Notes · History

23 · Constitutional, Administrative & Judicial Developments 1773–1947

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

15 min read10 sections

23 · Constitutional, Administrative & Judicial Developments 1773–1947

📌
Sub-topics: British Acts (1773–1935) · Civil services · Police · Army · Judiciary · Central/provincial/local administration. Very high yield for Act-wise statement questions (also tested in Polity).

1. Background

After Buxar (1764) the Company got the Diwani of Bengal, Bihar, Orissa (1765); deputy diwans Mohammad Reza Khan (Bengal) and Raja Shitab Rai (Bihar) 🟣. 1767: first British government intervention — demanded a share of £4 lakh (400,000) a year. Dual Government (1765–72): authority without responsibility; corruption, private trade, over-collection, oppression; Company bankrupt while servants grew rich → Parliament stepped in.

2. Constitutional development 1773–1858 ⭐⭐⭐

Regulating Act, 1773 (PM Lord North)

  • First step of British government control/regulation of the Company; recognised its political and administrative role; introduced centralised administration.
  • Directors to submit all revenue, civil and military correspondence to the government (British cabinet’s first right of control).
  • Governor of Bengal became Governor-General of Bengal with an Executive Council of 4, decisions by majority. First GG: Warren Hastings (council: Clavering, Monson, Francis, Barwell named in the Act).
  • Supreme Court at Calcutta (1774) — original and appellate jurisdiction (Chief Justice Elijah Impey); its jurisdiction vis-à-vis the council was disputed.
  • Governors of Bombay and Madras made (vaguely) subordinate to the GG of Bengal.
  • Company servants barred from private trade and taking presents/bribes. Based on checks and balances.
  • Amending Act 1781 (Act of Settlement): defined Supreme Court jurisdiction (within Calcutta; personal law of the defendant); government servants immune for official acts; social and religious usages to be respected.

Pitt’s India Act, 1784

  • Company became a subordinate department of the State; territories called “British possessions in India”.
  • Board of Control (Chancellor of Exchequer, a Secretary of State, 4 Privy Councillors) to control civil, military, revenue affairs; Court of Directors managed commerce → dual system of control.
  • GG’s council reduced to 3 (incl. Commander-in-Chief); Bombay and Madras clearly subordinated.
  • Ban on aggressive wars and treaties (often breached).

Act of 1786

  • Cornwallis got the powers of both GG and Commander-in-Chief and the right to override his council on his responsibility (later extended to all GGs).

Charter Act, 1793

  • Company’s trade privileges renewed for 20 years.
  • Company to pay £5 lakh annually to the British government after expenses.
  • Royal approval required for appointment of GG, Governors, C-in-C.
  • Senior officials couldn’t leave India without permission (= resignation).
  • Company could license individuals and employees to trade in India — “privilege” or “country trade” → opium shipments to China.
  • Revenue administration separated from judiciary → Maal Adalats disappeared.
  • Home Government members paid from Indian revenues (continued till 1919).

Charter Act, 1813

  • Pressure from British business (laissez-faire; Napoleon’s Continental System closed European ports).
  • Company’s trade monopoly in India ended — retained monopoly of trade with China and in tea.
  • Dividend of 10.5% to shareholders.
  • Company to hold territories for 20 more years “without prejudice to the sovereignty of the Crown” — constitutional position of British territories defined for the first time.
  • Rs 1 lakh a year for revival and promotion of literature, learning and science — first state responsibility for education.
  • Regulations of the three councils to be laid before Parliament; separate commercial and territorial accounts; Board of Control enlarged.
  • Christian missionaries allowed to come and preach.

Charter Act, 1833 (Saint Helena Act)

  • Lease extended 20 years; territories governed in the name of the Crown.
  • Ended all commercial activity — monopoly of China trade and tea ended; Company became purely administrative.
  • Restrictions on European immigration and property acquisition lifted (way to European colonisation).
  • Centralisation: Governor-General of Bengal became Governor-General of India (first: William Bentinck) with control over all civil and military affairs and all revenues/expenditure; Madras and Bombay lost legislative powers (could only propose laws).
  • A Law Member added to the GG’s council (first: Macaulay) for law-making advice.
  • Indian laws to be codified (Law Commission under Macaulay).
  • No Indian to be denied office by religion, colour, birth, descent (sheet-anchor of later agitation, though not implemented).
  • Steps to improve slaves’ condition; slavery abolished 1843.

