Notes · History

19 · Haripura–Tripuri, WWII, August Offer, Individual Satyagraha & Cripps

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

10 min read9 sections

19 · Haripura–Tripuri, WWII, August Offer, Individual Satyagraha & Cripps

📌
Sub-topics: Haripura & Tripuri crisis · Gandhi vs Bose ideas · Congress response to WWII · Ministries resign · Ramgarh 1940 · Lahore (Pakistan) Resolution · August Offer · Individual Satyagraha · Nehru as successor · Cripps Mission.

1. Crisis over method of struggle (1938–39)

After CDM, Gandhi saw corruption, indiscipline, bogus membership and squabbles in the Congress; he wanted to put the house in order first and felt masses weren’t ready. Others wanted struggle to continue.

Subhas Chandra Bose — background

President of the Bengal PCC; worked among youth and trade unions; with Nehru opposed dominion status in the Nehru Report, formed the Independence League; backed Purna Swaraj (1929); active in the Salt Satyagraha (arrested); opposed suspension of CDM and the Gandhi-Irwin Pact (esp. because Bhagat Singh wasn’t saved).

Haripura session (February 1938, Gujarat) ⭐

  • Bose elected president unanimously.
  • Said provincial ministries had immense revolutionary potential; spoke of planning and state-owned industrial development → National Planning Committee (1938) (chaired by Nehru).
  • Resolution: moral support to people agitating in the princely states.

1939 presidential election and Tripuri (March 1939) ⭐⭐

  • Bose stood again (Jan 1939), claiming to represent new ideas and programmes. Patel, Rajendra Prasad, Kripalani and others said the president’s post is constitutional/symbolic; Gandhi backed Pattabhi Sitaramayya.
  • Bose won 1,580 to 1,377 (supported by Congress Socialists and Communists). Gandhi: “Pattabhi’s defeat is my defeat.”
  • Bose had accused CWC leaders of being ready to compromise on federation → 12 of 15 CWC members resigned.
  • Tripuri session (near Jabalpur, CP), March 1939 — Bose ill but present; predicted an imperialist war; wanted a six-month ultimatum to Britain, followed by mass civil disobedience.
  • Gandhi: neither Congress nor masses ready; communal discord and class strife.
  • G.B. Pant’s resolution reaffirmed faith in Gandhian policies and asked Bose to nominate the CWC “in accordance with the wishes of Gandhiji” — passed without opposition from socialists/communists (the Left didn’t want a split).
  • Gandhi refused to impose a CWC; Bose refused to form one without Gandhi’s approval; Gandhi: “your views are diametrically opposed…”
  • Bose resigned (April 1939) → Rajendra Prasad 🟣 became president.
  • May 1939: Bose formed the Forward Bloc (at Makur, Unnao) as a party within Congress. After he called an all-India protest (9 July) against an AICC resolution, the CWC (Aug 1939) removed him as Bengal PCC president and debarred him from elective office for 3 years.
  • Tripuri also sent greetings to China and approved a Congress Medical Mission to China (Dr Kotnis among doctors).

2. Gandhi vs Bose — ideological differences

Theme
Gandhi
Subhas Bose
Mutual respect
Called Bose “Prince among Patriots” (1942)
Called Gandhi “Father of Our Nation” (Rangoon/Singapore radio, 1944)
Method
Ahimsa and satyagraha; violence breeds hatred
Non-violence inadequate; armed struggle needed alongside civil disobedience
Means & ends
Purity of means; would never ally with fascists; won’t embarrass Britain in crisis
Results matter; “Britain’s difficulty is India’s opportunity”; took help of Germany, Italy, Japan (pragmatism, not ideological kinship)
State
Hind Swaraj (1909); Ramrajya; minimal/stateless; decentralised village republics (“oceanic circles”); panchayat of five elected annually; duties over rights; called a philosophical anarchist (Judith Brown)
Initially democracy, later an authoritarian state in the first phase for socialist reconstruction; “Samyavada” — synthesis of socialism and fascism (discipline); Head of State + PM + war + foreign minister of Azad Hind govt
Military
Against militarism; minimal force for defence
Admired military discipline; uniformed volunteer corps at Calcutta Congress (1928/1930)
Economy
Decentralised village economy; Sarvodaya; against large-scale mechanisation; trusteeship
Industrialisation under state ownership; planning commission; abolish landlordism; Soviet model; heavy + medium + cottage industries
Religion
Deeply religious; all religions true; no separation of religion and politics
Upanishads, Gita, Vivekananda; but religion private, state neutral; INA mixed messes, common festivals
Caste
Abolish untouchability but retain varna
Casteless, classless society; inter-caste marriage
Women
Brought women into struggle; but complementary roles, Sita as ideal
Full equality; separate women’s planning sub-committee (Rani Lakshmibai Rajwade); Rani of Jhansi Regiment (1943) under Capt. Lakshmi Swaminathan (Sahgal)
Education
Vernacular; free compulsory 7–14; Nai Talim / basic education (1937) — craft-centred
Higher technical and scientific education; students abroad by plan

3. Congress response to World War II ⭐

  • 1 Sept 1939 Germany attacked Poland; 3 Sept Britain declared war; Viceroy Linlithgow declared India a belligerent without consulting Indians.
  • Congress offered cooperation on two conditions: (1) Constituent Assembly after the war; (2) some genuinely responsible government at the centre immediately. Rejected.

