Sub-topics: First day and first cabinet · Radcliffe Award and riots · division of assets · Gandhi's assassination · refugees and Nehru–Liaquat Pact · communist insurgency | British policy towards states (6 stages) · Chamber of Princes · Butler Committee · integration: Junagadh, Hyderabad, Kashmir | Constituent Assembly: background, formation, committees, drafting, adoption.
PART A — CHALLENGES BEFORE THE NEWBORN NATION (Ch 33)1. The first day of independenceFirst Council of Ministers (15 August 1947) ⭐2. Challenges3. Radcliffe Award and the riots ⭐4. Division of resources5. Assassination of Gandhi ⭐6. Refugees and rehabilitation7. The communists and independencePART B — THE INDIAN (PRINCELY) STATES (Ch 34)8. Stages of British policy towards states ⭐⭐9. Integration (1947–49) ⭐⭐⭐The problem statesGradual integration ("merger and democratisation")PART C — MAKING OF THE CONSTITUTION (Ch 35)10. Background — the demand for a Constituent Assembly ⭐11. Formation of the Constituent Assembly ⭐⭐⭐Evaluation12. Committees ⭐⭐Drafting Committee (set up 29 August 1947) ⭐⭐13. Five stages of work and adoption🧠 Memory box🎯 Exam traps
PART A — CHALLENGES BEFORE THE NEWBORN NATION (Ch 33)
1. The first day of independence
- Constituent Assembly met at 11 p.m., 14 August 1947, presided by Rajendra Prasad; at midnight Nehru gave the "Tryst with Destiny" speech in the Constitution Hall.
- 15 August 1947: Nehru hoisted the national flag above the Lahori Gate of the Red Fort.
- Governor-General: Lord Mountbatten (to June 1948), then C. Rajagopalachari — first and last Indian Governor-General — till 26 January 1950, when Rajendra Prasad became first President.
- Patel was Deputy PM till his death in December 1950.
First Council of Ministers (15 August 1947) ⭐
Minister | Portfolio |
Jawaharlal Nehru | PM; External Affairs & Commonwealth Relations; Scientific Research |
Vallabhbhai Patel | Deputy PM; Home; States; Information & Broadcasting |
Maulana Abul Kalam Azad | Education |
John Mathai | Railways & Transport |
Sardar Baldev Singh | Defence |
Jairamdas Daulatram | Food & Agriculture |
Jagjivan Ram 🟣 | Labour |
C.H. Bhabha | Commerce |
Rajkumari Amrit Kaur | Health (only woman) |
Rafi Ahmad Kidwai | Communications |
N.V. Gadgil | Works, Mines & Power |
R.K. Shanmukham Chetty | Finance (presented first budget, 26 Nov 1947) |
K.C. Neogy | Relief & Rehabilitation |
B.R. Ambedkar | Law (Scheduled Castes Federation; resigned 1951 over Hindu Code Bill) |
Shyama Prasad Mookerjee | Industries & Supplies (Hindu Mahasabha; first to resign, April 1950) |
N. Gopalaswami Ayyangar | Without portfolio (link with East Punjab govt) |
Mohanlal Saxena | Without portfolio |
2. Challenges
- Immediate: integrating princely states; communal riots; rehabilitating ~60 lakh refugees from West Pakistan; protecting Muslims; avoiding war with Pakistan; communist insurgency.
- Medium-term: framing the Constitution; a representative, democratic, civil-libertarian order; elections; ending agrarian feudalism.
- Long-term: national integration, economic development, poverty removal.
- The Independence Act set procedures for: (i) boundaries; (ii) division of civil services; (iii) division of the armed forces.
3. Radcliffe Award and the riots ⭐
- Punjab and Bengal assemblies met in two sections (Muslim-majority districts vs rest) and by simple majority voted to partition the provinces.