Charter Act, 1853

  • Company to continue till Parliament decided otherwise (no fixed term).
  • Court of Directors reduced to 18.
  • Company’s patronage ended — civil services open to competitive examination (Macaulay Committee, 1854).
  • Law Member made a full member of the Executive Council.
  • Separation of executive and legislative functions: 6 additional members for legislation → Indian (Central) Legislative Council (mini-parliament); local representation introduced (4 of 6 from provincial governments); GG could veto bills.

Government of India Act, 1858 (Act for the Better Government of India)

  • India governed by and in the name of the Crown through a Secretary of State (British cabinet member; first: Lord Stanley) with a Council of India of 15 (advisory); Board of Control and Court of Directors abolished → end of dual system.
  • GG became Viceroy (first: Canning).
  • “A decent burial to an already dead horse.”

3. Developments after 1858 ⭐⭐

Indian Councils Act, 1861

  • Non-official representatives in legislatures accepted; law-making by deliberation.
  • Viceroy’s Executive Council: a 5th member (jurist) added; for legislation 6–12 additional members, at least half non-official (Indian or English) — Raja of Benares, Maharaja of Patiala, Sir Dinkar Rao nominated (1862).
  • Portfolio system (Canning) — foundation of cabinet government.
  • Restored legislative powers to Bombay and Madras; provision for councils in other provinces (Bengal 1862, NWFP 1886, Punjab 1897) — legislative devolution.
  • Viceroy could issue ordinances (6 months) in emergencies.
  • Weaknesses: no financial discussion without approval; no budget control; no discussion of executive action; Viceroy’s approval needed and Secretary of State could disallow; non-officials were elite loyalists.

Indian Councils Act, 1892

  • In response to Congress (“reform of councils is the root of all other reforms”).
  • Non-officials increased (central 10–16); universities, district boards, municipalities, zamindars, chambers of commerce could recommend members — indirect election (the word “election” avoided).
  • Could discuss the budget (financial statement) and ask questions (6 days’ notice); no voting on budget, no supplementaries.

Indian Councils Act, 1909 (Morley-Minto)

  • First attempt at a representative, popular element; enlarged councils; first Indian in the Viceroy’s Executive Council — Satyendra Prasanna Sinha (Law Member).
  • Separate electorates for Muslims, weightage, lower voting qualification; very indirect elections; real power with government (details page 10).

Government of India Act, 1919 (Montford)

  • British Parliament, not Indians, to decide each step.
  • Bicameral central legislature (Council of State + Legislative Assembly) with directly elected majorities (restricted franchise).
  • Separate electorates extended to Sikhs, Indian Christians, Anglo-Indians, Europeans.
  • Dyarchy in provinces; unicameral provincial legislatures.
  • Separated provincial and central budgets.
  • High Commissioner for India in London (6-year term; trade functions).
  • Secretary of State paid by the British exchequer.
  • Central Legislature could vote supplies but couldn’t remove the government; GG could certify laws. A “non-sovereign law-making body” (Subhash Kashyap). Statutory Commission after 10 years.

Simon Commission → RTCs → White Paper (March 1933) → Joint Parliamentary Committee (Linlithgow, report 1934) → GoI Act 1935

Government of India Act, 1935 ⭐⭐

  • Lengthy: 321 sections and 10 schedules.
  • All-India Federation of provinces and acceding states (via Instrument of Accession) — never came into being.
  • Dyarchy at the centre (federal executive); dyarchy abolished in provinces → provincial autonomy (from 1 April 1937).
  • Bicameral federal legislature (Council of States permanent); joint sitting for deadlocks.
  • Three lists — Federal, Provincial, Concurrent; residuary powers to the GG; GG’s veto; King-in-Council could disallow.
  • Provinces derived authority from the Crown; own finances; could borrow.
  • Bicameralism in six provinces — Madras, Bombay, Bengal, UP, Bihar 🟣, Assam.
  • Communal electorates and weightage extended to depressed classes, women, labour.
  • Franchise ~10% of population (14% of British India).
  • Federal Court (set up 1937) — original and appellate jurisdiction; Privy Council above it.
  • Council of India (of the Secretary of State) abolished.
  • Burma separated (1937); Orissa and Sindh new provinces (1936); RBI, Federal Railway Authority, PSCs provided.
  • Centre continued under the 1919 Act; the operative parts lasted till 15 Aug 1947. A written constitution without Indian participation; rigid; amendable only by Parliament.

