Notes · History

27 · Challenges after 1947, Integration of Princely States & Making of the Constitution

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

14 min read18 sections

27 · Challenges after 1947, Integration of Princely States & Making of the Constitution

📌
Sub-topics: First day and first cabinet · Radcliffe Award and riots · division of assets · Gandhi's assassination · refugees and Nehru–Liaquat Pact · communist insurgency | British policy towards states (6 stages) · Chamber of Princes · Butler Committee · integration: Junagadh, Hyderabad, Kashmir | Constituent Assembly: background, formation, committees, drafting, adoption.

PART A — CHALLENGES BEFORE THE NEWBORN NATION (Ch 33)

1. The first day of independence

  • Constituent Assembly met at 11 p.m., 14 August 1947, presided by Rajendra Prasad; at midnight Nehru gave the "Tryst with Destiny" speech in the Constitution Hall.
  • 15 August 1947: Nehru hoisted the national flag above the Lahori Gate of the Red Fort.
  • Governor-General: Lord Mountbatten (to June 1948), then C. Rajagopalachari — first and last Indian Governor-General — till 26 January 1950, when Rajendra Prasad became first President.
  • Patel was Deputy PM till his death in December 1950.

First Council of Ministers (15 August 1947) ⭐

Minister
Portfolio
Jawaharlal Nehru
PM; External Affairs & Commonwealth Relations; Scientific Research
Vallabhbhai Patel
Deputy PM; Home; States; Information & Broadcasting
Maulana Abul Kalam Azad
Education
John Mathai
Railways & Transport
Sardar Baldev Singh
Defence
Jairamdas Daulatram
Food & Agriculture
Jagjivan Ram 🟣
Labour
C.H. Bhabha
Commerce
Rajkumari Amrit Kaur
Health (only woman)
Rafi Ahmad Kidwai
Communications
N.V. Gadgil
Works, Mines & Power
R.K. Shanmukham Chetty
Finance (presented first budget, 26 Nov 1947)
K.C. Neogy
Relief & Rehabilitation
B.R. Ambedkar
Law (Scheduled Castes Federation; resigned 1951 over Hindu Code Bill)
Shyama Prasad Mookerjee
Industries & Supplies (Hindu Mahasabha; first to resign, April 1950)
N. Gopalaswami Ayyangar
Without portfolio (link with East Punjab govt)
Mohanlal Saxena
Without portfolio

2. Challenges

  • Immediate: integrating princely states; communal riots; rehabilitating ~60 lakh refugees from West Pakistan; protecting Muslims; avoiding war with Pakistan; communist insurgency.
  • Medium-term: framing the Constitution; a representative, democratic, civil-libertarian order; elections; ending agrarian feudalism.
  • Long-term: national integration, economic development, poverty removal.
  • The Independence Act set procedures for: (i) boundaries; (ii) division of civil services; (iii) division of the armed forces.

3. Radcliffe Award and the riots ⭐

  • Punjab and Bengal assemblies met in two sections (Muslim-majority districts vs rest) and by simple majority voted to partition the provinces.
Unit
Area (sq miles)
Population (1941)
Muslims
West Punjab (Pak)
62,000
15.7 million
11.85 million
East Punjab (India)
37,000
12.6 million
4.37 million
West Bengal (India)
28,000
21.2 million
5.3 million
East Bengal (Pak)
49,400
39.1 million
27.7 million
  • Result: ~20 million non-Muslims in Pakistan and ~42 million (later 35 million) Muslims in India became minorities.
  • Boundary Commissions chaired by Sir Cyril Radcliffe — each with two Muslim and two non-Muslim judges; Radcliffe had never been to India ("never been east of Gibraltar"); out-of-date maps and faulty 1941 census; only six weeks.
  • Factors besides religion: rivers, administrative units, economic viability, rail/road links, canals. Sikhs were scattered and demanded all shrines in East Punjab.
  • Award ready by 12 August but published on 17 August 1947 (after independence) so that responsibility for the violence would not fall on the British.
  • Riots: began August 1946 (Direct Action); worst along the Radcliffe Line; ~1,80,000 killed (60,000 west, 1,20,000 east, per one estimate); trains of dead bodies.
  • Bengal calmer due to Gandhi's presence and fasts (Calcutta, the "one-man boundary force"). Delhi saw massacres of Muslims.
  • 🟣 Bihar, October 1946: Hindu peasants (allegedly incited by landlords to divert agrarian anger) killed Muslims — followed by Garhmukteshwar (UP). After partition, Gandhi's efforts prevented massacres there.
  • Punjab Boundary Force of 50,000 under Mountbatten's plan (commander Maj-Gen Pete Rees) itself split communally; Nehru didn't want British troops; European officers were leaving. Gen. Lockhart (C-in-C, 15 Aug–31 Dec 1947) believed disorder could have been controlled had personnel been placed in their new countries earlier.

