Notes · History

22 · Independence with Partition 1947

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

8 min read9 sections

22 · Independence with Partition 1947

📌
Sub-topics: Attlee’s statement (20 Feb 1947) · Mountbatten · Plan Balkan · 3 June Plan · Indian Independence Act 1947 · Radcliffe Award · Integration of states (phase I) · Why Congress accepted partition.

1. Attlee’s Statement — 20 February 1947 ⭐⭐

  • PM Clement Attlee announced in the House of Commons Britain’s intention to leave India.
  • Deadline: 30 June 1948 for transfer of power, even without agreement on a constitution.
  • Power would go to some form of central government or, in some areas, to existing provincial governments (if the CA was not fully representative, i.e., Muslim-majority provinces stayed out).
  • British powers and obligations to princely states would lapse and not pass to any successor.
  • Mountbatten to replace Wavell.
  • Implied partition and even Balkanisation; essentially a return to the Cripps Offer.
Why a fixed date: shock parties into agreement; avert a constitutional crisis; convince Indians of British sincerity; Wavell was right that government authority had irreversibly declined.
Congress accepted transfer to more than one centre (CA could proceed for areas represented). But the League, emboldened, launched civil disobedience to topple the Khizr ministry in Punjab (resigned March 1947).

2. Towards partition (early 1947)

  • Riots and the unworkable coalition made partition thinkable. Insistent demand from Hindu and Sikh groups in Bengal and Punjab, who feared compulsory grouping would put them in Pakistan; Hindu Mahasabha in Bengal explored a separate Hindu province in West Bengal.
  • 10 March 1947: Nehru — Cabinet Mission Plan the best if implemented; the only alternative was partition of Punjab and Bengal. (CWC resolution, March 1947 — Punjab, and by implication Bengal, must be partitioned if India was divided — first official reference to Pakistan.)
  • April 1947: Congress president J.B. Kripalani to the Viceroy: “rather than have a battle, we shall let them have their Pakistan, provided you allow Bengal and Punjab to be partitioned in a fair manner.”

3. Lord Mountbatten (Viceroy from 24 March 1947)

  • More decisive than predecessors — informal powers to decide on the spot; firm British decision to quit early. Task: explore unity or division till Oct 1947, then advise.
  • Found the Cabinet Mission Plan a “dead horse” and Jinnah adamant on a sovereign state; preferred to woo both sides rather than back unity forces.
⚠️
Plan Balkan (March–May 1947): transfer power to separate provinces (or a confederation), Punjab and Bengal could vote to partition, and all units plus princely states (freed by lapse of paramountcy) could join India, Pakistan or stay separate. Abandoned after Nehru reacted violently.

4. Mountbatten Plan — 3 June 1947 ⭐⭐⭐

  • Key innovation (suggested by V.P. Menon): immediate transfer of power on the basis of dominion status (with right of secession) — no need to wait for CA agreement.
Main points:
  1. Punjab and Bengal legislative assemblies to meet in two groups (Hindu-majority and Muslim-majority districts); if a simple majority of either group voted for partition, the province would be partitioned.
  1. If partitioned, two dominions and two constituent assemblies.
  1. Sindh to decide on its own (assembly).
  1. Referendums in NWFP and Sylhet district (Assam).
  1. Because Congress conceded unity, its other points were met: no independence for princely states (join India or Pakistan); no independent Bengal; no accession of Hyderabad to Pakistan (Mountbatten backed Congress); freedom on 15 August 1947; a Boundary Commission if partition.
  • Formula: divide India but retain maximum unity; Pakistan conceded but kept as small as possible.

Why Congress accepted dominion status (despite Lahore 1929)

  1. Peaceful and quick transfer of power;
  1. Need to take authority urgently to control the explosive situation;
  1. Continuity in bureaucracy and army. For Britain: keeps India in the Commonwealth (economic, defence, trade value).

Why the early date (15 August 1947)

To secure Congress agreement to dominion status and let Britain escape responsibility for the communal situation. (15 Aug = second anniversary of Japan’s surrender.)

Implementation

  • Bengal and Punjab assemblies voted for partition → East Bengal and West Punjab to Pakistan; West Bengal and East Punjab to India.
  • Sylhet referendum → joined East Bengal.
  • NWFP referendum → Pakistan (provincial Congress/Khudai Khidmatgars boycotted).
  • Baluchistan and Sindh joined Pakistan.
  • Two Boundary Commissions under Sir Cyril Radcliffe.