Later steps

August Offer (1940) → Cripps (1942) → C.R. Formula (1944) → Wavell Plan (1945) → Cabinet Mission (1946) → Mountbatten Plan & Indian Independence Act (1947).

4. Evolution of the Civil Services ⭐

Stage
Development
Cornwallis (1786–93) — “father of civil services”
Raised salaries; enforced ban on private trade; no presents/bribes; promotion by seniority. But believed “every native of Hindustan is corrupt”; Charter Act 1793 reserved posts worth £500+ a year for covenanted (British) servants
Wellesley
Fort William College (1800) for training recruits; replaced (1806) by the East India College, Haileybury (England, 2-year training)
Charter Act 1833
Theoretically open to Indians (not implemented)
Charter Act 1853
Open competitive examination
Queen’s Proclamation 1858
Indians to be admitted freely and impartially
Indian Civil Service Act 1861
Certain posts reserved for covenanted service; exam in London, in English, with Greek and Latin; max age cut 23 (1859) → 22 (1860) → 21 (1866) → 19 (1878)
1863/64
Satyendranath Tagore — first Indian to qualify for the ICS
Statutory Civil Service (1878–79, Lytton)
1/6 of covenanted posts by nomination of Indians of high families — failed, abolished
Congress demand (1885 →)
Raise age limit; simultaneous exams in India and England
Aitchison Committee (1886, Dufferin)
Drop “covenanted/uncovenanted”; three tiers — Imperial ICS (exam in England), Provincial and Subordinate services (in India); age limit to 23
1893
House of Commons resolution for simultaneous exams — never implemented (Kimberley: an adequate number must always be European)
Montford (1919)
Simultaneous exams; ⅓ recruitment in India, rising 1.5% a year (first simultaneous exam 1922)
Lee Commission (1923–24)
Secretary of State to recruit ICS, Irrigation, Forest services; provinces to recruit for transferred fields; 50:50 Indian–European parity in 15 years; set up a Public Service Commission (est. 1926)
GoI Act 1935
Federal PSC and Provincial PSCs
Evaluation: Indians systematically excluded from key, well-paid posts; Indianisation after 1918 did not transfer real power — Indian officers served imperial interests.

5. Evolution of the Police

  • Pre-colonial: village watchmen; Mughal faujdars, amils (revenue + rebels), kotwal in towns. During dual rule, zamindars kept thanedars (often colluded with dacoits).
  • 1770: faujdars and amils abolished; 1774 Warren Hastings restored faujdars; 1775 faujdari thanas in big towns.
  • 1791 — Cornwallis: regular police; modernised thanas under a daroga (Indian) and an SP at the district; relieved zamindars of police duties (“father of the modern police”).
  • 1808: an SP for each division with spies (goyendas) — they oppressed people (Lord Minto I).
  • 1814: darogas abolished except in Bengal.
  • Bentinck: abolished SPs; Collector/Magistrate headed police; Commissioner as SP — overburdened.
  • Police Commission 1860 → Indian Police Act 1861: civil constabulary with village watchman linked to the system; IG (province), DIG (range), SP (district). No all-India police; uniform ranks.
  • 1902–03 Police Commission (Sir Andrew Fraser, Curzon): direct recruitment of senior officers; training schools; more strength and pay; Criminal Intelligence Department at the centre and CIDs in provinces. (1929: CID split into Special Branch, CID, Crime Branch.)
  • Police curbed thuggee and dacoity, but were unsympathetic and used against the national movement.

