Notes · History

12 · WWI, Home Rule Leagues, Lucknow Pact & August Declaration

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

7 min read6 sections

12 · WWI, Home Rule Leagues, Lucknow Pact & August Declaration

📌
Sub-topics: Nationalist response to WWI · Home Rule League Movement (1916) · Lucknow session 1916 — reunion & Lucknow Pact · Montagu’s August Declaration (1917).

1. Nationalist response to the First World War (1914–18/19)

Britain (with France, Russia, USA, Italy, Japan) fought Germany, Austria-Hungary and Turkey. Indian responses were three-fold:
  1. Moderates — supported the Empire as a duty.
  1. Extremists incl. Tilak (released June 1914) — supported the war in the mistaken belief that Britain would repay loyalty with self-government.
  1. Revolutionaries — used the opportunity to wage war on British rule (Ghadr, Berlin Committee, Singapore mutiny — page 11). White troops in India fell to ~15,000; hope of German/Turkish help.
Supporters failed to see that imperial powers were fighting for their colonies and markets.

2. The Home Rule League Movement (1916–18) ⭐⭐

A less dramatic but more effective response than the Ghadr. Leaders (Tilak, Annie Besant, G.S. Khaparde, Sir S. Subramania Iyer, Joseph Baptista, M.A. Jinnah) wanted a year-round national alliance (unlike the Congress’s annual session) demanding self-government / Home Rule within the British Commonwealth, on the model of the Irish Home Rule League.

Factors

  1. Felt need for popular pressure to win concessions.
  1. Moderates disillusioned with the Morley-Minto reforms.
  1. Wartime miseries — high taxes, rising prices — people ready to protest.
  1. The war between imperialist powers exposed the myth of white superiority.
  1. Tilak, after release (June 1914), reassured the government of loyalty and the Moderates that he wanted administrative reform, not overthrow; admitted violence had retarded progress; urged help to Britain.
  1. Annie Besant (Irish theosophist, in India since 1893/96) wanted to build an Irish-style Home Rule movement.

Formation

  • Tilak and Besant knew they needed the Moderate-dominated Congress and Extremist cooperation. Failure at the 1914 Congress (Madras) to reunite them.
  • Early 1915: Besant campaigned for self-government after the war through her papers New India and Commonweal.
  • 1915 Congress (Bombay): decided to readmit the Extremists; did not approve Besant’s league but promised propaganda and revival of local committees; Besant warned she would start her own league if nothing happened (Sept 1916 deadline).
  • Two separate leagues to avoid friction, with areas divided and coordination.
ㅤ
Tilak’s Indian Home Rule League
Besant’s All-India Home Rule League
Founded
April 1916 (first meeting at Belgaum)
September 1916
HQ
Poona
Madras (Adyar)
Area
Maharashtra (excl. Bombay city), Karnataka, Central Provinces, Berar
Rest of India incl. Bombay city
Branches
6
200 (loosely organised)
Key people
Tilak, Khaparde, N.C. Kelkar
Organising secretary George Arundale; B.P. Wadia, C.P. Ramaswamy Aiyar
Demands
Swarajya, linguistic states, education in the vernacular
Self-government

Programme

  • Take the message of Home Rule = self-government to the common man; reached “politically backward” Gujarat and Sindh.
  • Methods: public meetings, libraries and reading rooms on national politics, conferences, classes for students, newspapers, pamphlets, posters, illustrated postcards, plays, religious songs, fund collection, social work, local government participation.
  • The Russian Revolution (1917) helped the campaign.
  • Joined by Motilal and Jawaharlal Nehru, Bhulabhai Desai, C.R. Das, K.M. Munshi, B. Chakravarti, Saifuddin Kitchlew, Madan Mohan Malaviya, M.A. Jinnah (led the Bombay branch), Tej Bahadur Sapru, Lajpat Rai; Moderates and Servants of India members too.
  • Did not join: Anglo-Indians, most Muslims, southern non-Brahmins (feared Hindu, high-caste rule).

Government response

  • Severe repression, esp. in Madras (students barred from political meetings); case against Tilak (quashed by the High Court); Tilak barred from Punjab and Delhi.
  • June 1917: Besant, B.P. Wadia, George Arundale arrested → nationwide protest; Sir S. Subramania Aiyar renounced his knighthood; Tilak advocated passive resistance.
  • Montagu: Shiva cut his wife into 52 pieces and found he had 52 wives — that is what happens when the government interns Mrs Besant.
  • Besant released September 1917.

Why it faded by 1919

  1. Lack of effective organisation.
  1. Communal riots (1917–18).
  1. Moderates pacified by Montagu’s Declaration (Aug 1917) and Besant’s release.
  1. Extremists’ talk of passive resistance kept Moderates away (from Sept 1918).
  1. Montagu-Chelmsford reform proposals (July 1918) divided nationalists; Besant vacillated.
  1. Tilak went to England (Sept 1918) for his libel case against Valentine Chirol (author of Indian Unrest, who called Tilak “father of Indian unrest”).
  1. Gandhi’s rise sidelined it.
(1920: Gandhi became president of the All India Home Rule League and renamed it Swarajya Sabha; it merged with the Congress within a year.)

