Notes · History

18 · Strategy Debates 1934–37, GoI Act 1935 & Congress Ministries

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

9 min read6 sections

18 · Strategy Debates 1934–37, GoI Act 1935 & Congress Ministries

📌
Sub-topics: Debates after CDM (council entry, Nehru’s S-V vs Gandhi’s S-T-S) · GoI Act 1935 (political view) · Office acceptance debate · 1937 elections · 28 months of Congress rule (1937–39). The constitutional details of the 1935 Act are also on page 23.

1. First-stage debate (1934–35): what to do after CDM?

Three views:
  1. Constructive work on Gandhian lines.
  1. Constitutional struggle / council entry — contest the 1934 Central Legislative Assembly elections: M.A. Ansari, Asaf Ali, Bhulabhai Desai, S. Satyamurthy, B.C. Roy. Arguments: keeps up interest and morale in a period of apathy; doesn’t mean faith in constitutionalism; another front to build Congress; brings prestige.
  1. Leftists (Nehru) — reject both; continue non-constitutional mass struggle as the situation was still revolutionary (economic crisis).

Nehru’s vision

  • “The basic goal… is abolition of capitalism and establishment of socialism.”
  • Called withdrawal of CDM and council entry a “spiritual defeat”, “surrender of ideals”, “retreat from revolutionary to reformist mentality”.
  • Wanted class organisations (kisan sabhas, trade unions) affiliated to the Congress; no genuine anti-imperialism without the class struggle of the masses.

S-T-S vs S-V

  • Gandhi’s Struggle–Truce–Struggle (S-T-S): a mass phase must be followed by a truce to let masses recoup and give the government a chance to respond; then struggle again.
  • Nehru’s Struggle–Victory (S-V): after Lahore’s Purna Swaraj call, continuous confrontation till imperialism is overthrown; “real power cannot be won by two annas and four annas”.

Outcome

  • Gandhi accepted council entry for those unable to do satyagraha or constructive work, provided they did not get sucked into constitutionalism.
  • May 1934, AICC at Patna 🟣 set up a Parliamentary Board to fight elections under the Congress itself.
  • Congress Socialist Party formed (founding conference Patna, 17 May 1934 🟣; first conference Bombay, Oct 1934) — Acharya Narendra Dev (president), Jayaprakash Narayan (general secretary), Minoo Masani, Asoka Mehta, Ram Manohar Lohia, Achyut Patwardhan (later history on page 28; JP's life on page 32).
  • October 1934: Gandhi resigned from the Congress (primary membership) to serve it better, aware he was out of tune with parliamentarians, critics of the charkha (“second lung of the nation”) and socialists.
  • Leftists preferred to radicalise Congress gradually rather than split — unity against imperialism came first.
  • Nov 1934 Central Assembly elections: Congress won 45 of 75 seats reserved for Indians.

2. Government of India Act, 1935 ⭐⭐ (political essentials)

Outcome of the 3rd RTC → White Paper (1933) → Joint Select Committee → passed August 1935.

All-India Federation (never came into being)

  • To include British Indian provinces, Chief Commissioners’ provinces and princely states.
  • Conditional on: (i) states with 52 seats in the Council of States agreeing to join; (ii) their population being 50% of all states’ population. Not fulfilled → centre continued under the 1919 Act till 1946.

Federal (centre)

  • Governor-General the pivot.
  • Dyarchy at the centre: Reserved subjects — foreign affairs, defence, tribal areas, ecclesiastical affairs — by GG with executive councillors (not responsible). Transferred — all others, by ministers responsible to the legislature.
  • GG’s “special responsibilities” and “individual judgement”.
  • Bicameral legislature: Council of States (260) — permanent, ⅓ retire every 3 years, 40% nominated by princes, the rest directly elected (odd!); Federal Assembly (375) — 5 years, ⅓ nominated by princes, rest indirectly elected.
  • Three lists: Federal, Provincial, Concurrent; residuary powers with the GG.
  • No-confidence only in the Federal Assembly. 80% of budget non-votable.
  • Communal and class electorates extended. GG could restore cuts, certify bills, issue ordinances, veto.