5. Indian Independence Act, 1947 ⭐⭐

  • Passed by the British Parliament (introduced 4/5 July 1947); royal assent 18 July 1947; effective 15 August 1947.
  • Two independent dominions — India and Pakistan — each with a Governor-General.
  • Each Constituent Assembly to act as the dominion legislature; Central Legislative Assembly and Council of States dissolved.
  • Till new constitutions, each governed under the GoI Act 1935 (adapted).
  • Paramountcy lapsed; office of Secretary of State abolished; British Crown no longer “Emperor of India”.
  • Pakistan independent on 14 August, India on 15 August 1947. Jinnah became Pakistan’s first Governor-General; India requested Mountbatten to continue as its Governor-General (till June 1948; then C. Rajagopalachari — first and last Indian GG).

Problems of hasty withdrawal

  • No transitional institutions to handle partition problems; Punjab massacres not prevented.
  • Mountbatten hoped to be common GG of both dominions; Jinnah wanted it for himself.
  • Radcliffe Award ready by 12 Aug 1947 but published after independence (17 Aug) so the British could escape responsibility.

6. Integration of states — phase I (1947)

  • 1946–47: new upsurge of States’ People’s Movements for rights and elected representation in the CA. Nehru presided over the All India States People’s Conference at Udaipur (1945) and Gwalior (April 1947); warned that states refusing to join the CA would be treated as hostile.
  • July 1947: Vallabhbhai Patel headed the new States Department (with V.P. Menon as secretary) — baits and threats of mass pressure.
  • Phase I: by 15 August 1947 all states except Kashmir, Hyderabad, Junagadh signed the Instrument of Accession (defence, external affairs, communications). Easy because princes surrendered only what they never had (paramountcy subjects) and internal structure was untouched.
  • Phase II (within a year): integration with neighbouring provinces or into unions (Kathiawar/Saurashtra, Vindhya Pradesh, Madhya Bharat, Rajasthan, Himachal Pradesh, PEPSU), with constitutional changes; some (Hyderabad, Mysore, Travancore-Cochin) kept old boundaries for some years. Bait: generous privy purses; some princes became Governors/Rajpramukhs. Patel’s greatest achievement. (Details on page 27.)

7. Why partition was accepted ⭐

  1. Long-term failure to draw Muslim masses into the national movement — Congress succeeded in building national consciousness to make Britain quit, but failed to weld the nation, especially Muslims.
  1. Only immediate transfer of power could forestall Direct Action and communal violence; collapse of the Interim Government made Pakistan look unavoidable.
  1. The plan ruled out independence for princely states — avoided Balkanisation.
  1. The final step in a series of concessions:
      • Cripps (1942) — autonomy/opt-out of Muslim-majority provinces;
      • Gandhi–Jinnah talks (1944) — self-determination for Muslim-majority areas;
      • Cabinet Mission (1946) — possibility of a separate CA for Muslim provinces; Congress accepted compulsory grouping (Dec 1946);
      • March 1947 CWC — partition of Punjab (and Bengal) if India divided;
      • 3 June 1947 — partition accepted.
  1. Above all, Congress could not stop the communal riots.
Wishful thinking (esp. Nehru): differences would vanish once the British left; partition was temporary; partition would be peaceful. The communalism of the 1940s — an assertive “Muslim nation” — was underestimated.
Gandhi’s helplessness: people were communalised; no movement could fight communalism with a communalised people; he asked Congressmen not to accept partition in their hearts.
💬
Nehru: we were tired men… partition offered a way out and we took it. · Patel: otherwise India would split into many bits — “Pakistan cells in every office”. · Azad: people accepted partition out of anger or despair, not with free minds. · Jinnah: “I alone with the help of my secretary and my typewriter won Pakistan.” · R.C. Majumdar: freedom came from the cumulative effect of Gandhian campaigns, revolutionaries/INA and the war; the INA trial showed Britain it could no longer rely on sepoys. · R.J. Moore: devolving power by stages was itself divisive.

🧠 Memory box

  • 1947 chain: 20 Feb Attlee (deadline 30 June 1948) → 24 Mar Mountbatten → Plan Balkan dropped → 3 June Plan → 18 July royal assent → 14/15 Aug independence → 17 Aug Radcliffe Award published.
  • 3 June Plan decision-makers: Assemblies (Punjab, Bengal, Sindh) vs Referendums (NWFP, Sylhet).
  • Accession holdouts on 15 Aug: K-H-J = Kashmir, Hyderabad, Junagadh.
  • Idea of dominion-status-first: V.P. Menon.

🎯 Exam traps

  • ⚠️ Attlee’s deadline was June 1948; Mountbatten advanced it to 15 Aug 1947.
  • ⚠️ The Indian Independence Act got royal assent on 18 July 1947.
  • ⚠️ Referendum was held only in NWFP and Sylhet; Punjab and Bengal decided through their assemblies.
  • ⚠️ First GG of independent India = Mountbatten; first Indian GG = C. Rajagopalachari; first GG of Pakistan = Jinnah.
  • ⚠️ Radcliffe Award was published after independence (17 Aug 1947).