Unit | Area (sq miles) | Population (1941) | Muslims |
West Punjab (Pak) | 62,000 | 15.7 million | 11.85 million |
East Punjab (India) | 37,000 | 12.6 million | 4.37 million |
West Bengal (India) | 28,000 | 21.2 million | 5.3 million |
East Bengal (Pak) | 49,400 | 39.1 million | 27.7 million |
- Result: ~20 million non-Muslims in Pakistan and ~42 million (later 35 million) Muslims in India became minorities.
- Boundary Commissions chaired by Sir Cyril Radcliffe — each with two Muslim and two non-Muslim judges; Radcliffe had never been to India ("never been east of Gibraltar"); out-of-date maps and faulty 1941 census; only six weeks.
- Factors besides religion: rivers, administrative units, economic viability, rail/road links, canals. Sikhs were scattered and demanded all shrines in East Punjab.
- Award ready by 12 August but published on 17 August 1947 (after independence) so that responsibility for the violence would not fall on the British.
- Riots: began August 1946 (Direct Action); worst along the Radcliffe Line; ~1,80,000 killed (60,000 west, 1,20,000 east, per one estimate); trains of dead bodies.
- Bengal calmer due to Gandhi's presence and fasts (Calcutta, the "one-man boundary force"). Delhi saw massacres of Muslims.
- 🟣 Bihar, October 1946: Hindu peasants (allegedly incited by landlords to divert agrarian anger) killed Muslims — followed by Garhmukteshwar (UP). After partition, Gandhi's efforts prevented massacres there.
- Punjab Boundary Force of 50,000 under Mountbatten's plan (commander Maj-Gen Pete Rees) itself split communally; Nehru didn't want British troops; European officers were leaving. Gen. Lockhart (C-in-C, 15 Aug–31 Dec 1947) believed disorder could have been controlled had personnel been placed in their new countries earlier.
4. Division of resources
- Partition Council chaired by the Governor-General, two representatives each from India and Pakistan; Steering Committee of H.M. Patel and Chaudhri Muhammad Ali. ~1,60,000 civil employees opted to move.
- ICS: Indians continued in their chosen country on existing terms; Europeans could continue or retire with compensation.
- Finances: Pakistan wanted a quarter of cash balances. India withheld Pakistan's share of the sterling balances (~Rs 55 crore) because of Pakistan's attack on Kashmir; Gandhi's fast (January 1948) forced its release — cited by some as a motive for his assassination.
- Armed forces: Joint Defence Council under Field Marshal Auchinleck as Supreme Commander; Muslim-majority units to Pakistan; post abolished due to disputes. British troops left from 17 August 1947, completed by February 1948.
5. Assassination of Gandhi ⭐
- 30 January 1948, evening prayer meeting at Birla House, New Delhi; shot by Nathuram Godse.
- Nehru on AIR: "The light has gone out of our lives…". Patel appealed against revenge.
- Godse tried and sentenced to death (hanged Nov 1949, with Narayan Apte).
- RSS banned on 4 February 1948; ban lifted July 1949 after it accepted conditions: cultural activities only, renounce violence and secrecy, loyalty to the Constitution and tricolour, democratic organisation.
6. Refugees and rehabilitation
- No organised population exchange. Emergency Committee of the Cabinet for Delhi; Ministry of Relief and Rehabilitation.
- "Evacuee property" protection became rhetoric — refugees occupied empty Muslim houses.
- East Punjab: camps till 1949; vocational training and business grants for urban refugees; land, loans, housing subsidies for rural; benefits skewed towards those with caste/class/political capital.
- Bengal: prolonged problem. Khulna violence (Dec 1949–Jan 1950) → anti-Muslim riots Feb 1950 (~1 million Muslims left WB) → by 1951 ~15 lakh Hindu refugees in WB.
- Nehru–Liaquat Pact / Delhi Pact (8 April 1950) ⭐: minority ministers at centre and provinces; minority commissions; commissions of inquiry into riots; minority representatives in the cabinets of East Pakistan and West Bengal; two central ministers posted to affected areas; agency to recover abducted women. Opposed by S.P. Mookerjee and K.C. Neogy — both resigned. (Mookerjee founded the Bharatiya Jana Sangh, 1951.)
