Sub-topics: Haripura & Tripuri crisis · Gandhi vs Bose ideas · Congress response to WWII · Ministries resign · Ramgarh 1940 · Lahore (Pakistan) Resolution · August Offer · Individual Satyagraha · Nehru as successor · Cripps Mission.
1. Crisis over method of struggle (1938–39)Subhas Chandra Bose — backgroundHaripura session (February 1938, Gujarat) ⭐1939 presidential election and Tripuri (March 1939) ⭐⭐2. Gandhi vs Bose — ideological differences3. Congress response to World War II ⭐CWC at Wardha (10–14 Sept 1939)Government response and resignationsRamgarh session (March 1940) 🟣4. Lahore (Pakistan) Resolution — 23 March 1940 ⭐⭐5. August Offer — 8 August 1940 ⭐6. Individual Satyagraha (Oct 1940 – 1941) ⭐⭐Gandhi names Nehru his successor (Jan 1942)7. Cripps Mission — March–April 1942 ⭐⭐⭐ProposalsNew featuresWhy it failed🧠 Memory box🎯 Exam traps
1. Crisis over method of struggle (1938–39)
After CDM, Gandhi saw corruption, indiscipline, bogus membership and squabbles in the Congress; he wanted to put the house in order first and felt masses weren’t ready. Others wanted struggle to continue.
Subhas Chandra Bose — background
President of the Bengal PCC; worked among youth and trade unions; with Nehru opposed dominion status in the Nehru Report, formed the Independence League; backed Purna Swaraj (1929); active in the Salt Satyagraha (arrested); opposed suspension of CDM and the Gandhi-Irwin Pact (esp. because Bhagat Singh wasn’t saved).
Haripura session (February 1938, Gujarat) ⭐
- Bose elected president unanimously.
- Said provincial ministries had immense revolutionary potential; spoke of planning and state-owned industrial development → National Planning Committee (1938) (chaired by Nehru).
- Resolution: moral support to people agitating in the princely states.
1939 presidential election and Tripuri (March 1939) ⭐⭐
- Bose stood again (Jan 1939), claiming to represent new ideas and programmes. Patel, Rajendra Prasad, Kripalani and others said the president’s post is constitutional/symbolic; Gandhi backed Pattabhi Sitaramayya.
- Bose won 1,580 to 1,377 (supported by Congress Socialists and Communists). Gandhi: “Pattabhi’s defeat is my defeat.”
- Bose had accused CWC leaders of being ready to compromise on federation → 12 of 15 CWC members resigned.
- Tripuri session (near Jabalpur, CP), March 1939 — Bose ill but present; predicted an imperialist war; wanted a six-month ultimatum to Britain, followed by mass civil disobedience.
- Gandhi: neither Congress nor masses ready; communal discord and class strife.
- G.B. Pant’s resolution reaffirmed faith in Gandhian policies and asked Bose to nominate the CWC “in accordance with the wishes of Gandhiji” — passed without opposition from socialists/communists (the Left didn’t want a split).
- Gandhi refused to impose a CWC; Bose refused to form one without Gandhi’s approval; Gandhi: “your views are diametrically opposed…”
- Bose resigned (April 1939) → Rajendra Prasad 🟣 became president.
- May 1939: Bose formed the Forward Bloc (at Makur, Unnao) as a party within Congress. After he called an all-India protest (9 July) against an AICC resolution, the CWC (Aug 1939) removed him as Bengal PCC president and debarred him from elective office for 3 years.
- Tripuri also sent greetings to China and approved a Congress Medical Mission to China (Dr Kotnis among doctors).
2. Gandhi vs Bose — ideological differences
Theme | Gandhi | Subhas Bose |
Mutual respect | Called Bose “Prince among Patriots” (1942) | Called Gandhi “Father of Our Nation” (Rangoon/Singapore radio, 1944) |
Method | Ahimsa and satyagraha; violence breeds hatred | Non-violence inadequate; armed struggle needed alongside civil disobedience |
Means & ends | Purity of means; would never ally with fascists; won’t embarrass Britain in crisis | Results matter; “Britain’s difficulty is India’s opportunity”; took help of Germany, Italy, Japan (pragmatism, not ideological kinship) |
State | Hind Swaraj (1909); Ramrajya; minimal/stateless; decentralised village republics (“oceanic circles”); panchayat of five elected annually; duties over rights; called a philosophical anarchist (Judith Brown) | Initially democracy, later an authoritarian state in the first phase for socialist reconstruction; “Samyavada” — synthesis of socialism and fascism (discipline); Head of State + PM + war + foreign minister of Azad Hind govt |
Military | Against militarism; minimal force for defence | Admired military discipline; uniformed volunteer corps at Calcutta Congress (1928/1930) |
Economy | Decentralised village economy; Sarvodaya; against large-scale mechanisation; trusteeship | Industrialisation under state ownership; planning commission; abolish landlordism; Soviet model; heavy + medium + cottage industries |
Religion | Deeply religious; all religions true; no separation of religion and politics | Upanishads, Gita, Vivekananda; but religion private, state neutral; INA mixed messes, common festivals |
Caste | Abolish untouchability but retain varna | Casteless, classless society; inter-caste marriage |
Women | Brought women into struggle; but complementary roles, Sita as ideal | Full equality; separate women’s planning sub-committee (Rani Lakshmibai Rajwade); Rani of Jhansi Regiment (1943) under Capt. Lakshmi Swaminathan (Sahgal) |
Education | Vernacular; free compulsory 7–14; Nai Talim / basic education (1937) — craft-centred | Higher technical and scientific education; students abroad by plan |
3. Congress response to World War II ⭐
- 1 Sept 1939 Germany attacked Poland; 3 Sept Britain declared war; Viceroy Linlithgow declared India a belligerent without consulting Indians.
