Sub-topics: Press laws 1799–1947 · nationalist newspapers · Vernacular Press Act · Tilak and press freedom | Education: Orientalist–Anglicist debate · Macaulay · Wood’s Despatch · Hunter, Raleigh, Sadler, Hartog · Wardha · Sargent · vernacular and technical education.
PART A — DEVELOPMENT OF THE INDIAN PRESS1. Beginnings2. Press laws — timeline ⭐⭐3. The Vernacular Press Act, 1878 ⭐⭐4. Nationalist press and its role5. Repression of journalistsPART B — DEVELOPMENT OF EDUCATION6. Under Company rule7. Orientalist–Anglicist controversy and Macaulay’s Minute ⭐⭐8. James Thomason’s village education (1843–53)9. Wood’s Despatch (1854) ⭐⭐⭐10. After the Crown takeoverHunter Education Commission (1882–83) ⭐Raleigh Commission (1902) → Indian Universities Act, 1904 ⭐Gokhale and compulsory educationGovernment Resolution on Education Policy, 1913Sadler (Calcutta University) Commission (1917–19) ⭐Education under dyarchy (1919)Hartog Committee (1929)Wardha Scheme of Basic Education (1937) — Nai Talim ⭐Sargent Plan (1944) ⭐11. Vernacular education timeline12. Technical education13. Evaluation of British education policy🧠 Memory box🎯 Exam traps
PART A — DEVELOPMENT OF THE INDIAN PRESS
1. Beginnings
- 1780: James Augustus Hicky started The Bengal Gazette (Calcutta General Advertiser) — first newspaper in India; seized in 1782 for criticising the government.
- Others: Bengal Journal, Calcutta Chronicle, Madras Courier, Bombay Herald. Company officers feared exposure in London → curbs.
2. Press laws — timeline ⭐⭐
Year | Law / step | Governor-General | Key points |
1799 | Censorship of Press Act | Wellesley | Wartime curbs (fear of French invasion), pre-censorship. Relaxed by Lord Hastings; pre-censorship dropped 1818 |
1823 | Licensing Regulations | John Adam (acting GG) | Press without licence a penal offence; later extended to journals, books; aimed at Indian-language papers. Rammohan Roy’s Mirat-ul-Akbar closed; Rammohan protested (1824) |
1835 | Press Act / Metcalfe Act | Charles Metcalfe (1835–36) | Repealed 1823 rules — “Liberator of the Indian Press”; printer/publisher to declare premises; rapid growth of papers |
1857 | Licensing Act | Canning | Emergency of 1857 — licensing on top of registration; power to stop any publication |
1867 | Registration Act | John Lawrence | Replaced Metcalfe’s Act; regulatory not restrictive — print name of printer, publisher, place; copy to government within a month |
1870 | IPC Section 124A (sedition) | Mayo | Transportation for life or up to 3 years for causing disaffection |
1878 | Vernacular Press Act | Lytton | “Gagging Act” (below) |
1882 | VPA repealed | Ripon | — |
1898 | Section 124A amended; Section 153A added | Elgin II | Offence to bring the government into contempt or create hatred between classes (incl. against English in India) |
1908 | Newspapers (Incitement to Offences) Act | Minto II | Magistrates could confiscate press property publishing material inciting murder/violence (against Extremists) |
1910 | Indian Press Act | Minto II | Revived VPA’s worst features — security at registration, forfeiture, deregistration; 2 free copies of each issue to government. Nearly 1,000 papers prosecuted, ~Rs 5 lakh securities/forfeitures in 5 years, 500+ publications proscribed |
1914–18 | Defence of India Rules | Hardinge, Chelmsford | Wartime repression |
1921 | Press Acts of 1908 and 1910 repealed | Reading | On recommendation of the Press Committee under Tej Bahadur Sapru |
1931 | Indian Press (Emergency Powers) Act | Irwin/Willingdon | Sweeping provincial powers against CDM propaganda; widened in 1932 to all activity undermining authority |
1939–45 | Defence of India Rules | Linlithgow | Pre-censorship; Press Emergency and Official Secrets Acts amended; at one time all Congress news banned |
3. The Vernacular Press Act, 1878 ⭐⭐
- Background: post-1857 racial bitterness; European press backed the government, vernacular press criticised it — esp. Lytton’s handling of the 1876–77 famine and lavish Delhi Durbar (1877).
- Purpose: “better control” and punish “seditious writing” in “publications in oriental languages”.
- Provisions:
- District magistrate could make a vernacular printer/publisher sign a bond not to cause disaffection or antipathy between religions, castes, races; demand a security deposit (forfeitable); seize press equipment on repetition.
- Magistrate’s action final — no appeal in a court.