4. Division of resources

  • Partition Council chaired by the Governor-General, two representatives each from India and Pakistan; Steering Committee of H.M. Patel and Chaudhri Muhammad Ali. ~1,60,000 civil employees opted to move.
  • ICS: Indians continued in their chosen country on existing terms; Europeans could continue or retire with compensation.
  • Finances: Pakistan wanted a quarter of cash balances. India withheld Pakistan's share of the sterling balances (~Rs 55 crore) because of Pakistan's attack on Kashmir; Gandhi's fast (January 1948) forced its release — cited by some as a motive for his assassination.
  • Armed forces: Joint Defence Council under Field Marshal Auchinleck as Supreme Commander; Muslim-majority units to Pakistan; post abolished due to disputes. British troops left from 17 August 1947, completed by February 1948.

5. Assassination of Gandhi ⭐

  • 30 January 1948, evening prayer meeting at Birla House, New Delhi; shot by Nathuram Godse.
  • Nehru on AIR: "The light has gone out of our lives…". Patel appealed against revenge.
  • Godse tried and sentenced to death (hanged Nov 1949, with Narayan Apte).
  • RSS banned on 4 February 1948; ban lifted July 1949 after it accepted conditions: cultural activities only, renounce violence and secrecy, loyalty to the Constitution and tricolour, democratic organisation.

6. Refugees and rehabilitation

  • No organised population exchange. Emergency Committee of the Cabinet for Delhi; Ministry of Relief and Rehabilitation.
  • "Evacuee property" protection became rhetoric — refugees occupied empty Muslim houses.
  • East Punjab: camps till 1949; vocational training and business grants for urban refugees; land, loans, housing subsidies for rural; benefits skewed towards those with caste/class/political capital.
  • Bengal: prolonged problem. Khulna violence (Dec 1949–Jan 1950) → anti-Muslim riots Feb 1950 (~1 million Muslims left WB) → by 1951 ~15 lakh Hindu refugees in WB.
  • Nehru–Liaquat Pact / Delhi Pact (8 April 1950) ⭐: minority ministers at centre and provinces; minority commissions; commissions of inquiry into riots; minority representatives in the cabinets of East Pakistan and West Bengal; two central ministers posted to affected areas; agency to recover abducted women. Opposed by S.P. Mookerjee and K.C. Neogy — both resigned. (Mookerjee founded the Bharatiya Jana Sangh, 1951.)
  • Settlements: Delhi — Lajpat Nagar, Rajinder Nagar, Punjabi Bagh, Nizamuddin East, Kingsway Camp; Sindhis — Gujarat, Maharashtra (Ulhasnagar), Rajasthan, MP; East Pakistan refugees — West Bengal, Assam, Tripura, NE, Andamans.

7. The communists and independence

  • December 1947: CPI called independence fake — "Yeh azadi jhooti hai"; Nehru government a stooge of Anglo-American imperialism.
  • Second Congress, Calcutta (Feb–March 1948): "Political Thesis" — national government the main enemy; armed revolution — the B.T. Ranadive line; aim: a "people's democratic republic". Insurgency in Telangana, West Bengal (Tebhaga revival, urban insurgency in Calcutta).
  • Reasons: class struggle to divert from communal politics; communist successes in China, Malaya, Indonesia, Philippines, Burma; Soviet Zhdanov thesis (Sept 1947, answer to the Marshall Plan); Telangana success misread as "Red India" (Guha).
  • Government: police action in Hyderabad; CPI banned in West Bengal (March 1948); preventive detention. Failed railway strike (9 May 1949); split over "Chinese line" vs "Russian line".
  • Sept 1950: Ajoy Ghosh, S.A. Dange, S.V. Ghate criticised the line. Third Party Congress, Calcutta (Oct 1951): Telangana withdrawn, broad front; ban lifted; CPI fought the 1951–52 elections — from insurrection to constitutional politics.

PART B — THE INDIAN (PRINCELY) STATES (Ch 34)

  • 562 states (often cited 565) over 7,12,508 sq miles; from tiny Bilbari (27 people) to Hyderabad (as large as Italy, 14 million). The Company had taken the coasts, river valleys and fertile tracts; states were mostly the inaccessible, less fertile areas.