6. The Army under the British

  • Before 1857: Queen’s army + Company’s army (European and native regiments with British officers).
  • After 1857 (Dufferin, 1888: remember the lessons of 30 years ago): prevent another revolt; defend India from Russia, Germany, France; Indian branch for expansion in Asia and Africa, British branch as an army of occupation.
  • European dominance: Peel Commission (1859) and Eden Commission (1879) — at least ⅓ white (vs 14% before 1857); ratio 1:2 in Bengal Army, 2:5 in Madras and Bombay armies; Europeans monopolised artillery, tanks, armoured corps and key locations; Indians got inferior rifles till 1900; highest Indian rank subedar till 1914; King’s commissions only from 1918; Indian Sandhurst (Skeen) Committee (1926) foresaw 50% Indian officers only by 1952.
  • Divide and rule (“balance and counterpoise”): 1879 Commission — “counterpoise of natives against natives”. “Martial races” theory (C-in-C Lord Roberts, 1887–92) favoured Sikhs, Gurkhas, Pathans; soldiers from Awadh, Bihar 🟣, Central and South India (rebels of 1857) declared “non-martial”; caste/communal companies mixed to balance each other. Charles Wood: Sikh should fire into Hindu, Gurkha into either. Soldiers isolated from newspapers and nationalist ideas.
  • A costly military machine.

7. Development of the Judiciary ⭐

  • Pre-colonial: caste elders, panchayats, zamindars for Hindus; qazis for Muslims; ruler the fountain of justice (often arbitrary).
  • 1726: Mayor’s Courts at Madras, Bombay, Calcutta — beginning of common law based on precedent.

Warren Hastings (1772–85)

  • District Diwani Adalats (civil) under the Collector; Hindu law for Hindus, Muslim law for Muslims; appeal to Sadar Diwani Adalat (President + 2 council members).
  • District Faujdari Adalats (criminal) under an Indian officer with qazis and muftis (Muslim law), supervised by the Collector; capital cases to Sadar Nizamat Adalat at Murshidabad (deputy nizam + chief qazi + chief mufti).
  • Supreme Court, Calcutta (1774) under the Regulating Act — jurisdiction clashes.

Cornwallis (1786–93) — separation of powers

  • District Faujdari Courts abolished; Circuit Courts (European judges) at Calcutta, Dacca, Murshidabad, Patna 🟣 — appeals civil and criminal.
  • Sadar Nizamat Adalat shifted to Calcutta, under GG and council with chief qazi and mufti.
  • District Diwani Adalat → District/Zila Court under a District Judge; Collector only for revenue (no magisterial role).
  • Gradation of civil courts: Munsiff (Indian) → Registrar (European) → District Court → 4 Circuit Courts → Sadar Diwani Adalat (Calcutta) → King-in-Council (appeals £5,000+).
  • Cornwallis Code (1793): separation of revenue and judicial administration; Europeans also under jurisdiction; officials answerable to civil courts; sovereignty of law.

Bentinck (1828–35)

  • 4 Circuit Courts abolished; functions to Collectors under Commissioners of Revenue and Circuit.
  • Sadar Diwani and Sadar Nizamat Adalats at Allahabad for Upper Provinces.
  • Persian or vernacular in lower courts; English replaced Persian in the Supreme Court (1835).

Later

  • 1833: Law Commission under Macaulay → Civil Procedure Code (1859), Indian Penal Code (1860), Criminal Procedure Code (1861).
  • 1860: Europeans lost special privileges except in criminal cases (no Indian judge could try them — cf. Ilbert Bill 1883).
  • 1865: Supreme Court and Sadar Adalats merged into High Courts at Calcutta, Bombay, Madras (Indian High Courts Act 1861; Allahabad 1866; Patna High Court 1916 🟣).
  • 1935 Act: Federal Court (1937).
Positive: rule of law; codified laws replaced rulers’ personal/religious laws; Europeans under jurisdiction (criminal cases only by European judges); officials answerable to courts. Negative: complicated, expensive (favoured the rich); false evidence and chicanery; delays; overburdened courts; European judges unfamiliar with Indian customs.

8. Administrative structure after 1858

A new stage of colonialism

Lessons of 1857 (narrow ruler–subject gap, associate natives); spread of industrial revolution, rivalry of new industrial powers (USA, Japan, Europe) for colonies; British capital in railways, loans, plantations, coal, jute, shipping, banking → consolidation and reactionary policies under Lytton, Dufferin, Lansdowne, Elgin, Curzon.

