Notes · History

09 · Rise of Nationalism, Pre-Congress Associations & the Moderates

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

9 min read6 sections

09 · Rise of Nationalism, Pre-Congress Associations & the Moderates

📌
Sub-topics: Factors in the growth of modern nationalism · Political associations before 1885 · Foundation of INC · Moderate phase (1885–1905).

1. Factors in the growth of modern nationalism ⭐

Indian nationalism grew partly as a result of colonial policies and partly as a reaction to them — a mix of: the worldwide spread of nationalism and self-determination after the French Revolution; the Indian Renaissance; modernisation introduced by the British; and strong reaction to imperialist policies.
  1. Understanding the contradiction between Indian and colonial interests — people realised colonial rule caused India’s backwardness and harmed all classes (peasants, artisans, workers, intellectuals, capitalists).
  1. Political, administrative and economic unification — British India stretched from the Himalayas to Cape Comorin and Assam to the Khyber; one civil service, unified judiciary, codified civil and criminal law; railways, roads, telegraph, electricity (built for British administration, defence and trade). Effects: regions’ economic fates got linked; leaders from different regions could meet and exchange ideas.
  1. Western thought and education — Milton, Shelley, J.S. Mill, Rousseau, Paine, Spencer, Voltaire taught rational, secular, democratic ideas; English became a link language; those educated in England compared free institutions there with denial of rights in India. This middle-class intelligentsia led the political associations.
  1. Press and literature — rapid growth of Indian-owned English and vernacular papers: about 169 vernacular papers by 1877 with ~1,00,000 circulation; criticised policy, urged unity, spread ideas of self-government and democracy.
  1. Rediscovery of India’s past — European scholars (Max Mueller, Monier Williams, Roth, Sassoon) and Indian (R.G. Bhandarkar, R.L. Mitra, later Vivekananda) revealed a glorious past; the theory that Indo-Aryans shared ancestry with Europeans boosted confidence; demolished the myth of perpetual servility.
  1. Progressive reform movements removed divisions and brought sections together.
  1. Rise of the middle-class intelligentsia — Percival Spear: “a dynamic minority” with a common foreground of knowledge and values; led the INC at every stage.
  1. World movements — new nations in South America; liberation movements in Greece, Italy, and especially Ireland.
  1. Reactionary policies and racial arrogance — especially under Lytton (1876–80):
      • ICS maximum age cut from 21 to 19 (1876);
      • grand Delhi Durbar (1877) during a terrible famine;
      • Vernacular Press Act (1878); Arms Act (1878);
      • then the Ilbert Bill controversy (1883) under Ripon: the bill let Indian judges try Europeans; European agitation forced a dilution (a jury half-European). Lesson: no justice when European interests were involved — but Europeans also taught Indians how to organise an agitation.

2. Political associations before the INC ⭐⭐

Early associations (first half of the 19th c.) were dominated by wealthy, aristocratic elements, were local/regional, and sent long petitions to the British Parliament for administrative reform, more Indians in administration, and education. After 1850s the educated middle class (lawyers, journalists, doctors, teachers) took over with a wider agenda.
Association
Year
Founders
Key points
Bangabhasha Prakasika Sabha
1836
Associates of Rammohan Roy
Earliest political body in Bengal
Zamindari Association / Landholders’ Society
1838
Dwarkanath Tagore, Prasanna Kumar Tagore, Radhakant Deb
Landlords’ interests; beginning of organised political activity and constitutional agitation
Bengal British India Society
1843
(George Thompson with Derozians)
Collect and spread information on the people’s condition; peaceful means
British Indian Association
1851
Merger of the above two (Radhakant Deb pres., Debendranath Tagore secy.)
Petition for Charter renewal: separate popular legislature, separation of executive and judiciary, lower salaries of high officials, abolition of salt duty, abkari and stamp duties → partly met by Charter Act 1853 (6 members added to GG’s council for legislation)
Madras Native Association
1852
—
—
Bombay Association
1852
Jagannath Shankarsheth
—
East India Association
1866, London
Dadabhai Naoroji
Influence British public opinion on Indian welfare; branches later in Indian cities
Poona Sarvajanik Sabha
1867 (1870)
M.G. Ranade and others
Bridge between government and people
Indian League
1875
Sisir Kumar Ghosh
“Stimulate the sense of nationalism”; political education
Indian Association of Calcutta (Indian National Association) ⭐
1876
Surendranath Banerjea & Ananda Mohan Bose
Most important pre-Congress body; younger nationalists unhappy with pro-landlord British Indian Association; aim: strong public opinion and unity on a common programme; ICS agitation against age cut (1877) — simultaneous exams in India and England, Indianisation; campaigns against Arms and Vernacular Press Acts; low membership fee; All-India National Conference, Calcutta, 28–30 Dec 1883 (100+ delegates) and 1885; merged with INC in 1886
Madras Mahajan Sabha
1884
M. Viraraghavachari, G. Subramania Aiyer, P. Ananda Charlu
—
Bombay Presidency Association
1885
Badruddin Tyabji, Pherozeshah Mehta, K.T. Telang
—

