Sub-topics: Rise of Extremists · Partition of Bengal · Swadeshi & Boycott (1905–11) · Moderates vs Extremists · Surat Split (1907) · Muslim League (1906) · Morley-Minto Reforms (1909).
1. Why militant nationalism grew (1890s → 1905) ⭐2. Partition of Bengal ⭐⭐3. The Swadeshi and Boycott Movement ⭐⭐Phase 1: Moderate-led anti-partition campaign (1903–05)Congress positionPhase 2: Extremist leadership (1905–08)New forms of struggleExtent of mass participationAnnulment of partition (1911)Why the movement fizzled out by 1908Why it was a turning point4. Moderates vs Extremists ⭐⭐5. The Surat Split (December 1907) ⭐⭐Run-upThe splitGovernment repressionGovernment strategy — “carrot and stick” / “rallying the Moderates” (Morley)6. All-India Muslim League (1906)7. Morley-Minto Reforms — Indian Councils Act, 1909 ⭐⭐🧠 Memory box🎯 Exam traps
1. Why militant nationalism grew (1890s → 1905) ⭐
- True nature of British rule recognised — no major demand met; economic misery: famines of 1896–1900 killed ~90 lakh; bubonic plague in the Deccan; riots. The government was taking away even existing rights:
- 1892 Indian Councils Act — disappointing;
- 1897 Natu brothers deported without trial; Tilak and others jailed for sedition;
- 1898 IPC 124A amplified and new Section 153A added;
- 1899 Calcutta Corporation Act reduced Indian members;
- 1904 Official Secrets Act curbed the press;
- 1904 Indian Universities Act — tighter control over universities (seen as factories of political agitators). Also, British rule was no longer socially progressive (blocked mass and technical education).
- Growth of confidence and self-respect — Tilak, Aurobindo, B.C. Pal urged reliance on Indians’ own strength; faith in the masses.
- Education — more awareness, but also educated unemployment.
- International influences — Japan’s rise after 1868; Ethiopia defeated Italy (Adwa, 1896); British reverses in the Boer War (1899–1902); Japan defeated Russia (1905); movements in Ireland, Russia, Egypt, Turkey, Persia, China.
- Reaction to Westernisation — inspiration from Vivekananda, Bankim Chandra, Dayananda (“India for the Indians”).
- Dissatisfaction with the Moderates — the “three Ps” (prayer, petition, protest) called “political mendicancy”.
- Curzon’s reactionary rule (1899–1905) — “missions, commissions and omissions”; called nationalist activity “letting off gas”; Official Secrets Act, Universities Act, Calcutta Corporation Act and above all the Partition of Bengal.
- A militant school of thought — Raj Narain Bose, Ashwini Kumar Dutta, Aurobindo Ghosh, Bipin Chandra Pal (Bengal); Vishnu Shastri Chiplunkar, B.G. Tilak (Maharashtra); Lala Lajpat Rai (Punjab). Tilak the most outstanding. Tenets: hatred of foreign rule; swaraj as the goal; direct political action; faith in the masses; personal sacrifice.
- Trained leadership ready to channel mass energy — released in the anti-partition/Swadeshi movement.
Tilak: “The Extremists of today will be the Moderates of tomorrow.” · Tilak: “Swaraj is my birthright and I shall have it.” · Karachi Chronicle (1905): if Japan can drub Russia, India can drub England.
2. Partition of Bengal ⭐⭐
- Proposal made public December 1903; formally announced July 1905; came into force 16 October 1905. Viceroy: Curzon.
- Plan: Bengal (West Bengal + Bihar 🟣 + Orissa; capital Calcutta) and Eastern Bengal & Assam (capital Dacca).
- Official reason: Bengal (78 million, ~¼ of British India) too big to administer; Assam would develop.