Central government

  • Secretary of State (with Council of 15) in London held real power → Viceroy subordinate; British industrialists, merchants, bankers gained influence; administration more reactionary than before 1858.

Provincial government and financial decentralisation

  • Presidencies (Bombay, Madras, Bengal) under Governors + council of 3 (Crown appointees); other provinces under Lt-Governors / Chief Commissioners (GG appointees).
  • 1870 — Lord Mayo: first step to separate central and provincial finances — fixed grants for police, jails, education, medical services, roads.
  • 1877 — Lord Lytton: land revenue, excise, general administration, law and justice transferred; provinces got a fixed share of income from stamps, excise, income tax.
  • 1882 — Lord Ripon: revenue sources divided into general (centre), provincial, and divided.
  • Centre stayed supreme; all subordinate to the Secretary of State.

Local bodies ⭐

Why: financial strain from over-centralisation; transplant European civic amenities; nationalist demand for basic facilities; associate Indians without weakening British supremacy; local taxes for local welfare (avoid taxing rich or burdening treasury).
Stage
Feature
1864–68
First local bodies — nominated members, headed by District Magistrates; tax-collecting tools
Mayo’s Resolution (1870)
Financial decentralisation; provinces could levy local taxes; “local interest, supervision and care” needed for education, sanitation, medical relief, public works; municipal Acts in Bengal, Madras, NWP, Punjab
Ripon’s Resolution (18 May 1882) ⭐
“Magna Carta of local self-government”; Ripon = “father of local self-government”: local bodies as instruments of political and popular education; urban and rural bodies with definite duties and revenues; non-official majority (elected where possible); non-official chairmen; official control only to check, not dictate; sanction needed for loans, new taxes, big works, bye-laws. Acts of 1883–85. Drawbacks: elected minority in district boards; tiny franchise; district boards still under officials; government could suspend/supersede. Curzon increased official control
Royal Commission on Decentralisation (1907–09)
Village panchayats to get powers (petty cases, minor works, schools, fuel/fodder) and income; sub-district boards in every taluka/tehsil; remove tax restrictions; municipalities to take primary education
GoI Resolution 1915
Official views — mostly on paper
Resolution of May 1918
After the August Declaration — local bodies as representative as possible with real authority (first step to responsible government)
Dyarchy (1919)
Local self-government a transferred subject, but finance reserved → little progress
Simon Commission (1930)
Panchayats progressed only in UP, Bengal, Madras; suggested more provincial control (retrograde); criticised finances
1935 Act
Provincial autonomy and popular control of finance helped; but tax powers stayed limited
Free India
Article 40 (DPSP); 73rd and 74th Amendments (1992)

🧠 Memory box

  • Act ladder: 1773 Regulating → 1781 Settlement → 1784 Pitt → 1786 → 1793 → 1813 → 1833 → 1853 → 1858 → 1861 → 1892 → 1909 → 1919 → 1935 → 1947.
  • “Firsts”: GG of Bengal 1773 (Hastings) · GG of India 1833 (Bentinck) · Viceroy 1858 (Canning) · Law Member 1833 (Macaulay) · open competition 1853 · portfolio system 1861 (Canning) · Indian in Executive Council 1909 (S.P. Sinha) · bicameral centre 1919 · Federal Court 1937 · PSC 1926.
  • Trade monopoly ends: India 1813; China & tea 1833.
  • Education money: Rs 1 lakh, 1813.
  • ICS age: 23 → 22 → 21 → 19 (Lytton 1878) → 23 (Aitchison).
  • Local self-govt: Mayo 1870 → Ripon 1882 → Decentralisation Commission 1909 → 1918 resolution.

🎯 Exam traps

  • ⚠️ The 1833 Act (not 1813) made the GG of Bengal the GG of India and ended the Company’s commercial role.
  • ⚠️ The Secretary of State was paid from Indian revenue from 1793 until the 1919 Act.
  • ⚠️ Dual control (Board of Control + Court of Directors) began with Pitt’s Act 1784 and ended in 1858.
  • ⚠️ The 1935 Act had bicameral legislatures in six provinces including Bihar.
  • ⚠️ Circuit courts (Cornwallis) were at Calcutta, Dacca, Murshidabad and Patna.
  • ⚠️ IPC = 1860; CrPC = 1861; CPC = 1859.