Sub-topics: Nationalist response to WWI · Home Rule League Movement (1916) · Lucknow session 1916 — reunion & Lucknow Pact · Montagu’s August Declaration (1917).
1. Nationalist response to the First World War (1914–18/19)2. The Home Rule League Movement (1916–18) ⭐⭐FactorsFormationProgrammeGovernment responseWhy it faded by 1919Positive gains3. Lucknow Session (December 1916) ⭐⭐A. Readmission of the ExtremistsB. The Lucknow Pact — Congress & Muslim League4. Montagu’s August Declaration — 20 August 1917 ⭐🧠 Memory box🎯 Exam traps
1. Nationalist response to the First World War (1914–18/19)
Britain (with France, Russia, USA, Italy, Japan) fought Germany, Austria-Hungary and Turkey. Indian responses were three-fold:
- Moderates — supported the Empire as a duty.
- Extremists incl. Tilak (released June 1914) — supported the war in the mistaken belief that Britain would repay loyalty with self-government.
- Revolutionaries — used the opportunity to wage war on British rule (Ghadr, Berlin Committee, Singapore mutiny — page 11). White troops in India fell to ~15,000; hope of German/Turkish help.
Supporters failed to see that imperial powers were fighting for their colonies and markets.
2. The Home Rule League Movement (1916–18) ⭐⭐
A less dramatic but more effective response than the Ghadr. Leaders (Tilak, Annie Besant, G.S. Khaparde, Sir S. Subramania Iyer, Joseph Baptista, M.A. Jinnah) wanted a year-round national alliance (unlike the Congress’s annual session) demanding self-government / Home Rule within the British Commonwealth, on the model of the Irish Home Rule League.
Factors
- Felt need for popular pressure to win concessions.
- Moderates disillusioned with the Morley-Minto reforms.
- Wartime miseries — high taxes, rising prices — people ready to protest.
- The war between imperialist powers exposed the myth of white superiority.
- Tilak, after release (June 1914), reassured the government of loyalty and the Moderates that he wanted administrative reform, not overthrow; admitted violence had retarded progress; urged help to Britain.
- Annie Besant (Irish theosophist, in India since 1893/96) wanted to build an Irish-style Home Rule movement.
Formation
- Tilak and Besant knew they needed the Moderate-dominated Congress and Extremist cooperation. Failure at the 1914 Congress (Madras) to reunite them.
- Early 1915: Besant campaigned for self-government after the war through her papers New India and Commonweal.
- 1915 Congress (Bombay): decided to readmit the Extremists; did not approve Besant’s league but promised propaganda and revival of local committees; Besant warned she would start her own league if nothing happened (Sept 1916 deadline).
- Two separate leagues to avoid friction, with areas divided and coordination.
ㅤ | Tilak’s Indian Home Rule League | Besant’s All-India Home Rule League |
Founded | April 1916 (first meeting at Belgaum) | September 1916 |
HQ | Poona | Madras (Adyar) |
Area | Maharashtra (excl. Bombay city), Karnataka, Central Provinces, Berar | Rest of India incl. Bombay city |
Branches | 6 | 200 (loosely organised) |
Key people | Tilak, Khaparde, N.C. Kelkar | Organising secretary George Arundale; B.P. Wadia, C.P. Ramaswamy Aiyar |
Demands | Swarajya, linguistic states, education in the vernacular | Self-government |
Programme
- Take the message of Home Rule = self-government to the common man; reached “politically backward” Gujarat and Sindh.
- Methods: public meetings, libraries and reading rooms on national politics, conferences, classes for students, newspapers, pamphlets, posters, illustrated postcards, plays, religious songs, fund collection, social work, local government participation.
- The Russian Revolution (1917) helped the campaign.
- Joined by Motilal and Jawaharlal Nehru, Bhulabhai Desai, C.R. Das, K.M. Munshi, B. Chakravarti, Saifuddin Kitchlew, Madan Mohan Malaviya, M.A. Jinnah (led the Bombay branch), Tej Bahadur Sapru, Lajpat Rai; Moderates and Servants of India members too.
- Did not join: Anglo-Indians, most Muslims, southern non-Brahmins (feared Hindu, high-caste rule).
Government response
- Severe repression, esp. in Madras (students barred from political meetings); case against Tilak (quashed by the High Court); Tilak barred from Punjab and Delhi.
- June 1917: Besant, B.P. Wadia, George Arundale arrested → nationwide protest; Sir S. Subramania Aiyar renounced his knighthood; Tilak advocated passive resistance.
- Montagu: Shiva cut his wife into 52 pieces and found he had 52 wives — that is what happens when the government interns Mrs Besant.
- Besant released September 1917.
Why it faded by 1919
- Lack of effective organisation.
- Communal riots (1917–18).
- Moderates pacified by Montagu’s Declaration (Aug 1917) and Besant’s release.