- Exemption possible by submitting proofs to a government censor (pre-censorship; later dropped and a Press Commissioner appointed to supply news).
- Worst features: discrimination between English and vernacular press; no appeal.
- Proceedings against Som Prakash, Bharat Mihir, Dacca Prakash, Samachar. Amrita Bazar Patrika turned into an English paper overnight to escape it.
- Repealed by Ripon (1882).
4. Nationalist press and its role
- 1870–1918: the movement relied on press for propaganda and political education; the early Congress spread its resolutions only through the press.
- Papers were a national service, not business; read aloud and discussed in village “libraries” — political education and participation; acted as the opposition to government.
- Tricks to evade sedition laws: preface critical articles with loyal sentiments; quote British socialists or Irish nationalists.
Newspaper | Editor / founder |
The Hindu (English), Swadesamitran (Tamil) | G. Subramania Aiyar |
The Bengalee | Surendranath Banerjea |
Voice of India | Dadabhai Naoroji |
Amrita Bazar Patrika | Sisir Kumar Ghosh & Motilal Ghosh |
Indian Mirror | N.N. Sen |
Kesari (Marathi), Mahratta (English) | B.G. Tilak |
Sudharak | G.G. Agarkar |
Hindustan and Advocate | G.P. Verma |
Tribune, Akhbar-i-Am | Punjab |
Gujarati, Indu Prakash, Dnyan Prakash, Kal | Bombay |
Som Prakash, Banganivasi, Sadharani | Bengal |
(🟣 Bihar: Bihar Herald (1875, Guru Prasad Sen), Bihar Bandhu, Beharee (Sachchidanand Sinha), The Searchlight (1918) — from general knowledge.)
5. Repression of journalists
- 1883: Surendranath Banerjea — first Indian journalist imprisoned (for a Bengalee editorial criticising a Calcutta High Court judge for insensitivity to Bengali religious sentiment).
- Tilak — most associated with press freedom:
- Ganapati festival (1893), Shivaji festival (1896); Kesari and Mahratta.
- Among first to want lower middle class, peasants, artisans, workers in the Congress.
- 1896: all-Maharashtra boycott of foreign cloth against cotton excise duty; 1896–97: no-tax campaign where crops failed.
- 1897: Poona plague — resentment at segregation, house searches → Chapekars killed Rand. Tilak arrested for the poem “Shivaji’s Utterances” in Kesari and a speech justifying Shivaji’s killing of Afzal Khan → 18 months’ rigorous imprisonment → became “Lokmanya”.
- 1908: sedition trial → 6 years in Mandalay; Bombay textile and railway workers fought the army and struck for days — Lenin hailed it as the Indian working class’s entry onto the political stage.
- “The government has converted the entire nation into a prison…”
PART B — DEVELOPMENT OF EDUCATION
6. Under Company rule
- For 60 years the Company ignored education, except:
- Calcutta Madrasah (1781) — Warren Hastings (Muslim law);
- Sanskrit College, Benaras (1791) — Jonathan Duncan, the Resident (Hindu law, philosophy);
- Fort William College (1800) — Wellesley (train civil servants in Indian languages; closed 1802). (Purpose: supply Indians for courts and correspondence.)
- Pressure from enlightened Indians and missionaries (esp. Serampore missionaries) for modern Western education.
- Charter Act 1813: Rs 1 lakh a year for learning and modern sciences — not spent till 1823 due to controversy.
- Calcutta (Hindu) College, 1817 (Bengali elite with David Hare/Rammohan) got a grant; government set up Sanskrit colleges at Calcutta, Delhi, Agra.
7. Orientalist–Anglicist controversy and Macaulay’s Minute ⭐⭐
- In the General Committee of Public Instruction (1823): Anglicists — spend only on modern Western studies; Orientalists (H.T. Prinsep etc.) — Western sciences for jobs but expand traditional learning. Anglicists split on medium — English vs vernaculars.
- Macaulay’s Minute (2 Feb 1835) settled it for the Anglicists — limited funds for Western sciences and literature through English only; “Indian learning inferior to European” (a single shelf of a good European library worth more than all native literature). Accepted by William Bentinck (English Education Act 1835).
- Result: English became the medium; a few English schools and colleges instead of many elementary schools — mass education neglected.
- Downward Filtration Theory: educate a small upper/middle class — “Indian in blood and colour, but English in tastes, opinions, morals and intellect” — who would interpret between government and masses and pass knowledge down via vernaculars.
- Modern ideas did reach masses — but via parties, press, pamphlets, platforms; modern education gave nationalists tools for social analysis, though curricula served colonial interests.
- 1844 (Hardinge I): English knowledge preferred for government jobs → decline of traditional learning.