Provincial autonomy

  • Dyarchy abolished in provinces; provinces got autonomy and separate legal identity, deriving authority directly from the Crown; freed from “superintendence, direction” of the Secretary of State and GG; own finances, could borrow.
  • Governor = Crown’s nominee with special powers (minorities, civil servants, law and order, British business, excluded areas, states); could take over administration indefinitely.
  • All members directly elected; separate electorates per the Communal Award; franchise extended; women on the same basis as men.
  • Ministers (council of ministers headed by a Premier) responsible to and removable by the legislature; 40% budget non-votable; governor could refuse assent, issue ordinances, enact Governor’s Acts.

Evaluation

  • “Safeguards” and “special responsibilities” acted as brakes; governors kept wide powers.
  • Enfranchised only ~14% of British Indian population.
  • Extended communal electorates → separatism → partition.
  • Rigid; amendment only by the British Parliament.
  • Nehru: “a car, all brakes and no engine”; “a charter of slavery”. Linlithgow: framed “as the best way… of maintaining British influence in India”.

Long-term British strategy behind it

  • Repression is short-term; long-term aim: weaken the movement by integrating large segments into constitutional and administrative structures.
  • Revive liberals and moderates; convince Congressmen that extra-legal struggle is futile; once Congressmen taste power they won’t return to sacrifice.
  • Divide Congress — placate the right, crush the left.
  • Provincial autonomy would create powerful provincial leaders and provincialise the Congress.

Response

Condemned by nearly all; unanimously rejected by Congress, which demanded a Constituent Assembly elected by adult franchise. Hindu Mahasabha and the Liberals favoured working it.

3. Second-stage debate (1936–37): office acceptance

Against office (leftists)
For office
Nehru, Subhas Bose, Congress Socialists, Communists
Mainstream (Patel, Rajendra Prasad, Rajaji)
Office = working the Act we rejected; responsibility without power; would blunt the revolutionary edge
Only a short-term tactic when mass struggle isn’t possible; office or not is strategy, not socialism; don’t leave the field to reactionaries; ministries can promote constructive work
Counter-plan: enter councils to create deadlocks (Swarajist method); long-term reliance on workers and peasants
Fight wrong tendencies rather than abandon office
  • Gandhi first opposed office acceptance in the CWC but by early 1936 was willing to try it.
  • Lucknow (April 1936, Nehru) and Faizpur (Dec 1936, Nehru — first village session) decided to contest elections, postponing the office decision; resolution: “not to submit to this constitution… but to combat it both inside and outside the legislatures”.
  • March 1937: AICC/CWC permitted office acceptance (after assurances from the Viceroy that governors would not interfere routinely).

1937 provincial elections (February 1937)

  • In 11 provinces: Madras, CP, Bihar 🟣, Orissa, UP, Bombay, Assam, NWFP, Bengal, Punjab, Sindh.
  • ~30.1 million enfranchised (incl. 4.25 million women; ~14% of population); 15.5 million voted.
  • Congress manifesto: total rejection of the 1935 Act; release of prisoners; end of gender and caste disabilities; radical agrarian change; cut in rent and revenue; scaling down of rural debt; cheap credit; right to unionise and strike. Gandhi addressed no election meeting.
  • Result: Congress won 716 of 1,161 seats contested (total 1,585); majority in all provinces except Bengal, Assam, Punjab, Sindh, NWFP; largest party in Bengal, Assam, NWFP. Muslim League did poorly (won only ~109 of 482 Muslim seats). Nehru reconciled to S-T-S.

4. Congress rule in the provinces (July 1937 – Oct/Nov 1939) ⭐

Ministries in Bombay, Madras, Central Provinces, Orissa, United Provinces, Bihar 🟣, later NWFP and Assam (8 provinces). A Central Control Board (“Parliamentary Sub-Committee”) of Patel, Maulana Azad, Rajendra Prasad guided them.
🟣
Bihar ministry: Premier (Prime Minister) Sri Krishna Sinha, with Anugrah Narayan Sinha (finance). In Feb 1938, the Bihar and UP ministries resigned when the Governors refused the release of political prisoners; the Viceroy gave way and they returned (Haripura session supported them). Bihar passed tenancy amendments (1937–38) amid the Kisan Sabha’s Bakasht agitation (page 26).

