Bhagat Singh and Batukeshwar Dutt threw harmless bombs to protest the Public Safety Bill and Trade Disputes Bill — “to make the deaf hear”; courted arrest to use the trial for propaganda |
1929 | Lahore Conspiracy Case; hunger strike for political-prisoner status — Jatin Das died on the 63rd day (13 Sept 1929); Congress organised defence |
Dec 1929 | Azad’s bid to blow up Viceroy Irwin’s train near Delhi; 26 violent actions in Punjab in 1930 |
27 Feb 1931 | Chandrashekhar Azad betrayed, surrounded at Alfred Park, Allahabad; shot himself rather than be captured (his Colt pistol in Allahabad Museum) |
23 March 1931 | Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev, Rajguru hanged (Lahore) for Saunders’ murder — now Shaheed Diwas; slogans “Inquilab Zindabad”, “Down with Imperialism” |
Bihar & HSRA: Phanindranath Ghosh turned approver in the Lahore case; he was killed in Bettiah (1932) by Baikunth Shukla, who was hanged at Gaya jail (1934). Yogendra Shukla was a founder member of HSRA in Bihar.
B. Bengal
- Many revolutionaries worked within Congress (helped C.R. Das). After Das (1925), Bengal Congress split: J.M. Sengupta (backed by Anushilan) vs Subhas Bose (backed by Yugantar).
- 1924: Gopinath Saha tried to kill Calcutta Police Commissioner Charles Tegart (killed a man named Day instead); hanged. New ordinance; Subhas Bose arrested.
Chittagong Armoury Raid — 18 April 1930 ⭐⭐
- Surya Sen (‘Masterda’) — NCM participant, national-school teacher, jailed 1926–28, secretary of Chittagong District Congress; “Humanism is a special virtue of a revolutionary”; admirer of Tagore and Nazrul Islam.
- With Anant Singh, Ganesh Ghosh, Lokenath Baul — 65 activists of the Indian Republican Army – Chittagong Branch seized two armouries, cut telephone/telegraph and rail links; Sen hoisted the national flag and proclaimed a provisional revolutionary government; then guerrilla raids (Jalalabad Hill battle).
- Surya Sen arrested Feb 1933, hanged January 1934.
New features in Bengal:
- Large-scale participation of young women: Pritilata Waddedar (died leading a raid on the Pahartali European Club, 1932); Kalpana Dutt (life sentence with Surya Sen); Santi Ghosh and Suniti Chaudhury (Comilla schoolgirls, shot the District Magistrate, Dec 1931); Bina Das (fired at the Governor at the Calcutta University convocation, Feb 1932).
- Group action against organs of the state instead of individual action.
- Hindu religiosity shed (no oath rituals) → Muslims joined (Satar, Mir Ahmed, Fakir Ahmed Mian, Tunu Mian).
- Drawbacks: some conservatism; no broader socio-economic goals; did not support Muslim peasants against zamindars.
- Repression: ~20 repressive acts; villages burnt in Chittagong; Nehru jailed 2 years (1933) for praising revolutionaries.
C. Ideological rethinking — Bhagat Singh ⭐
- Moved from individual heroism to Marxism and mass politics: revolution “by the masses, for the masses”; “real revolutionary armies are in villages and factories”.
- Individual action still used as “propaganda by deed” and the courtroom as a platform, because ideas spread slowly.
- Court statement: revolution “is not the cult of bomb and pistol” — it means the unjust order must change; aim: national liberation + a socialist order ending exploitation of man by man.
- Class approach: peasants must be free of landlords and capitalists too; the struggle continues whether exploiters are British or Indian.
- Thoroughly secular: Naujawan Bharat Sabha rules — no link with communal bodies; religion a personal matter; wrote Why I am an Atheist.
- Bismil in his last days urged youth to give up pistols, join open movements, unite under Congress, and affirmed faith in communism.
- The Philosophy of the Bomb — by Bhagwati Charan Vohra (reply to Gandhi’s The Cult of the Bomb).
- Bhagat Singh: force used aggressively is violence; used for a legitimate cause it has moral justification.
🧠 Memory box
- Swaraj Party: Gaya Dec 1922 → founded 1 Jan 1923 → Delhi Sept 1923 compromise → Nov 1923 polls (42/141) → Belgaum Dec 1924 (Gandhi presides) → Vithalbhai Speaker 1925 → Das dies 1925 → walkout Mar 1926 → out 1930.
- HRA/HSRA: 1924 HRA (Kanpur) → 1925 Kakori → 1928 HSRA (Ferozeshah Kotla) → 1928 Saunders → 1929 Assembly bomb → 1929 Jatin Das (63 days) → 1931 Azad (27 Feb) → 1931 Bhagat-Sukhdev-Rajguru (23 Mar).
- CPI: Tashkent 1920 → Kanpur case 1924 → Kanpur conference 1925 → Meerut case 1929.
- Kakori four hanged: “B-A-R-R” = Bismil, Ashfaqullah, Roshan Singh, Rajendra Lahiri.
🎯 Exam traps
- ⚠️ The Swaraj Party was formed after the Gaya session (1922), whose president was C.R. Das himself.
- ⚠️ Gandhi presided over only one Congress session — Belgaum 1924.
- ⚠️ Saunders was killed by mistake for Scott.
- ⚠️ The Assembly bombs (8 April 1929) were thrown by Bhagat Singh and B.K. Dutt, not Rajguru; the three hanged were for Saunders’ murder.
- ⚠️ AITUC first president = Lala Lajpat Rai (1920).
- ⚠️ HRA founded at Kanpur (1924); renamed HSRA at Delhi (1928).