8. James Thomason’s village education (1843–53)
Lt-Governor of the North-Western Provinces: vernacular village schools teaching useful subjects (mensuration, agriculture) to train staff for the new Revenue and PWD departments; model school in each tehsil; normal school for teachers.
9. Wood’s Despatch (1854) ⭐⭐⭐
Sir Charles Wood (President, Board of Control) — “Magna Carta of English Education in India”; first comprehensive plan.
- Government to take responsibility for mass education — repudiated downward filtration (on paper).
- Hierarchy: vernacular primary schools (villages) → Anglo-vernacular high schools and affiliated colleges (districts) → affiliating universities at Calcutta, Bombay, Madras (on London University model).
- English for higher studies, vernaculars at school.
- Stress on female and vocational education and teachers’ training.
- Education in government institutions to be secular.
- Grants-in-aid to private enterprise.
- Departments of Public Instruction in provinces.
Developments: universities of Calcutta, Bombay, Madras (1857); education departments in all provinces; Bethune School (1849) — J.E.D. Bethune (president, Council of Education) put girls’ schools on grants-in-aid; Agriculture Institute at Pusa (Bihar) 🟣; Engineering Institute at Roorkee. Wood’s ideals dominated for 5 decades.
10. After the Crown takeover
Hunter Education Commission (1882–83) ⭐
- Chaired by W.W. Hunter (Ripon); reviewed progress since 1854; focused on primary and secondary education (which suffered after education was transferred to provinces in 1870).
- Recommendations: state’s special care for primary education in the vernacular; control of primary education to new district and municipal boards; secondary education in two streams — literary (to university) and vocational (commercial careers); more female education outside presidency towns.
- Followed by growth of secondary and college education with Indian participation; teaching-cum-examining universities — Punjab University (1882), Allahabad University (1887).
Raleigh Commission (1902) → Indian Universities Act, 1904 ⭐
- Under Curzon; official view: quality fell under private management and colleges were “factories producing political revolutionaries”.
- Raleigh Commission barred from primary/secondary education.
- Act of 1904: universities to focus on study and research; fellows reduced and mostly nominated; government could veto senate regulations and make its own; stricter affiliation rules for private colleges; Rs 5 lakh a year for 5 years for higher education.
- Nationalists saw it as strengthening imperialism; Gokhale: “a retrograde measure”.
Gokhale and compulsory education
- Baroda introduced compulsory primary education in 1906.
- Gokhale’s Resolution (1910) in the Imperial Legislative Council: compulsory primary education where 35% of boys (6–10) already attend; central education department and secretary. Withdrawn on assurance; an education department was created.
- Gokhale’s Bill (March 1911) for free and compulsory primary education in phases — rejected.
Government Resolution on Education Policy, 1913
Refused compulsory education but accepted removal of illiteracy; provinces urged to give free elementary education to poorer sections; encourage private effort; improve secondary schools; a university in each province; teaching universities; practical curriculum for girls; more women teachers.
Sadler (Calcutta University) Commission (1917–19) ⭐
- Chaired by Michael Sadler; reviewed school to university.
- Recommendations: 12-year school course; entry to university after an intermediate stage for a 3-year degree; separate Board of Secondary and Intermediate Education; less rigid regulations; universities as centralised, unitary, residential, teaching, autonomous bodies; extend female, applied science, technical and teacher education.
- Impact: seven new universities 1916–21 — Mysore, Patna (1917) 🟣, Benaras (1916), Aligarh (1920), Dacca, Lucknow, Osmania; then Delhi, Agra, Annamalai; Honours courses, professors, education departments, Academic Councils; Inter-University Board (1925); student welfare boards. Criticised as too advanced for the time.
Education under dyarchy (1919)
Education became a provincial transferred subject; central grants (liberal since 1902) stopped; finance shortage; growth mainly through philanthropy.
Hartog Committee (1929)
- Auxiliary committee of the Simon Commission under Sir Philip Hartog.
- Primary: “wastage and stagnation” (dropouts due to poverty, ignorance, caste, conservatism, disease, crop failure; repeated classes due to single-teacher schools, unqualified teachers, few women teachers, poor inspection); recommended consolidation over expansion, government control and inspection, 4-year primary course adapted to local life, teacher training, schools as community centres.
- Secondary: too examination-oriented; diversified curricula; industrial and commercial courses.
- Higher: low standards, overcrowding, poor libraries; selective admission, honours courses.
- Women: equal importance; more girls’ schools; hygiene, home science, music.
- Improved quality but slowed expansion.
Wardha Scheme of Basic Education (1937) — Nai Talim ⭐
- Congress’s All-India Education Conference at Wardha (Oct 1937) → Zakir Hussain Committee drafted the scheme, based on Gandhi’s Harijan articles; principle: “learning through activity” (craft-centred).