Pre-Congress campaigns

  1. Import duty on cotton (1875) — against its removal;
  1. Indianisation of government service (1878–79);
  1. Against Lytton’s Afghan adventure;
  1. Against the Arms Act (1878);
  1. Against the Vernacular Press Act (1878);
  1. Right to join volunteer corps;
  1. Against plantation labour conditions and the Inland Emigration Act;
  1. In support of the Ilbert Bill;
  1. An All-India Fund for Political Agitation;
  1. Campaign in Britain to vote for a pro-India party;
  1. ICS agitation against reducing the maximum age.

3. Foundation of the Indian National Congress (1885) ⭐⭐

  • Ground was ready by the late 1870s–early 1880s. A.O. Hume, a retired English civil servant, gave it final shape (first as the Indian National Union, 1884).
  • First session: Gokuldas Tejpal Sanskrit College, Bombay, 28–31 December 1885 — 72 delegates, President W.C. (Womesh Chunder) Bonnerjee. (Originally planned at Poona; shifted due to cholera.)
  • Preceded by the two sessions of the Indian National Conference (1883, 1885) — architects Surendranath Banerjea and Ananda Mohan Bose.
  • Thereafter met every December in a different city.
  • Great early presidents: Dadabhai Naoroji (thrice: 1886, 1893, 1906), Badruddin Tyabji (1887, first Muslim), George Yule (1888, first Englishman), Pherozeshah Mehta, P. Ananda Charlu, Surendranath Banerjea, R.C. Dutt, Ananda Mohan Bose, G.K. Gokhale. Other leaders: Ranade, Tilak, Sisir Kumar and Motilal Ghosh, Madan Mohan Malaviya, G. Subramania Aiyer, C. Vijayaraghavachariar, D.E. Wacha.
  • 1890: Kadambini Ganguly, first woman graduate of Calcutta University, addressed the Congress (Calcutta session).

Was it a “safety valve”? ⭐

Theory
Meaning
Associated with
Safety Valve
Hume founded it to release Indian discontent safely; got Dufferin’s approval
Lala Lajpat Rai (Extremists) — Lajpat Rai first used it to attack the Moderates
Conspiracy
Born of a conspiracy to abort a popular uprising, with bourgeois leaders party to it
Marxist R.P. Dutt
Lightning Conductor
Indians used Hume as a catalyst/shield; an Indian-founded body would have faced official hostility
G.K. Gokhale; elaborated by Bipan Chandra
Modern historians reject the safety-valve theory: the INC reflected the genuine urge of politically conscious Indians for a national body.

Aims of the early Congress

  1. Found a democratic, nationalist movement;
  1. Politicise and politically educate people;
  1. Establish a headquarters for the movement;
  1. Promote friendship among nationalist workers of all regions;
  1. Develop and spread an anti-colonial ideology;
  1. Present common demands to unite people on a common programme;
  1. Build national unity across religion, caste and province;
  1. Nurture Indian nationhood.

4. The Moderates (1885–1905)

Leaders: Dadabhai Naoroji, Pherozeshah Mehta, D.E. Wacha, W.C. Bonnerjee, S.N. Banerjea, Gokhale — believers in liberalism.

Methods

  • Constitutional agitation within the law; slow, orderly progress.
  • Belief that the British were basically just but ill-informed; so create public opinion and present demands through resolutions, petitions, memorials, meetings — “prayer and petition” (the 3 Ps: prayer, petition, protest).
  • Two-pronged: (1) arouse national consciousness and unite people; (2) persuade the British government and British public.
  • British Committee of the INC in London (1889) with journal India; Dadabhai spent much of his life and income in England; plan to hold a Congress session in London (1892) dropped due to British elections.
  • Believed the British connection was in India’s interest at that stage; aimed to make colonial rule as close to national rule as possible.
  • Ranade to Gokhale (1891): memorials are nominally to the government, really to the people — to teach them to think politically.