- Settlements: Delhi — Lajpat Nagar, Rajinder Nagar, Punjabi Bagh, Nizamuddin East, Kingsway Camp; Sindhis — Gujarat, Maharashtra (Ulhasnagar), Rajasthan, MP; East Pakistan refugees — West Bengal, Assam, Tripura, NE, Andamans.
7. The communists and independence
- December 1947: CPI called independence fake — "Yeh azadi jhooti hai"; Nehru government a stooge of Anglo-American imperialism.
- Second Congress, Calcutta (Feb–March 1948): "Political Thesis" — national government the main enemy; armed revolution — the B.T. Ranadive line; aim: a "people's democratic republic". Insurgency in Telangana, West Bengal (Tebhaga revival, urban insurgency in Calcutta).
- Reasons: class struggle to divert from communal politics; communist successes in China, Malaya, Indonesia, Philippines, Burma; Soviet Zhdanov thesis (Sept 1947, answer to the Marshall Plan); Telangana success misread as "Red India" (Guha).
- Government: police action in Hyderabad; CPI banned in West Bengal (March 1948); preventive detention. Failed railway strike (9 May 1949); split over "Chinese line" vs "Russian line".
- Sept 1950: Ajoy Ghosh, S.A. Dange, S.V. Ghate criticised the line. Third Party Congress, Calcutta (Oct 1951): Telangana withdrawn, broad front; ban lifted; CPI fought the 1951–52 elections — from insurrection to constitutional politics.
PART B — THE INDIAN (PRINCELY) STATES (Ch 34)
- 562 states (often cited 565) over 7,12,508 sq miles; from tiny Bilbari (27 people) to Hyderabad (as large as Italy, 14 million). The Company had taken the coasts, river valleys and fertile tracts; states were mostly the inaccessible, less fertile areas.
8. Stages of British policy towards states ⭐⭐
Stage | Period | Essence |
I. Struggle for equality from subordination | 1740–1765 | Anglo-French rivalry; capture of Arcot (1751); Plassey 1757; Diwani (1765) made the Company a major power |
II. Ring Fence | 1765–1813 | Buffer zones to defend frontiers (Warren Hastings' wars with Marathas, Mysore; Awadh's defence to protect Bengal); Wellesley's subsidiary alliance an extension — Hyderabad, Awadh, Marathas accepted |
III. Subordinate Isolation | 1813–1857 | Paramountcy theory (Hastings); states lost external sovereignty, kept internal; Residents became controlling officers; Charter Act 1833; prior sanction for successions; 1834 Directors' guidelines to annex whenever possible → Dalhousie's Doctrine of Lapse (Satara, Nagpur, Jhansi etc.) |
IV. Subordinate Union | 1858–1935 | Annexation abandoned ("punish or depose but not annex"); succession a gift of the Crown; Kaiser-i-Hind (1876); interference for princes', people's, foreigners' or all-India interest; railways, telegraph, press aided control; Butler: for international relations state territory = British territory |
V. Equal Federation | 1935–1947 | GoI Act 1935 federation — 125 of 375 seats in Federal Assembly and 104 of 260 in Council of States for princes; needed accession of states with half the population; never came into force, dropped after WWII began |
VI. Integration and Merger | 1947–1950 | Patel and V.P. Menon |
- Curzon: princes as servants of the people working alongside the Governor-General; policy of patronage and "intrusive surveillance"; relationship neither feudal nor federal.
- Post-1905: "cordial cooperation" with princes against nationalist and revolutionary unrest.
- Chamber of Princes (Narendra Mandal) — recommended by Montford, set up 8 Feb 1921: consultative only; no say in internal affairs. States classified: 109 directly represented; 127 through representatives (12 seats); the rest as feudal holdings/jagirs.
- Butler Committee (1927) (Harcourt Butler): paramountcy must remain supreme and adapt to changing needs; states not to be handed over to an Indian government responsible to an Indian legislature without their consent — paramountcy left undefined ("a hydra-headed creature").