- Real motive: weaken Bengal, the nerve centre of nationalism:
- by language — Bengalis a minority in new Bengal (17 million Bengalis vs 37 million Hindi and Oriya speakers);
- by religion — West: Hindu majority (42 of 54 million); East: Muslim majority (18 of 31 million).
- Curzon wooed Muslims: Dacca as capital would give them unity not seen since the old Muslim viceroys.
- Risley (Home Secretary, 1904): “Bengal united is a power; Bengal divided will pull in several different ways… One of our main objects is to split up… a solid body of opponents.”
3. The Swadeshi and Boycott Movement ⭐⭐
Phase 1: Moderate-led anti-partition campaign (1903–05)
- Leaders: Surendranath Banerjea, K.K. Mitra, Prithwishchandra Ray.
- Methods: petitions, public meetings, memoranda, propaganda in Hitabadi, Sanjibani, Bengalee.
- After the July 1905 announcement, boycott pledges taken in small towns.
- 📅 7 August 1905: Boycott Resolution at a massive meeting in the Calcutta Town Hall — formal proclamation of the Swadeshi Movement; boycott of Manchester cloth and Liverpool salt.
- 16 October 1905 (partition day): day of mourning — fasting, bathing in the Ganga, barefoot processions singing Bande Mataram (theme song); Tagore’s ‘Amar Sonar Bangla’ (now Bangladesh’s anthem) sung; on the appeal of Tagore and Ramendrasundar Trivedi (Bangiya Sahitya Parishad), Raksha Bandhan observed — rakhis tied as a symbol of unity; Surendranath and A.M. Bose addressed huge crowds; Rs 50,000 raised in hours.
- Spread: Poona & Bombay — Tilak; Punjab — Lajpat Rai & Ajit Singh; Delhi — Syed Haider Raza; Madras — V.O. Chidambaram Pillai.
Congress position
- Benaras 1905 (Gokhale): condemned partition and Curzon’s policies; supported Swadeshi and boycott in Bengal (compromise).
- Extremists (Tilak, Lajpat, Pal, Aurobindo = “Lal-Bal-Pal” + Aurobindo) wanted it all-India and a full political mass struggle for swaraj.
- Calcutta 1906 (Dadabhai Naoroji): goal declared “self-government or swaraj like the United Kingdom or the colonies” (Australia, Canada); resolutions on swadeshi, boycott, national education — “Swaraj” mentioned for the first time.
Phase 2: Extremist leadership (1905–08)
Why Extremists took over: Moderate methods failed; divisive tactics of the two Bengal governments; repression — caning of students, ban on singing Vande Mataram in public, curbs on meetings, prosecution, deportations, press censorship.
Programme: swadeshi + boycott + passive resistance — boycott of government schools and colleges, services, courts, councils, municipalities, titles. Aurobindo: make administration impossible by organised refusal. “Political freedom is the lifebreath of a nation.” The goal of independence became central.
New forms of struggle
- Boycott of foreign goods — public burning of foreign cloth; boycott of foreign salt and sugar; priests refused rites, washermen refused to wash foreign clothes.
- Public meetings and processions.
- Samitis (volunteer corps) — Swadesh Bandhab Samiti of Ashwini Kumar Dutta (Barisal); Swadeshi Sangam at Tirunelveli (V.O. Chidambaram Pillai, Subramania Siva). Magic-lantern lectures, songs, physical training, famine relief, schools, arbitration courts.
- Traditional festivals and melas — Tilak’s Ganapati (1893) and Shivaji (1895) festivals; folk theatre (jatras) in Bengal.
- Self-reliance (‘atma shakti’) — national dignity, village regeneration, campaigns against caste, child marriage, dowry, alcohol.
- National education:
- Raja Subodh Mullick gave Rs 1 lakh for a national university;
- National Council of Education — 15 August 1906;
- Bengal National College (first principal Aurobindo Ghosh; president Rashbehari Ghosh) and Bengal Technical Institute; inspired by Tagore’s Shantiniketan (1901); national schools also in Bihar 🟣; vernacular medium; students sent to Japan.