CWC at Wardha (10–14 Sept 1939)

  • Gandhi: unconditional (moral, non-violent) support to the Allies; distinguished democracies from Nazis; would not embarrass Britain.
  • Bose, Narendra Dev, JP (socialists): imperialist war on both sides; time for civil disobedience.
  • Nehru: justice on the side of Britain, France, Poland, but they were imperialists; no Indian participation until India is free, but no advantage to be taken of Britain’s difficulty.
  • Gandhi isolated → accepted Nehru’s line. CWC resolution: condemned fascism; India cannot fight for freedom denied to itself; Britain should prove its war aims by ending imperialism in India; declare war aims.

Government response and resignations

  • Linlithgow’s statement (17 Oct 1939): no war aims beyond resisting aggression; post-war consultation with “communities, parties, interests and princes” on modifying the 1935 Act; a consultative committee now. Used League and princes against Congress.
  • Hidden agenda: regain ground from Congress; emergency powers (1935 Act amended), Defence of India Ordinance on day one; secret Revolutionary Movement Ordinance draft (May 1940). Churchill and Zetland called Congress a Hindu body.
  • Gandhi: “there is to be no democracy for India if Britain can prevent it.”
  • 23 Oct 1939 CWC: rejected the statement; no support to the war; ministries to resign (they did by early Nov 1939). League celebrated Deliverance Day (22 Dec 1939).
  • Gandhi still against immediate struggle (allied cause just; communal tension; weak organisation; masses not ready).
  • Jan 1940: Linlithgow — “Dominion Status of the Westminster variety after the war” is the goal.
  • CWC Allahabad (Nov 1939): the war is imperialist; India’s independence and a Constituent Assembly must be recognised.

Ramgarh session (March 1940) 🟣

  • At Ramgarh (Hazaribagh, then Bihar); president Maulana Abul Kalam Azad.
  • Battle to be waged but form and timing left to Gandhi; declared nothing short of complete independence (no dominion status); sovereignty rests with the people in provinces and states; civil disobedience when organisation is fit or a crisis arises.
  • (Bose held a parallel Anti-Compromise Conference at Ramgarh.)

4. Lahore (Pakistan) Resolution — 23 March 1940 ⭐⭐

Muslim League session at Lahore (Jinnah presiding; moved by A.K. Fazlul Huq): “geographically contiguous units… in which the Muslims are numerically in a majority as in the North-Western and Eastern zones… should be grouped to constitute ‘independent States’ in which the constituent units shall be autonomous and sovereign”, with safeguards for Muslims where they are a minority. (The word “Pakistan” itself was coined by Choudhary Rahmat Ali, 1933.)

5. August Offer — 8 August 1940 ⭐

After Hitler’s victories (fall of Belgium, Holland, France), Britain became conciliatory. Gandhi and Nehru refused to exploit Britain’s plight; Congress asked for a national/interim government (Poona offer) — refused. Linlithgow’s August Offer:
  1. Dominion status as the objective;
  1. Expansion of the Viceroy’s Executive Council with an Indian majority (from major parties);
  1. A Constituent Assembly after the war, mainly of Indians, subject to obligations on defence, minorities, treaties with states, all-India services;
  1. No future constitution without the consent of minorities (a veto for the League).
  • Congress rejected it — Nehru: “Dominion status concept is dead as a doornail”; Gandhi: it widened the gulf. League welcomed the veto, reiterated partition.
  • Significance: first recognition of Indians’ inherent right to frame their constitution; Constituent Assembly conceded; dominion status explicitly offered.
  • July 1941: Executive Council enlarged — Indians a majority (8 of 12) for the first time, but British kept defence, finance, home; advisory National Defence Council set up.