- Congress offered cooperation on two conditions: (1) Constituent Assembly after the war; (2) some genuinely responsible government at the centre immediately. Rejected.
CWC at Wardha (10–14 Sept 1939)
- Gandhi: unconditional (moral, non-violent) support to the Allies; distinguished democracies from Nazis; would not embarrass Britain.
- Bose, Narendra Dev, JP (socialists): imperialist war on both sides; time for civil disobedience.
- Nehru: justice on the side of Britain, France, Poland, but they were imperialists; no Indian participation until India is free, but no advantage to be taken of Britain’s difficulty.
- Gandhi isolated → accepted Nehru’s line. CWC resolution: condemned fascism; India cannot fight for freedom denied to itself; Britain should prove its war aims by ending imperialism in India; declare war aims.
Government response and resignations
- Linlithgow’s statement (17 Oct 1939): no war aims beyond resisting aggression; post-war consultation with “communities, parties, interests and princes” on modifying the 1935 Act; a consultative committee now. Used League and princes against Congress.
- Hidden agenda: regain ground from Congress; emergency powers (1935 Act amended), Defence of India Ordinance on day one; secret Revolutionary Movement Ordinance draft (May 1940). Churchill and Zetland called Congress a Hindu body.
- Gandhi: “there is to be no democracy for India if Britain can prevent it.”
- 23 Oct 1939 CWC: rejected the statement; no support to the war; ministries to resign (they did by early Nov 1939). League celebrated Deliverance Day (22 Dec 1939).
- Gandhi still against immediate struggle (allied cause just; communal tension; weak organisation; masses not ready).
- Jan 1940: Linlithgow — “Dominion Status of the Westminster variety after the war” is the goal.
- CWC Allahabad (Nov 1939): the war is imperialist; India’s independence and a Constituent Assembly must be recognised.
Ramgarh session (March 1940) 🟣
- At Ramgarh (Hazaribagh, then Bihar); president Maulana Abul Kalam Azad.
- Battle to be waged but form and timing left to Gandhi; declared nothing short of complete independence (no dominion status); sovereignty rests with the people in provinces and states; civil disobedience when organisation is fit or a crisis arises.
- (Bose held a parallel Anti-Compromise Conference at Ramgarh.)
4. Lahore (Pakistan) Resolution — 23 March 1940 ⭐⭐
Muslim League session at Lahore (Jinnah presiding; moved by A.K. Fazlul Huq): “geographically contiguous units… in which the Muslims are numerically in a majority as in the North-Western and Eastern zones… should be grouped to constitute ‘independent States’ in which the constituent units shall be autonomous and sovereign”, with safeguards for Muslims where they are a minority. (The word “Pakistan” itself was coined by Choudhary Rahmat Ali, 1933.)
5. August Offer — 8 August 1940 ⭐
After Hitler’s victories (fall of Belgium, Holland, France), Britain became conciliatory. Gandhi and Nehru refused to exploit Britain’s plight; Congress asked for a national/interim government (Poona offer) — refused. Linlithgow’s August Offer:
- Dominion status as the objective;
- Expansion of the Viceroy’s Executive Council with an Indian majority (from major parties);
- A Constituent Assembly after the war, mainly of Indians, subject to obligations on defence, minorities, treaties with states, all-India services;
- No future constitution without the consent of minorities (a veto for the League).
- Congress rejected it — Nehru: “Dominion status concept is dead as a doornail”; Gandhi: it widened the gulf. League welcomed the veto, reiterated partition.
- Significance: first recognition of Indians’ inherent right to frame their constitution; Constituent Assembly conceded; dominion status explicitly offered.
- July 1941: Executive Council enlarged — Indians a majority (8 of 12) for the first time, but British kept defence, finance, home; advisory National Defence Council set up.
6. Individual Satyagraha (Oct 1940 – 1941) ⭐⭐
- Government insisted on no advance without Congress–League agreement; ordinances curbed speech, press, association.