- Satishchandra Mukherjee — paper Dawn (1897), Dawn Society (1902), Bhagabat Chatuspathi (1895); later principal of Bengal National College.
- Swadeshi enterprises — textile mills, soap and match factories, tanneries, banks, insurance (more patriotism than business sense). Earlier: Tagore’s Swadeshi Bhandar (1897), Jogeshchandra Chaudhuri’s Indian Stores (1901), Sarala Devi’s Lakshmir Bhandar (1903), P.C. Ray’s Bengal Chemicals (1893). V.O. Chidambaram Pillai’s Swadeshi Steam Navigation Company at Tuticorin challenged the British India Steam Navigation Co.
- Sakharam Ganesh Deuskar’s Desher Katha (1904) — popularised Naoroji and Ranade; warned of the “hypnotic conquest of the mind”; sold 15,000+ copies; banned 1910.
- Culture — songs by Tagore, Rajnikant Sen, Dwijendralal Ray, Mukunda Das, Syed Abu Muhammad; Subramania Bharati’s Sudesha Geetham. Art: Abanindranath Tagore broke Victorian naturalism (inspired by Ajanta, Mughal, Rajput art); Nandalal Bose — first scholarship of the Indian Society of Oriental Art (1907). Science: J.C. Bose, P.C. Ray.
Extent of mass participation
- Students: picketing; in Bengal, Poona, Guntur, Madras, Salem; government threatened disaffiliation, loss of grants, scholarships and jobs (Carlyle Circular).
- Women: urban middle-class women joined processions and picketing — a lasting change.
- Muslims: some joined (Barrister Abdul Rasul, Liaqat Hussain, Guznavi, Maulana Azad — who joined a revolutionary group), but most upper/middle-class Muslims under Nawab Salimullah of Dacca supported partition. Hindu religious symbols used by leaders tended to exclude Muslims.
- Labour: Sept 1905 — 250+ Bengali clerks of Burn Company, Howrah walked out; July 1906 — East Indian Railway strike → Railwaymen’s Union; jute mill strikes (1906–08); Subramania Siva & Chidambaram Pillai led strikes at Tuticorin/Tirunelveli (foreign cotton mill, Coral Mills); Rawalpindi arsenal and railway strikes (Lajpat Rai, Ajit Singh). Subsided by mid-1908.
- Social base: sections of zamindars, students, women, urban lower middle class; failed to win Muslim peasantry (divide and rule, class–community overlap).
Annulment of partition (1911)
- Announced at the Delhi Durbar (12 Dec 1911) (King George V; Viceroy Hardinge II) — mainly to curb revolutionary terrorism.
- Capital shifted from Calcutta to Delhi (as a sop to Muslims; Delhi associated with Muslim glory — they were not pleased).
- Bihar and Orissa separated from Bengal (new province from 1 April 1912) 🟣; Assam a separate province again.
Why the movement fizzled out by 1908
- Severe repression.
- No effective organisation/party structure — it threw up Gandhian techniques (non-cooperation, passive resistance, filling jails, constructive work) but without disciplined focus.
- Leaderless by 1908 — arrests, deportations; Aurobindo and B.C. Pal retired.
- Surat split (1907).
- Could not channel released energy into new forms.
- Confined to upper/middle classes and zamindars; did not reach peasants.
- Non-cooperation and passive resistance remained ideas.
- Hard to sustain a mass movement at high pitch for long.
Why it was a turning point
- A “leap forward”: students, women, workers, some urban and rural people joined; all major trends of the later movement (moderation, extremism, revolutionary activity, incipient socialism, petitions, passive resistance, non-cooperation) appeared.
- Enriched art, literature, science and industry.
- Undermined the hegemony of colonial ideas; future struggles drew on its experience.