8. Stages of British policy towards states ⭐⭐

Stage
Period
Essence
I. Struggle for equality from subordination
1740–1765
Anglo-French rivalry; capture of Arcot (1751); Plassey 1757; Diwani (1765) made the Company a major power
II. Ring Fence
1765–1813
Buffer zones to defend frontiers (Warren Hastings' wars with Marathas, Mysore; Awadh's defence to protect Bengal); Wellesley's subsidiary alliance an extension — Hyderabad, Awadh, Marathas accepted
III. Subordinate Isolation
1813–1857
Paramountcy theory (Hastings); states lost external sovereignty, kept internal; Residents became controlling officers; Charter Act 1833; prior sanction for successions; 1834 Directors' guidelines to annex whenever possible → Dalhousie's Doctrine of Lapse (Satara, Nagpur, Jhansi etc.)
IV. Subordinate Union
1858–1935
Annexation abandoned ("punish or depose but not annex"); succession a gift of the Crown; Kaiser-i-Hind (1876); interference for princes', people's, foreigners' or all-India interest; railways, telegraph, press aided control; Butler: for international relations state territory = British territory
V. Equal Federation
1935–1947
GoI Act 1935 federation — 125 of 375 seats in Federal Assembly and 104 of 260 in Council of States for princes; needed accession of states with half the population; never came into force, dropped after WWII began
VI. Integration and Merger
1947–1950
Patel and V.P. Menon
  • Curzon: princes as servants of the people working alongside the Governor-General; policy of patronage and "intrusive surveillance"; relationship neither feudal nor federal.
  • Post-1905: "cordial cooperation" with princes against nationalist and revolutionary unrest.
  • Chamber of Princes (Narendra Mandal) — recommended by Montford, set up 8 Feb 1921: consultative only; no say in internal affairs. States classified: 109 directly represented; 127 through representatives (12 seats); the rest as feudal holdings/jagirs.
  • Butler Committee (1927) (Harcourt Butler): paramountcy must remain supreme and adapt to changing needs; states not to be handed over to an Indian government responsible to an Indian legislature without their consent — paramountcy left undefined ("a hydra-headed creature").
  • 🟣 States' people's movements: All India States People's Conference (1927); Congress at Haripura (1938) declared Purna Swaraj for states too; Nehru its president in 1939.

9. Integration (1947–49) ⭐⭐⭐

  • Cripps (1942): paramountcy would not pass to any Indian party. States dreamt of sovereignty or a "third force". Attlee's Statement and June 3 Plan: paramountcy lapses; states free to join either dominion; Mountbatten refused sovereign status.
  • States Department (set up 5 July 1947) — Sardar Patel with secretary V.P. Menon. Rulers asked to sign the Instrument of Accession on three subjects — defence, external affairs, communications (which they never controlled anyway) — plus a Standstill Agreement. By 15 August 1947, 136 states had joined (all but a few).

The problem states

State
Problem
Resolution
Junagadh (Kathiawar)
Muslim Nawab (Mahabat Khan) acceded to Pakistan; Hindu majority wanted India
Popular revolt, Indian troops; plebiscite (Feb 1948) — overwhelmingly for India
Hyderabad
Nizam (Mir Osman Ali Khan) wanted sovereignty and a sea outlet (Goa)
Standstill Agreement (Nov 1947); Razakar violence (Kasim Razvi), foreign arms → "police action" — Operation Polo, 13–17 Sept 1948; formal accession Nov 1949
Jammu & Kashmir
Hindu ruler (Hari Singh), Muslim majority; wanted independence
Pakistani tribal raiders (Oct 1947) → Instrument of Accession (26 Oct 1947), endorsed by Sheikh Abdullah; Indian troops airlifted; India went to the UN (Jan 1948); ceasefire (1 Jan 1949) left ~84,000 sq km under Pakistani occupation; special status under Article 370
(Also: Travancore's Dewan C.P. Ramaswamy Aiyar and Bhopal's Nawab initially resisted; Jodhpur flirted with Pakistan — general knowledge.)

Gradual integration ("merger and democratisation")

  1. 216 small states merged into neighbouring provinces (Part A) — e.g., 39 Orissa/Chhattisgarh states into Orissa and CP; Gujarat states into Bombay.
  1. 61 states made centrally administered (Part C) for strategic/special reasons — Himachal Pradesh, Vindhya Pradesh, Manipur, Tripura, Bhopal, Kutch etc.
  1. Five unions (Part B, with Hyderabad, Mysore, J&K): United States of Kathiawar (Saurashtra), Matsya Union, PEPSU (Patiala and East Punjab States Union), Rajasthan, Travancore-Cochin, plus Madhya Bharat. Headed by a Rajpramukh; rulers got privy purses (abolished 1971 by the 26th Amendment).
  • Unions and Mysore accepted Union jurisdiction (except taxation), subject to Article 238 and 10 years' Union supervision.
  • Seventh Amendment (1956) abolished the Part A/B/C classification (with the States Reorganisation Act) → uniform set-up.