- 🟣 States' people's movements: All India States People's Conference (1927); Congress at Haripura (1938) declared Purna Swaraj for states too; Nehru its president in 1939.
9. Integration (1947–49) ⭐⭐⭐
- Cripps (1942): paramountcy would not pass to any Indian party. States dreamt of sovereignty or a "third force". Attlee's Statement and June 3 Plan: paramountcy lapses; states free to join either dominion; Mountbatten refused sovereign status.
- States Department (set up 5 July 1947) — Sardar Patel with secretary V.P. Menon. Rulers asked to sign the Instrument of Accession on three subjects — defence, external affairs, communications (which they never controlled anyway) — plus a Standstill Agreement. By 15 August 1947, 136 states had joined (all but a few).
The problem states
State | Problem | Resolution |
Junagadh (Kathiawar) | Muslim Nawab (Mahabat Khan) acceded to Pakistan; Hindu majority wanted India | Popular revolt, Indian troops; plebiscite (Feb 1948) — overwhelmingly for India |
Hyderabad | Nizam (Mir Osman Ali Khan) wanted sovereignty and a sea outlet (Goa) | Standstill Agreement (Nov 1947); Razakar violence (Kasim Razvi), foreign arms → "police action" — Operation Polo, 13–17 Sept 1948; formal accession Nov 1949 |
Jammu & Kashmir | Hindu ruler (Hari Singh), Muslim majority; wanted independence | Pakistani tribal raiders (Oct 1947) → Instrument of Accession (26 Oct 1947), endorsed by Sheikh Abdullah; Indian troops airlifted; India went to the UN (Jan 1948); ceasefire (1 Jan 1949) left ~84,000 sq km under Pakistani occupation; special status under Article 370 |
(Also: Travancore's Dewan C.P. Ramaswamy Aiyar and Bhopal's Nawab initially resisted; Jodhpur flirted with Pakistan — general knowledge.)
Gradual integration ("merger and democratisation")
- 216 small states merged into neighbouring provinces (Part A) — e.g., 39 Orissa/Chhattisgarh states into Orissa and CP; Gujarat states into Bombay.
- 61 states made centrally administered (Part C) for strategic/special reasons — Himachal Pradesh, Vindhya Pradesh, Manipur, Tripura, Bhopal, Kutch etc.
- Five unions (Part B, with Hyderabad, Mysore, J&K): United States of Kathiawar (Saurashtra), Matsya Union, PEPSU (Patiala and East Punjab States Union), Rajasthan, Travancore-Cochin, plus Madhya Bharat. Headed by a Rajpramukh; rulers got privy purses (abolished 1971 by the 26th Amendment).
- Unions and Mysore accepted Union jurisdiction (except taxation), subject to Article 238 and 10 years' Union supervision.
- Seventh Amendment (1956) abolished the Part A/B/C classification (with the States Reorganisation Act) → uniform set-up.