6. Individual Satyagraha (Oct 1940 – 1941) ⭐⭐

  • Government insisted on no advance without Congress–League agreement; ordinances curbed speech, press, association.
  • Gandhi took command (end 1940) and launched a limited, individual satyagraha by selected persons. Aims: (1) show nationalist patience was not weakness; (2) express that people had no interest in the war and saw no difference between Nazism and the “double autocracy” ruling India; (3) give government another chance.
  • Demand: freedom of speech against the war — an anti-war declaration; if not arrested, repeat it in villages and march to Delhi — the “Delhi Chalo” movement.
  • First satyagrahi: Vinoba Bhave (17 Oct 1940); second: Jawaharlal Nehru; (third: Brahma Dutt). By May 1941, ~25,000 convicted.
  • World events: June 1941 Germany attacked USSR; Dec 1941 Japan attacked Pearl Harbor; March 1942 Japan took Rangoon.

Gandhi names Nehru his successor (Jan 1942)

  • Leaders released Dec 1941; CWC (overriding Gandhi and Nehru) offered to help defend India if full independence after the war and real power now.
  • Gandhi designated Nehru as his heir — despite differences (religion, industrialisation, state power) both shared inclusive patriotism, non-violence, democracy. Rajmohan Gandhi (The Good Boatman): Nehru best reflected the pluralist idea of India — trusted by Muslims, respected in the south, admired by women.

7. Cripps Mission — March–April 1942 ⭐⭐⭐

  • Sir Stafford Cripps — left-wing Labour leader, Leader of the House of Commons, War Cabinet member, sympathetic to India.
  • Why sent: Japanese threat after reverses in SE Asia; pressure from the US, USSR, China; Indians had offered support for real power now and independence later.

Proposals

  1. An Indian Union with dominion status, free to decide relations with the Commonwealth and join the UN.
  1. Constituent Assembly after the war — partly elected by provincial assemblies through proportional representation, partly nominated by princes.
  1. Britain to accept the constitution subject to: (i) any province unwilling to join could have a separate constitution / separate Union; (ii) a treaty to transfer power and protect racial and religious minorities.
  1. Meanwhile, defence in British hands; GG’s powers intact.

New features

Constitution-making solely in Indian hands (vs “mainly” in the August Offer); a concrete plan for the CA; provincial opt-out — a blueprint for partition; free India could leave the Commonwealth; large Indian share in interim administration.

Why it failed

Party
Objections
Congress (negotiators Nehru and Maulana Azad)
Dominion status not independence; princes’ nominees not elected; provincial secession against national unity; no immediate transfer of power or real share in defence; GG’s supremacy retained
Muslim League
Rejected a single Union; disliked CA machinery and accession procedure; Pakistan not explicitly conceded
Others
Liberals, Hindu Mahasabha opposed secession; depressed classes feared caste Hindus; Sikhs feared losing Punjab
  • Cripps’s rigid “take it or leave it”; he spoke of “cabinet” and “national government” but later meant only an expanded Executive Council.
  • Accession procedure: secession by 60% legislative vote; otherwise a plebiscite of adult males by simple majority — unfair to Hindus in Punjab and Bengal.
  • Churchill, Amery (Secretary of State), Linlithgow, Wavell (C-in-C) torpedoed it; talks broke down on the Viceroy’s veto.
  • Gandhi: “a post-dated cheque” (the phrase “on a crashing bank” was added by others). Nehru: Indians would become the Viceroy’s “liveried camp followers”. Azad: accepting would leave no justification for a fresh struggle. Churchill: “I have not become the King’s First Minister to preside over the liquidation of the British Empire.”
  • Result: a frustrated, embittered people — time for a final assault (Quit India).

🧠 Memory box

  • Bose: Haripura Feb 1938 (unanimous) → Jan 1939 beats Pattabhi 1580–1377 → Tripuri Mar 1939 (Pant resolution) → resigns Apr 1939 → Forward Bloc May 1939 → debarred Aug 1939.
  • WWII sequence: 3 Sept 1939 India dragged in → Wardha CWC → 17 Oct Linlithgow → 23 Oct resign call → 22 Dec Deliverance Day → Mar 1940 Ramgarh + Lahore Resolution → 8 Aug 1940 August Offer → 17 Oct 1940 Vinoba → Mar 1942 Cripps.
  • Quotes: “dead as a doornail” = Nehru (August Offer) · “post-dated cheque” = Gandhi (Cripps) · “Pattabhi’s defeat is my defeat” = Gandhi.

🎯 Exam traps

  • ⚠️ First individual satyagrahi = Vinoba Bhave; second = Nehru.
  • ⚠️ August Offer = Linlithgow, 1940; Cripps = 1942; the first to formally concede a Constituent Assembly made by Indians was the August Offer.
  • ⚠️ Ramgarh session (1940) was in Bihar (Hazaribagh, now Jharkhand), president Azad.
  • ⚠️ The Lahore Resolution (1940) didn’t use the word “Pakistan”; it spoke of “independent States”.
  • ⚠️ Cripps proposals gave provinces the right to opt out — seen as the first blueprint of partition.