Contributions ⭐

1. Economic critique of imperialism — Dadabhai Naoroji, R.C. Dutt, D.E. Wacha developed the Drain Theory; opposed turning India into a colonial economy (raw material supplier, market for finished goods, field for British capital). Created all-India opinion that British rule caused India’s poverty. Demanded: lower land revenue, abolition of salt tax, better conditions for plantation labour, cuts in military spending, protection and aid to modern industry.
2. Constitutional reforms and work in legislatures:
  • Councils under the Indian Councils Act 1861 were powerless; only 45 Indians nominated 1862–92, mostly loyalist landlords (exceptions: Syed Ahmed Khan, Kristodas Pal, V.N. Mandlik, K.L. Nulkar, Rashbehari Ghosh).
  • 1885–92 demands: expansion of councils (more Indians) and reform (more powers, esp. over finance).
  • Result: Indian Councils Act 1892:
    • Imperial Council non-officials raised to 10–16 (from 6–10);
    • non-officials nominated on recommendation of universities, municipalities, zamindars, chambers of commerce (Bengal Chamber of Commerce, provincial councils) — principle of representation (indirect election) introduced;
    • members could discuss the budget and ask questions;
    • limits: official majority; no voting/amending budget; no supplementaries; the council met only ~13 days a year (till 1909).
  • After 1892 they demanded a majority of elected Indians and control over the budget — slogan “No taxation without representation”.
  • Self-government like Canada/Australia demanded by Dadabhai (1904), Gokhale (1905), Tilak (1906); Dadabhai at Calcutta 1906 used the word “Swaraj”.
  • Councils, meant to let off “steam”, became forums to expose bureaucracy and debate public finance (Pherozeshah Mehta, Gokhale). Weakness: did not demand adult franchise or include masses/women.
3. General administrative reforms:
  • Indianisation of services — economic (cheaper), political (salaries and pensions of Britons = drain), moral (discrimination).
  • Separation of judiciary from executive.
  • Criticism of oppressive bureaucracy and costly, slow justice.
  • Criticism of aggressive foreign policy (Burma annexation, Afghan wars, NW tribal campaigns) paid from Indian revenue.
  • More spending on welfare, health, sanitation, education (elementary and technical), irrigation, agriculture, agricultural banks.
  • Better treatment of Indian labour in other British colonies.
4. Defence of civil rights — speech, association, free press; public outrage at the arrest of Tilak (1897) and deportation of the Natu brothers without trial (1897).

Evaluation

  • Represented the most progressive forces of the time; created a national awakening and a feeling of one nation.
  • Trained people in politics; popularised modern ideas.
  • Exposed the exploitative character of colonial rule, undermining its moral basis.
  • Politics based on hard economic reality, not religion or sentiment.
  • Established that India must be ruled in Indians’ interest.
  • Built a base for the later mass movement.
  • Failure: narrow social base; masses passive — Moderates lacked faith in the masses, wanting them “welded into a nation” first; hence no militant stand.
💬
Views — Pattabhi Sitaramayya: the Moderates were the bricks buried in the foundation that made the superstructure possible. Bipan Chandra: 1858–1905 was the seed time of Indian nationalism; the early nationalists sowed well. Lala Lajpat Rai: an “opportunist movement”.

Government’s attitude

  • Hostile from the start; hardened after 1887 when the Congress refused to limit itself to social issues.
  • Nationalists called “seditious Brahmins”, “disloyal babus”; Dufferin called the Congress a “factory of sedition” and a “microscopic minority”.
  • Divide and rule: officials encouraged Syed Ahmed Khan and Raja Shiv Prasad Singh of Benaras to form the United Indian Patriotic Association (1888) against the Congress; set Moderates against Extremists (carrot and stick).
  • Curzon (1900): the Congress is “tottering to its fall” and he hoped to assist its “peaceful demise”.

🧠 Memory box

  • Bengal associations chain: 1836 Bangabhasha → 1838 Landholders’ → 1843 Bengal British India Society → 1851 British Indian Association → 1875 Indian League → 1876 Indian Association → 1883 National Conference → 1886 merged into INC.
  • “Bombay 1885”: Bombay Presidency Association + first INC session.
  • Theories: Safety valve – Lajpat Rai; Conspiracy – R.P. Dutt; Lightning conductor – Gokhale/Bipan Chandra.
  • First session: 72 delegates, W.C. Bonnerjee, Gokuldas Tejpal Sanskrit College.

🎯 Exam traps

  • ⚠️ The East India Association (1866) was founded in London by Dadabhai, not in India.
  • ⚠️ The Indian Association (1876) was founded by S.N. Banerjea and A.M. Bose, not by Hume.
  • ⚠️ Lytton cut the ICS age from 21 to 19 in 1876.
  • ⚠️ Indian Councils Act 1892 allowed discussion of the budget, not voting on it.
  • ⚠️ Dufferin = “factory of sedition”; Curzon = “peaceful demise”.