4. Moderates vs Extremists ⭐⭐
Basis | Moderates | Extremists |
Social base | Zamindars, upper middle class in towns | Educated middle and lower middle class |
Inspiration | Western liberal thought, European history | Indian history, cultural heritage, Hindu symbols |
British role | Believed in England’s “providential mission” | Rejected it as an illusion |
British connection | In India’s interest | Perpetuates exploitation |
Loyalty | Loyal to the Crown | Crown unworthy of loyalty |
Masses | Not ready; limited to intelligentsia | Immense faith in the masses |
Demands | Constitutional reforms, share in services | Swaraj as the cure-all |
Methods | Strictly constitutional | Extra-constitutional too — boycott, passive resistance |
Evaluation of the Extremists: leaders differed (Tilak: self-government; Aurobindo: complete independence). They broadened the social base and raised patriotism from an “academic pastime” to “service and sacrifice”. But they were socially conservative with revivalist undertones — Tilak opposed the Age of Consent Bill (1891) (raising girls’ age from 10 to 12; his objection: reform should come from self-government, not alien rule), organised Ganapati/Shivaji festivals, supported anti-cow-killing campaigns; Pal and Aurobindo spoke of a Hindu nation — alienating Muslims and mixing religion with politics.
5. The Surat Split (December 1907) ⭐⭐
Run-up
- Benaras 1905 (Gokhale): Extremists wanted boycott extended outside Bengal and to government service, courts, councils; Moderates refused. A mild compromise resolution averted a split.
- Calcutta 1906: Extremists wanted Tilak or Lajpat Rai as president; Moderates proposed Dadabhai Naoroji (accepted by all). Concessions: goal of swaraj/self-government; resolutions on swadeshi, boycott, national education. “Swaraj” undefined → different interpretations.
- Extremists then called for wide passive resistance; Moderates, hoping for council reforms from the Liberal government (Morley), toned it down.
- Extremists thought the battle for freedom had begun and Moderates were a drag; Moderates feared ruthless suppression and wanted to grab the reforms. Neither saw that reforms were meant to isolate the Extremists, that Moderates were a shield against repression, or that only a broad united movement could succeed.
The split
- Extremists wanted the 1907 session at Nagpur with Tilak or Lajpat Rai as president and reaffirmation of the 1906 resolutions.
- Moderates moved it to Surat (Tilak’s home province — a host-province leader could not preside), proposed Rashbehari Ghosh as president, and sought to drop the swadeshi/boycott/national education resolutions.
- Rigid stands → split; Congress came under Moderates, who reaffirmed self-government within the Empire by constitutional means only (Allahabad convention 1908 adopted a constitution excluding Extremists).
Government repression
- New laws: Seditious Meetings Act (1907); Newspapers (Incitement to Offences) Act (1908); Criminal Law Amendment Act (1908); Indian Press Act (1910).
- Tilak tried (1908) for Kesari articles on the Muzaffarpur bomb 🟣 (which killed two European women) — he argued real cure was granting Swarajya; sentenced to 6 years’ transportation + Rs 1,000 fine, sent to Mandalay (Burma), released 1914. (Earlier, in 1897, he had been jailed for sedition.) His dock statement is engraved at the Bombay High Court (plaque unveiled by M.C. Chagla, 1956).
- Aurobindo and B.C. Pal retired; Lajpat Rai went abroad.
- Extremists couldn’t form an alternative party; Moderates had no popular base. National movement declined after 1908 until 1914.
Government strategy — “carrot and stick” / “rallying the Moderates” (Morley)
Three-pronged: repression–conciliation–suppression: mildly repress Extremists to scare Moderates → placate Moderates with concessions, hinting at more if they kept away from Extremists → crush isolated Extremists → then ignore Moderates. The Surat split showed it worked.
6. All-India Muslim League (1906)
- Simla Deputation (1 October 1906): Muslim elites led by the Aga Khan met Viceroy Minto — demanded separate electorates and representation beyond their numbers (“value of contribution to the defence of the empire”). Minto was sympathetic (called a “command performance”).