PART C — MAKING OF THE CONSTITUTION (Ch 35)

10. Background — the demand for a Constituent Assembly ⭐

Year
Step
1895
Constitution of India Bill (Home Rule Bill) — rights like free expression, equality before law, inviolable home, property; Annie Besant thought it inspired by Tilak
1922
Gandhi in Young India: swaraj not a gift of Parliament; the Constitution to reflect Indians' wishes
Feb 1924
Motilal Nehru's "National Demand" resolution in the Central Legislative Assembly — first clear demand for a constitution and procedure
1925
Commonwealth of India Bill (Annie Besant, Tej Bahadur Sapru, V.S. Srinivasa Sastri); backed by the Labour Party; first reading Dec 1925, defeated; demanded dominion equality
1927
Simon Commission (all-white)
Aug 1928
Nehru Report — first Indian draft constitution: dominion status, sovereignty of people, fundamental rights, federation with residuary powers at Centre, joint electorates (→ page 16)
Dec 1929
Lahore: Purna Swaraj
1933/34
Idea of a Constituent Assembly — first suggested by M.N. Roy (1927/1934); Nehru first national leader to enunciate it (1933); Congress official demand 1934 (CWC, rejecting the 1933 White Paper)
1936
Lucknow Congress: no constitution imposed from outside
1937
Congress ministries' assemblies (and Sind) passed resolutions demanding a Constituent Assembly (draft by J.B. Kripalani); S. Satyamurti's resolution in the Central Assembly (Sept 1937)
1938
Haripura reiterated
1940
August Offer — first British acceptance that Indians would frame their constitution (after the war)
1942
Cripps — conceded a constitution-making body
Sept 1945
Labour government announced a constituent assembly
1946
Cabinet Mission (arrived 24 March) — scheme of the CA and interim government
  • Mridula Mukherjee rejects the view that the Constitution was simply the culmination of British Acts (1861, 1892, 1909, 1919, 1935) — British concessions always fell short of nationalist demands.

11. Formation of the Constituent Assembly ⭐⭐⭐

  • Indirectly elected by provincial assemblies (themselves elected on a limited franchise of 1935 — over 70% of adults excluded).
  • Seats allotted by population — roughly 1 per million; divided among three communities — General, Muslim, Sikh; elected by each community's members by proportional representation with single transferable vote.
  • Total 389: 296 from British India (292 from 11 Governors' provinces + 4 from Chief Commissioners' provinces — Delhi, Ajmer-Merwara, Coorg, British Baluchistan) + 93 from princely states (nominated by rulers).
  • Elections July–August 1946: Congress 208, Muslim League 73, others/independents 15. States' seats remained vacant initially; Baroda, Bikaner, Jaipur, Patiala, Rewa, Udaipur joined by April 1947; all states by after August 1947.
  • League boycotted. Congress appointed an expert committee and joined the interim government (2 Sept 1946).
  • First meeting: 9 December 1946, Constitution Hall (now Central Hall of Parliament); 207 members attended. Dr Sachchidananda Sinha 🟣 (oldest member) — provisional (temporary) President, proposed by J.B. Kripalani (French practice).
  • 11 December 1946: Dr Rajendra Prasad 🟣 elected permanent President; Vice-Presidents H.C. Mookerjee and V.T. Krishnamachari; B.N. Rau constitutional adviser.
  • 13 December 1946: Nehru moved the Objectives Resolution (adopted 22 January 1947) — basis of the Preamble: independent sovereign republic, sovereignty from the people, autonomous units with residuary powers (then), justice, equality, freedoms, minority safeguards.
  • 26 June 1947: Mountbatten announced a separate CA for Pakistan. Indian Independence Act (in force 18 July 1947) made the CA a fully sovereign body; Section 8 gave it full legislative power. After partition, membership fell to 299 (229 provinces + 70 states).
  • From 15 August 1947 it had two roles — constitution-making (chaired by Rajendra Prasad) and Dominion Legislature (chaired by G.V. Mavalankar).

Evaluation

  • A result of Congress compromises: not fully sovereign at first; not elected by adult franchise; accepted communal representation, the grouping plan and a weak centre.
  • But it mirrored the country's ideological range: socialists (Marxian and democratic — Nehru among the moderate group), rightists (Patel, Purushottam Das Tandon, S.P. Mookerjee), Gandhians (village panchayats). Dominant influence: liberals and democratic socialists. Congress had over 80% after partition.
  • Granville Austin: an "oligarchy" of four — Nehru, Patel, Rajendra Prasad, Azad dominated; the CWC was the real architect. Decisions by consensus (unanimity or near-unanimity) and "accommodation".