Gandhi’s advice

Hold office “lightly, not tightly”; offices are “crowns of thorns”; use them in ways not intended by the British; show Congress can rule with minimum help from police and army.

Work done in 28 months

Civil liberties: emergency laws repealed; bans on organisations (Hindustani Seva Dal, Youth Leagues) and books lifted; press curbs removed; arms licences restored; police powers curbed, CID stopped shadowing politicians; political prisoners released; deportation orders revoked; Bombay restored CDM-confiscated lands; pensions restored.
  • Blemishes: Yusuf Meherally and S.S. Batliwala (socialists) arrested in Madras; Bombay Home Minister K.M. Munshi used the CID against communists.
Agrarian reforms — laws on land reform, debt relief, forest grazing fees, rent arrears, tenures; but zamindari was not abolished. Constraints: limited powers; little money (centre took the lion’s share); need to conciliate zamindars; short time; war clouds (1938); landlord-dominated upper houses in UP, Bihar, Bombay, Madras, Assam; complex structure. Benefits went mainly to statutory/occupancy tenants; sub-tenants and agricultural labourers gained little.
Labour — advance workers’ interests while keeping industrial peace; compulsory arbitration before strikes; wage increases; but militant protests treated as law-and-order issues (Section 144, arrests); Bombay Trade Disputes Act 1938 seen as anti-labour. Nehru privately unhappy; Gandhi wanted political education of masses, not colonial methods.
Social welfare: prohibition in some areas; Harijan welfare (temple entry, public facilities, scholarships, more jobs in services and police); primary, technical, higher education; public health; khadi subsidies; prison reforms; indigenous enterprise; National Planning Committee (1938) under Congress president Subhas Bose (chaired by Nehru). Basic education (Wardha scheme, 1937).
Extra-parliamentary activity: mass literacy campaigns; Congress police stations and panchayats; Congress Grievance Committees; states’ people’s movements.

Evaluation

  • Showed self-government is necessary for social transformation; that a movement can use state power without being co-opted.
  • Controlled communal riots; lowered bureaucracy’s morale; neutralised hostile landlords; people saw a preview of freedom; destroyed the myth that Indians can’t rule.
  • But: internal strife, opportunism, hunger for power by 1939; workers’ hopes raised then partly dashed; dilemma over Praja Mandal movements in princely states.
  • Muslim League’s Pirpur Committee Report (1938) accused Congress ministries of interfering in religious rites, suppressing Urdu for Hindi, denying representation and economically oppressing Muslims (also the Shareef Report on Bihar 🟣 and Fazlul Huq’s report).
  • Congress ministries resigned in October–November 1939 over India’s unilateral involvement in WWII → League observed “Deliverance Day” (22 Dec 1939).

🧠 Memory box

  • Patna May 1934 = Parliamentary Board (+ CSP founding meeting). Oct 1934 = Gandhi quits Congress. Nov 1934 = 45/75 seats.
  • 1935 Act numbers: Council of States 260, Federal Assembly 375, federation needs 52 seats + 50% population of states; 80% central budget non-votable; 14% franchise.
  • 1937: 716 seats; ministries in 8 provinces; 28 months; resigned Oct 1939.
  • Gandhi’s phrases: “lightly, not tightly”, “crowns of thorns”, “second lung of the nation” (charkha).

🎯 Exam traps

  • ⚠️ The 1935 Act introduced dyarchy at the centre (never implemented) and abolished it in provinces.
  • ⚠️ Residuary powers under the 1935 Act were with the Governor-General.
  • ⚠️ In the 1935 Act, the Council of States was directly elected and the Federal Assembly indirectly.
  • ⚠️ Faizpur (1936) was the first Congress session held in a village.
  • ⚠️ Congress did not form a ministry in Bengal or Punjab in 1937 (Fazlul Huq’s KPP–League and Sikandar Hayat’s Unionists).