- All-India Muslim League founded at Dacca, 30 December 1906 (during the All-India Muhammadan Educational Conference) by Nawab Salimullah of Dacca with Nawab Mohsin-ul-Mulk and Waqar-ul-Mulk; first president Aga Khan (permanent). Aims: loyalty to the British, protect Muslim rights, keep Muslim intelligentsia away from the Congress; supported partition.
7. Morley-Minto Reforms — Indian Councils Act, 1909 ⭐⭐
Secretary of State John Morley + Viceroy Lord Minto (II); aim: placate Moderates and Muslims. Gokhale lobbied Morley in London.
Provisions:
- Elective principle recognised for non-official seats (on the basis of class and community).
- Separate electorates for Muslims introduced — Muslims alone vote for Muslim candidates (Minto = “Father of Communal Electorate”).
- Elected members increased; non-official majority in provincial councils (but with nominated members, non-elected majority remained). Central council still official majority.
- Imperial Legislative Council (Sumit Sarkar’s figures): 69 members — 37 officials + 32 non-officials (5 nominated + 27 elected: 8 Muslim separate seats, 4 British capitalists, 2 landlords, 13 general).
- Indirect election: local bodies → electoral college → provincial councils → central council (“infiltration through sieves”).
- Muslims got weightage beyond population and lower income qualification for voters.
- Legislatures could move resolutions, ask supplementaries, vote on separate items of the budget (not the budget as a whole).
- One Indian in the Viceroy’s Executive Council — Satyendra Prasanno Sinha (Law Member, 1909), first Indian.
Evaluation: no answer to Indian problems. Morley openly rejected parliamentary/responsible government for India. Aimed to confuse Moderates and divide Indians via separate electorates (benefiting a tiny Muslim elite). Parliamentary forms without responsibility → irresponsible criticism. Gokhale used councils well (universal primary education, repression, indentured labour). “Shadow rather than substance” — “benevolent despotism”. Nehru: separate electorates were a barrier that grew with every extension of franchise “like some canker”.
🧠 Memory box
- Swadeshi timeline: Dec 1903 proposal → July 1905 announced → 7 Aug 1905 Boycott resolution (Town Hall) → 16 Oct 1905 partition + Raksha Bandhan → Dec 1905 Benaras (Gokhale) → 15 Aug 1906 National Council of Education → 1 Oct 1906 Simla Deputation → 30 Dec 1906 Muslim League + Calcutta session (Swaraj) → Dec 1907 Surat split → 1908 Tilak to Mandalay → 1909 Morley-Minto → 12 Dec 1911 annulment.
- “Lal-Bal-Pal” = Lala Lajpat Rai (Punjab), Bal Gangadhar Tilak (Maharashtra), Bipin Chandra Pal (Bengal).
- Who led Swadeshi where: Tilak–Poona/Bombay · Lajpat & Ajit Singh–Punjab · Syed Haider Raza–Delhi · V.O. Chidambaram Pillai–Madras/Tuticorin.
- Morley-Minto: “SEPARATE” — Separate electorates, Elective principle, Provincial non-official majority, Ask supplementaries, Resolutions, Additional members, Tiered (indirect) elections, Executive council Indian (S.P. Sinha).
🎯 Exam traps
- ⚠️ Boycott Resolution: 7 Aug 1905; Partition effective: 16 Oct 1905.
- ⚠️ The word “Swaraj” first in Congress: Calcutta 1906, Dadabhai Naoroji.
- ⚠️ Surat 1907 president = Rashbehari Ghosh (Moderate).
- ⚠️ Muslim League founded at Dacca, not Aligarh; Simla Deputation led by Aga Khan.
- ⚠️ First Indian in Viceroy’s Executive Council = S.P. Sinha (1909).
- ⚠️ Partition annulled in 1911 by Hardinge, not Minto.