PART C — MAKING OF THE CONSTITUTION (Ch 35)
10. Background — the demand for a Constituent Assembly ⭐
Year | Step |
1895 | Constitution of India Bill (Home Rule Bill) — rights like free expression, equality before law, inviolable home, property; Annie Besant thought it inspired by Tilak |
1922 | Gandhi in Young India: swaraj not a gift of Parliament; the Constitution to reflect Indians' wishes |
Feb 1924 | Motilal Nehru's "National Demand" resolution in the Central Legislative Assembly — first clear demand for a constitution and procedure |
1925 | Commonwealth of India Bill (Annie Besant, Tej Bahadur Sapru, V.S. Srinivasa Sastri); backed by the Labour Party; first reading Dec 1925, defeated; demanded dominion equality |
1927 | Simon Commission (all-white) |
Aug 1928 | Nehru Report — first Indian draft constitution: dominion status, sovereignty of people, fundamental rights, federation with residuary powers at Centre, joint electorates (→ page 16) |
Dec 1929 | Lahore: Purna Swaraj |
1933/34 | Idea of a Constituent Assembly — first suggested by M.N. Roy (1927/1934); Nehru first national leader to enunciate it (1933); Congress official demand 1934 (CWC, rejecting the 1933 White Paper) |
1936 | Lucknow Congress: no constitution imposed from outside |
1937 | Congress ministries' assemblies (and Sind) passed resolutions demanding a Constituent Assembly (draft by J.B. Kripalani); S. Satyamurti's resolution in the Central Assembly (Sept 1937) |
1938 | Haripura reiterated |
1940 | August Offer — first British acceptance that Indians would frame their constitution (after the war) |
1942 | Cripps — conceded a constitution-making body |
Sept 1945 | Labour government announced a constituent assembly |
1946 | Cabinet Mission (arrived 24 March) — scheme of the CA and interim government |
- Mridula Mukherjee rejects the view that the Constitution was simply the culmination of British Acts (1861, 1892, 1909, 1919, 1935) — British concessions always fell short of nationalist demands.
11. Formation of the Constituent Assembly ⭐⭐⭐
- Indirectly elected by provincial assemblies (themselves elected on a limited franchise of 1935 — over 70% of adults excluded).
- Seats allotted by population — roughly 1 per million; divided among three communities — General, Muslim, Sikh; elected by each community's members by proportional representation with single transferable vote.
- Total 389: 296 from British India (292 from 11 Governors' provinces + 4 from Chief Commissioners' provinces — Delhi, Ajmer-Merwara, Coorg, British Baluchistan) + 93 from princely states (nominated by rulers).
- Elections July–August 1946: Congress 208, Muslim League 73, others/independents 15. States' seats remained vacant initially; Baroda, Bikaner, Jaipur, Patiala, Rewa, Udaipur joined by April 1947; all states by after August 1947.
- League boycotted. Congress appointed an expert committee and joined the interim government (2 Sept 1946).
- First meeting: 9 December 1946, Constitution Hall (now Central Hall of Parliament); 207 members attended. Dr Sachchidananda Sinha 🟣 (oldest member) — provisional (temporary) President, proposed by J.B. Kripalani (French practice).
- 11 December 1946: Dr Rajendra Prasad 🟣 elected permanent President; Vice-Presidents H.C. Mookerjee and V.T. Krishnamachari; B.N. Rau constitutional adviser.
- 13 December 1946: Nehru moved the Objectives Resolution (adopted 22 January 1947) — basis of the Preamble: independent sovereign republic, sovereignty from the people, autonomous units with residuary powers (then), justice, equality, freedoms, minority safeguards.
- 26 June 1947: Mountbatten announced a separate CA for Pakistan. Indian Independence Act (in force 18 July 1947) made the CA a fully sovereign body; Section 8 gave it full legislative power. After partition, membership fell to 299 (229 provinces + 70 states).
- From 15 August 1947 it had two roles — constitution-making (chaired by Rajendra Prasad) and Dominion Legislature (chaired by G.V. Mavalankar).
Evaluation
- A result of Congress compromises: not fully sovereign at first; not elected by adult franchise; accepted communal representation, the grouping plan and a weak centre.
- But it mirrored the country's ideological range: socialists (Marxian and democratic — Nehru among the moderate group), rightists (Patel, Purushottam Das Tandon, S.P. Mookerjee), Gandhians (village panchayats). Dominant influence: liberals and democratic socialists. Congress had over 80% after partition.
- Granville Austin: an "oligarchy" of four — Nehru, Patel, Rajendra Prasad, Azad dominated; the CWC was the real architect. Decisions by consensus (unanimity or near-unanimity) and "accommodation".