Positive gains

  • A transition from the inactive deliberative Congress to the Gandhian mass phase.
  • Shifted emphasis from the elite to the masses; deflected the movement permanently from the Moderate path.
  • Created an organisational link between town and country.
  • Produced a generation of ardent nationalists; prepared masses for Gandhian politics.
  • Influenced the August 1917 Declaration and the Montford reforms.
  • Helped the Moderate–Extremist reunion at Lucknow (1916).

3. Lucknow Session (December 1916) ⭐⭐

A. Readmission of the Extremists

President: Ambika Charan Majumdar (Moderate). Reasons:
  1. Old controversies had become meaningless.
  1. Both realised the split had caused political inactivity.
  1. Tilak and Besant worked for reunion; Tilak disowned overthrow and violence.
  1. Death of Pherozeshah Mehta (1915) (and Gokhale), leader of the anti-Extremist Moderates.
A.C. Majumdar: after ten years of painful separation both wings realised “united they stand, divided they fall”.

B. The Lucknow Pact — Congress & Muslim League

Why the League changed:
  1. Britain refused to help Turkey (the Khalifa) in the Balkan wars (1912–13) and against Italy (1911).
  1. Annulment of partition (1911) angered pro-partition Muslims.
  1. Government refused an Aligarh university with powers to affiliate colleges across India.
  1. Younger members outgrew the Aligarh school; the League’s Calcutta/Lucknow session (1912–13) adopted the goal of self-government suited to India (if Muslim interests were protected).
  1. Wartime repression — Maulana Azad’s Al Hilal and Mohammad Ali’s Comrade suppressed; Ali brothers, Azad, Hasrat Mohani interned → anti-imperialism among the “Young Party”.
(Architects: Tilak and Jinnah; League session at Lucknow was presided over by Jinnah.)
Terms:
  • League agreed to joint constitutional demands with the Congress.
  • Congress accepted separate electorates for Muslims (to continue until a community demanded joint electorates) and a fixed proportion of seats (weightage in minority provinces) in central and provincial legislatures.
Joint demands:
  1. Government should declare it would confer self-government at an early date.
  1. Expanded central and provincial assemblies with an elected majority and more powers.
  1. Legislative councils’ term: 5 years.
  1. Secretary of State’s salary from the British, not Indian, treasury.
  1. Half the members of the Viceroy’s and Governors’ executive councils to be Indians.
Critique: the executive would not be responsible to the legislature (half elected, but not removable) → likely deadlock; essentially an expanded Morley-Minto scheme. Accepting separate electorates meant Congress and League met as separate political entities — a landmark in the evolution of the two-nation theory; leaders united but masses not. Yet it showed a sincere desire to allay minority fears, created enthusiasm, and pushed the government toward Montagu’s declaration.

4. Montagu’s August Declaration — 20 August 1917 ⭐

Secretary of State Edwin Samuel Montagu in the House of Commons: the policy is “the increasing association of Indians in every branch of administration and the gradual development of self-governing institutions with a view to the progressive realisation of responsible government in India as an integral part of the British Empire.”
Significance:
  • Demand for self-government could no longer be called seditious — it was now official policy (contrast Morley 1909, who denied any intention of self-government).
  • “Responsible government” implied rulers answerable to elected representatives — but the British wouldn’t hand power to elected Indian majorities, so the idea of dyarchy was to be evolved.
Indian objections: (1) no time frame; (2) the British alone would decide the nature and timing of each advance.

🧠 Memory box

  • Home Rule: “Tilak = April, Poona, 6 branches, Belgaum · Besant = September, Madras, 200 branches, Arundale”.
  • Besant’s papers: New India (daily) and Commonweal (weekly). Tilak’s: Kesari and Maratha.
  • 1916 Lucknow = double union: Moderates + Extremists; Congress + League. President A.C. Majumdar.
  • 1917: June Besant arrested → Aug 20 Montagu Declaration → Sept Besant released → Dec Besant first woman Congress President (Calcutta 1917).

🎯 Exam traps

  • ⚠️ Tilak’s league came first (April 1916); Besant’s in September 1916.
  • ⚠️ Bombay city belonged to Besant’s league area, not Tilak’s.
  • ⚠️ The Lucknow Pact accepted separate electorates (a concession by the Congress).
  • ⚠️ Montagu’s declaration promised “progressive realisation of responsible government” — without a time frame.
  • ⚠️ Subramania Aiyar renounced knighthood in 1917 (Besant’s arrest); Tagore in 1919 (Jallianwala).