12. Committees ⭐⭐

Committee
Chairman
Union Powers Committee
Jawaharlal Nehru
Union Constitution Committee
Jawaharlal Nehru
States Committee (negotiating with states)
Jawaharlal Nehru
Provincial Constitution Committee
Sardar Patel
Advisory Committee on Fundamental Rights, Minorities, Tribal & Excluded Areas
Sardar Patel (sub-committees: FR — J.B. Kripalani; Minorities — H.C. Mookerjee; NE Tribal — Gopinath Bordoloi; Excluded areas other than Assam — A.V. Thakkar)
Rules of Procedure Committee, Steering Committee
Rajendra Prasad
Drafting Committee
B.R. Ambedkar
(Committee chairs from general knowledge.)

Drafting Committee (set up 29 August 1947) ⭐⭐

Seven members: B.R. Ambedkar (Chairman, then Law Minister), N. Gopalaswami Ayyangar, Alladi Krishnaswami Ayyar, K.M. Munshi, Syed Mohammad Saadulla, B.L. Mitter (resigned → N. Madhava Rau), D.P. Khaitan (died 1948 → T.T. Krishnamachari).

13. Five stages of work and adoption

  1. Committees reported on basic issues (April–August 1947).
  1. B.N. Rau (Calcutta HC judge, Constitutional Adviser) prepared an initial draft (end Oct 1947) — 240 clauses, 13 schedules.
  1. Drafting Committee's draft published for public comment (February 1948).
  1. Second draft — 315 articles, 8/9 schedules — placed before the Assembly 21 February 1948; debated clause by clause (second reading Nov 1948–Oct 1949). ~7,635 amendments proposed (~7,000), ~2,473 (~2,500) discussed.
  1. Third reading 14–26 November 1949; Preamble adopted last.
  • 26 November 1949: Constitution adopted, enacted and given to themselves by "We, the people" (now Constitution/Samvidhan Divas). Original: Preamble, 395 articles, 8 schedules, 22 parts. Some provisions (citizenship, elections, provisional parliament) came into force immediately.
  • Time taken: 2 years, 11 months, 18 days; 11 sessions; 165 days of sittings.
  • 24 January 1950 (last day): 284 members signed; National Anthem and National Song adopted; Rajendra Prasad elected first President.
  • National Flag adopted 22 July 1947.
  • 26 January 1950: Constitution came into force (anniversary of the 1930 Purna Swaraj Day). CA became the Provisional Parliament till the first Lok Sabha (1952).
  • Ambedkar on minority claims: claims of minorities called communalism, the majority's monopoly called nationalism.

🧠 Memory box

  • CA dates "9-11-13" December 1946: first meeting (9) → Prasad President (11) → Objectives Resolution (13); adopted 22 Jan 1947.
  • "389 = 296 + 93"; "292 + 4 = 296"; Congress 208, League 73.
  • Draft milestones: B.N. Rau Oct 1947 → Draft Feb 1948 → Third reading 14–26 Nov 1949 → Signed 24 Jan 1950 → In force 26 Jan 1950.
  • Flag 22 July 1947; Anthem & Song 24 Jan 1950.
  • States: "Ring Fence → Subordinate Isolation → Subordinate Union → Equal Federation → Integration".
  • Problem states "J-H-K": Junagadh = plebiscite · Hyderabad = police action (Polo) · Kashmir = Instrument of Accession 26 Oct 1947.
  • Bihar 🟣: Sachchidananda Sinha (provisional president), Rajendra Prasad (president), Jagjivan Ram (first Labour Minister).

🎯 Exam traps

  • ⚠️ Provisional President of the CA = Sachchidananda Sinha, not Rajendra Prasad.
  • ⚠️ Objectives Resolution moved 13 Dec 1946, adopted 22 Jan 1947.
  • ⚠️ Constituent Assembly idea: first by M.N. Roy; first national leader = Nehru; official Congress demand 1934; first British acceptance = August Offer 1940.
  • ⚠️ First minister to resign = S.P. Mookerjee (April 1950, over the Nehru–Liaquat Pact).
  • ⚠️ Radcliffe Award published after independence (17 Aug 1947).
  • ⚠️ Chamber of Princes = Narendra Mandal (1921), purely advisory.
  • ⚠️ CA members were indirectly elected — not by adult franchise.