- Gandhi: present education wasteful and harmful; English a permanent bar between the educated few and the masses.
- Provisions: free and compulsory education for 7–14; a basic handicraft (spinning, weaving, carpentry, agriculture, pottery, leather, home science); first 7 years in the mother tongue (Hindi taught where not the mother tongue); community service; social and scientific aspects of the craft; maths, general science, social studies, painting, music, PE; no religious instruction.
- A vision of a new non-violent society; stalled by WWII and resignation of ministries (1939).
Sargent Plan (1944) ⭐
- Sir John Sargent, Educational Adviser, memorandum to the Central Advisory Board of Education; aim: universal literacy in 40 years.
- Pre-primary free for 3–6 (women teachers).
- Universal, free, compulsory education 6–14: Junior Basic (6–11) + Senior Basic (11–14); learning through activity; crafts; PT and games.
- High school 6 years from age 11 for selected able children (fees + scholarships); academic and technical/vocational streams; mother tongue medium, English compulsory second language.
- University: 3-year degree after higher secondary; abolish intermediate; better admission, aid to poor students, research; an all-India body on the lines of the UK’s University Grants Committee (→ UGC).
- Also: adult illiteracy liquidated in 20 years; medical check-ups; special education for disabled; employment bureaus.
- Criticised: 40 years too long; too costly; England’s standard utopian. In hindsight realistic but ahead of its time.
11. Vernacular education timeline
Year | Step |
1835, 1836, 1838 | William Adam’s reports on vernacular education in Bengal and Bihar 🟣 |
1843–53 | James Thomason in NWP — model school in each tehsil, normal school |
1853 | Dalhousie’s minute strongly favouring vernacular education |
1854 | Wood’s Despatch — standards, supervision, normal schools |
1854–71 | Vernacular schools increased five-fold |
1882 | Hunter Commission — mass education through vernaculars |
1904 | Policy stressed vernacular education, more grants |
1929 | Hartog — gloomy picture of primary education |
1937 | Congress ministries encouraged them |
12. Technical education
- Roorkee Engineering College (1847) (Thomason College); Calcutta College of Engineering (1856); Poona Overseers’ School → Poona College of Engineering (1858); Guindy (Madras).
- Calcutta Medical College (1835).
- Curzon broadened professional education; set up the Agricultural Research Institute at Pusa 🟣 (1905; moved to Delhi after the 1934 earthquake).
13. Evaluation of British education policy
- Motives not philanthropic: pressure from Indians, missionaries and humane officials; cheap supply of clerks for administration and British firms (hence English); hope that educated Indians would expand the market for British goods and be reconciled to British rule.
- Traditional learning declined (esp. after 1844).
- Mass education neglected — illiteracy 84% (1911), 92% (1921) — gulf between the few educated and the masses.
- Paid education → monopoly of upper, richer, urban classes.
- Women’s education neglected (fear of orthodoxy, no utility for rule).
- Science and technical education neglected — by 1857 only three medical colleges and one engineering college (Roorkee, open only to Europeans and Eurasians).
🧠 Memory box
- Press: “W-A-M-C-R-L-R-M-S” → Wellesley 1799 · Adam 1823 · Metcalfe 1835 · Canning 1857 · Registration 1867 · Lytton 1878 · Ripon 1882 · Minto 1908/1910 · Sapru Committee 1921 · 1931 Emergency Powers.
- Education chain: 1781 Madrasah → 1791 Sanskrit College → 1800 Fort William → 1813 Rs 1 lakh → 1835 Macaulay → 1854 Wood → 1857 universities → 1882 Hunter → 1902 Raleigh → 1904 Act → 1913 Resolution → 1917 Sadler → 1929 Hartog → 1937 Wardha → 1944 Sargent.
- Nicknames: Metcalfe = “Liberator of the Indian Press” · VPA = “Gagging Act” · Wood’s Despatch = “Magna Carta of English Education”.
- Commission chairs: Hunter (W.W.), Raleigh (Thomas), Sadler (Michael), Hartog (Philip), Sargent (John).
🎯 Exam traps
- ⚠️ First newspaper: Hicky’s Bengal Gazette (1780).
- ⚠️ Amrita Bazar Patrika became English to dodge the VPA 1878.
- ⚠️ First Indian journalist jailed = Surendranath Banerjea (1883).
- ⚠️ Press Acts of 1908 & 1910 repealed in 1921 on the Sapru committee’s advice.
- ⚠️ Hunter Commission focused on primary/secondary; Raleigh on universities; Hartog was an arm of the Simon Commission.
- ⚠️ Wardha scheme: age 7–14; Sargent: 6–14 compulsory, 40 years to universal literacy.
- ⚠️ Patna University was set up in 1917 (Sadler-era expansion).