12. Committees ⭐⭐
Committee | Chairman |
Union Powers Committee | Jawaharlal Nehru |
Union Constitution Committee | Jawaharlal Nehru |
States Committee (negotiating with states) | Jawaharlal Nehru |
Provincial Constitution Committee | Sardar Patel |
Advisory Committee on Fundamental Rights, Minorities, Tribal & Excluded Areas | Sardar Patel (sub-committees: FR — J.B. Kripalani; Minorities — H.C. Mookerjee; NE Tribal — Gopinath Bordoloi; Excluded areas other than Assam — A.V. Thakkar) |
Rules of Procedure Committee, Steering Committee | Rajendra Prasad |
Drafting Committee | B.R. Ambedkar |
(Committee chairs from general knowledge.)
Drafting Committee (set up 29 August 1947) ⭐⭐
Seven members: B.R. Ambedkar (Chairman, then Law Minister), N. Gopalaswami Ayyangar, Alladi Krishnaswami Ayyar, K.M. Munshi, Syed Mohammad Saadulla, B.L. Mitter (resigned → N. Madhava Rau), D.P. Khaitan (died 1948 → T.T. Krishnamachari).
13. Five stages of work and adoption
- Committees reported on basic issues (April–August 1947).
- B.N. Rau (Calcutta HC judge, Constitutional Adviser) prepared an initial draft (end Oct 1947) — 240 clauses, 13 schedules.
- Drafting Committee's draft published for public comment (February 1948).
- Second draft — 315 articles, 8/9 schedules — placed before the Assembly 21 February 1948; debated clause by clause (second reading Nov 1948–Oct 1949). ~7,635 amendments proposed (~7,000), ~2,473 (~2,500) discussed.
- Third reading 14–26 November 1949; Preamble adopted last.
- 26 November 1949: Constitution adopted, enacted and given to themselves by "We, the people" (now Constitution/Samvidhan Divas). Original: Preamble, 395 articles, 8 schedules, 22 parts. Some provisions (citizenship, elections, provisional parliament) came into force immediately.
- Time taken: 2 years, 11 months, 18 days; 11 sessions; 165 days of sittings.
- 24 January 1950 (last day): 284 members signed; National Anthem and National Song adopted; Rajendra Prasad elected first President.
- National Flag adopted 22 July 1947.
- 26 January 1950: Constitution came into force (anniversary of the 1930 Purna Swaraj Day). CA became the Provisional Parliament till the first Lok Sabha (1952).
- Ambedkar on minority claims: claims of minorities called communalism, the majority's monopoly called nationalism.
🧠 Memory box
- CA dates "9-11-13" December 1946: first meeting (9) → Prasad President (11) → Objectives Resolution (13); adopted 22 Jan 1947.
- "389 = 296 + 93"; "292 + 4 = 296"; Congress 208, League 73.
- Draft milestones: B.N. Rau Oct 1947 → Draft Feb 1948 → Third reading 14–26 Nov 1949 → Signed 24 Jan 1950 → In force 26 Jan 1950.
- Flag 22 July 1947; Anthem & Song 24 Jan 1950.
- States: "Ring Fence → Subordinate Isolation → Subordinate Union → Equal Federation → Integration".
- Problem states "J-H-K": Junagadh = plebiscite · Hyderabad = police action (Polo) · Kashmir = Instrument of Accession 26 Oct 1947.
- Bihar 🟣: Sachchidananda Sinha (provisional president), Rajendra Prasad (president), Jagjivan Ram (first Labour Minister).
🎯 Exam traps
- ⚠️ Provisional President of the CA = Sachchidananda Sinha, not Rajendra Prasad.
- ⚠️ Objectives Resolution moved 13 Dec 1946, adopted 22 Jan 1947.
- ⚠️ Constituent Assembly idea: first by M.N. Roy; first national leader = Nehru; official Congress demand 1934; first British acceptance = August Offer 1940.
- ⚠️ First minister to resign = S.P. Mookerjee (April 1950, over the Nehru–Liaquat Pact).
- ⚠️ Radcliffe Award published after independence (17 Aug 1947).
- ⚠️ Chamber of Princes = Narendra Mandal (1921), purely advisory.
- ⚠️ CA members were indirectly elected — not by adult franchise.