- Gandhi took command (end 1940) and launched a limited, individual satyagraha by selected persons. Aims: (1) show nationalist patience was not weakness; (2) express that people had no interest in the war and saw no difference between Nazism and the “double autocracy” ruling India; (3) give government another chance.
- Demand: freedom of speech against the war — an anti-war declaration; if not arrested, repeat it in villages and march to Delhi — the “Delhi Chalo” movement.
- First satyagrahi: Vinoba Bhave (17 Oct 1940); second: Jawaharlal Nehru; (third: Brahma Dutt). By May 1941, ~25,000 convicted.
- World events: June 1941 Germany attacked USSR; Dec 1941 Japan attacked Pearl Harbor; March 1942 Japan took Rangoon.
Gandhi names Nehru his successor (Jan 1942)
- Leaders released Dec 1941; CWC (overriding Gandhi and Nehru) offered to help defend India if full independence after the war and real power now.
- Gandhi designated Nehru as his heir — despite differences (religion, industrialisation, state power) both shared inclusive patriotism, non-violence, democracy. Rajmohan Gandhi (The Good Boatman): Nehru best reflected the pluralist idea of India — trusted by Muslims, respected in the south, admired by women.
7. Cripps Mission — March–April 1942 ⭐⭐⭐
- Sir Stafford Cripps — left-wing Labour leader, Leader of the House of Commons, War Cabinet member, sympathetic to India.
- Why sent: Japanese threat after reverses in SE Asia; pressure from the US, USSR, China; Indians had offered support for real power now and independence later.
Proposals
- An Indian Union with dominion status, free to decide relations with the Commonwealth and join the UN.
- Constituent Assembly after the war — partly elected by provincial assemblies through proportional representation, partly nominated by princes.
- Britain to accept the constitution subject to: (i) any province unwilling to join could have a separate constitution / separate Union; (ii) a treaty to transfer power and protect racial and religious minorities.
- Meanwhile, defence in British hands; GG’s powers intact.
New features
Constitution-making solely in Indian hands (vs “mainly” in the August Offer); a concrete plan for the CA; provincial opt-out — a blueprint for partition; free India could leave the Commonwealth; large Indian share in interim administration.
Why it failed
Party | Objections |
Congress (negotiators Nehru and Maulana Azad) | Dominion status not independence; princes’ nominees not elected; provincial secession against national unity; no immediate transfer of power or real share in defence; GG’s supremacy retained |
Muslim League | Rejected a single Union; disliked CA machinery and accession procedure; Pakistan not explicitly conceded |
Others | Liberals, Hindu Mahasabha opposed secession; depressed classes feared caste Hindus; Sikhs feared losing Punjab |
- Cripps’s rigid “take it or leave it”; he spoke of “cabinet” and “national government” but later meant only an expanded Executive Council.
- Accession procedure: secession by 60% legislative vote; otherwise a plebiscite of adult males by simple majority — unfair to Hindus in Punjab and Bengal.
- Churchill, Amery (Secretary of State), Linlithgow, Wavell (C-in-C) torpedoed it; talks broke down on the Viceroy’s veto.
- Gandhi: “a post-dated cheque” (the phrase “on a crashing bank” was added by others). Nehru: Indians would become the Viceroy’s “liveried camp followers”. Azad: accepting would leave no justification for a fresh struggle. Churchill: “I have not become the King’s First Minister to preside over the liquidation of the British Empire.”
- Result: a frustrated, embittered people — time for a final assault (Quit India).
🧠 Memory box
- Bose: Haripura Feb 1938 (unanimous) → Jan 1939 beats Pattabhi 1580–1377 → Tripuri Mar 1939 (Pant resolution) → resigns Apr 1939 → Forward Bloc May 1939 → debarred Aug 1939.
- WWII sequence: 3 Sept 1939 India dragged in → Wardha CWC → 17 Oct Linlithgow → 23 Oct resign call → 22 Dec Deliverance Day → Mar 1940 Ramgarh + Lahore Resolution → 8 Aug 1940 August Offer → 17 Oct 1940 Vinoba → Mar 1942 Cripps.
- Quotes: “dead as a doornail” = Nehru (August Offer) · “post-dated cheque” = Gandhi (Cripps) · “Pattabhi’s defeat is my defeat” = Gandhi.
🎯 Exam traps
- ⚠️ First individual satyagrahi = Vinoba Bhave; second = Nehru.
- ⚠️ August Offer = Linlithgow, 1940; Cripps = 1942; the first to formally concede a Constituent Assembly made by Indians was the August Offer.
- ⚠️ Ramgarh session (1940) was in Bihar (Hazaribagh, now Jharkhand), president Azad.
- ⚠️ The Lahore Resolution (1940) didn’t use the word “Pakistan”; it spoke of “independent States”.
- ⚠️ Cripps proposals gave provinces the right to opt out — seen as the first blueprint of partition.