- Extremists’ talk of passive resistance kept Moderates away (from Sept 1918).
- Montagu-Chelmsford reform proposals (July 1918) divided nationalists; Besant vacillated.
- Tilak went to England (Sept 1918) for his libel case against Valentine Chirol (author of Indian Unrest, who called Tilak “father of Indian unrest”).
- Gandhi’s rise sidelined it.
(1920: Gandhi became president of the All India Home Rule League and renamed it Swarajya Sabha; it merged with the Congress within a year.)
Positive gains
- A transition from the inactive deliberative Congress to the Gandhian mass phase.
- Shifted emphasis from the elite to the masses; deflected the movement permanently from the Moderate path.
- Created an organisational link between town and country.
- Produced a generation of ardent nationalists; prepared masses for Gandhian politics.
- Influenced the August 1917 Declaration and the Montford reforms.
- Helped the Moderate–Extremist reunion at Lucknow (1916).
3. Lucknow Session (December 1916) ⭐⭐
A. Readmission of the Extremists
President: Ambika Charan Majumdar (Moderate). Reasons:
- Old controversies had become meaningless.
- Both realised the split had caused political inactivity.
- Tilak and Besant worked for reunion; Tilak disowned overthrow and violence.
- Death of Pherozeshah Mehta (1915) (and Gokhale), leader of the anti-Extremist Moderates.
A.C. Majumdar: after ten years of painful separation both wings realised “united they stand, divided they fall”.
B. The Lucknow Pact — Congress & Muslim League
Why the League changed:
- Britain refused to help Turkey (the Khalifa) in the Balkan wars (1912–13) and against Italy (1911).
- Annulment of partition (1911) angered pro-partition Muslims.
- Government refused an Aligarh university with powers to affiliate colleges across India.
- Younger members outgrew the Aligarh school; the League’s Calcutta/Lucknow session (1912–13) adopted the goal of self-government suited to India (if Muslim interests were protected).
- Wartime repression — Maulana Azad’s Al Hilal and Mohammad Ali’s Comrade suppressed; Ali brothers, Azad, Hasrat Mohani interned → anti-imperialism among the “Young Party”.
(Architects: Tilak and Jinnah; League session at Lucknow was presided over by Jinnah.)
Terms:
- League agreed to joint constitutional demands with the Congress.
- Congress accepted separate electorates for Muslims (to continue until a community demanded joint electorates) and a fixed proportion of seats (weightage in minority provinces) in central and provincial legislatures.
Joint demands:
- Government should declare it would confer self-government at an early date.
- Expanded central and provincial assemblies with an elected majority and more powers.
- Legislative councils’ term: 5 years.
- Secretary of State’s salary from the British, not Indian, treasury.
- Half the members of the Viceroy’s and Governors’ executive councils to be Indians.
Critique: the executive would not be responsible to the legislature (half elected, but not removable) → likely deadlock; essentially an expanded Morley-Minto scheme. Accepting separate electorates meant Congress and League met as separate political entities — a landmark in the evolution of the two-nation theory; leaders united but masses not. Yet it showed a sincere desire to allay minority fears, created enthusiasm, and pushed the government toward Montagu’s declaration.
4. Montagu’s August Declaration — 20 August 1917 ⭐
Secretary of State Edwin Samuel Montagu in the House of Commons: the policy is “the increasing association of Indians in every branch of administration and the gradual development of self-governing institutions with a view to the progressive realisation of responsible government in India as an integral part of the British Empire.”
Significance:
- Demand for self-government could no longer be called seditious — it was now official policy (contrast Morley 1909, who denied any intention of self-government).
- “Responsible government” implied rulers answerable to elected representatives — but the British wouldn’t hand power to elected Indian majorities, so the idea of dyarchy was to be evolved.
Indian objections: (1) no time frame; (2) the British alone would decide the nature and timing of each advance.
🧠 Memory box
- Home Rule: “Tilak = April, Poona, 6 branches, Belgaum · Besant = September, Madras, 200 branches, Arundale”.
- Besant’s papers: New India (daily) and Commonweal (weekly). Tilak’s: Kesari and Maratha.
- 1916 Lucknow = double union: Moderates + Extremists; Congress + League. President A.C. Majumdar.
- 1917: June Besant arrested → Aug 20 Montagu Declaration → Sept Besant released → Dec Besant first woman Congress President (Calcutta 1917).
🎯 Exam traps
- ⚠️ Tilak’s league came first (April 1916); Besant’s in September 1916.
- ⚠️ Bombay city belonged to Besant’s league area, not Tilak’s.
- ⚠️ The Lucknow Pact accepted separate electorates (a concession by the Congress).
- ⚠️ Montagu’s declaration promised “progressive realisation of responsible government” — without a time frame.
- ⚠️ Subramania Aiyar renounced knighthood in 1917 (Besant’s arrest); Tagore in 1919 (Jallianwala).