Notes · History

17 · Civil Disobedience, Round Table Conferences & Poona Pact

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

12 min read11 sections

17 · Civil Disobedience, Round Table Conferences & Poona Pact

📌
Sub-topics: Run-up (Calcutta 1928, Irwin Declaration, Delhi Manifesto) · Lahore 1929 Purna Swaraj · 11 demands · Dandi March · CDM across regions · Gandhi-Irwin Pact · Karachi 1931 · 3 RTCs · CDM phase 2 · Communal Award · Poona Pact · Harijan campaign.

1. Run-up to Civil Disobedience

Calcutta session (Dec 1928)

  • Approved the Nehru Report; young leaders (Nehru, Subhas Bose, Satyamurthy) wanted Purna Swaraj. Gandhi and Motilal suggested 2 years’ grace; reduced to one year under pressure: if dominion status wasn’t accepted by end-1929, Congress would demand complete independence and launch civil disobedience.

1929

  • Gandhi toured, preparing people; CWC’s Foreign Cloth Boycott Committee; Gandhi began bonfires in Calcutta (March 1929) and was arrested.
  • Meerut Conspiracy Case (March); Assembly bomb (April); Labour government of Ramsay MacDonald (May) with Wedgwood Benn as Secretary of State.
  • Irwin’s Declaration — 31 October 1929: “the natural issue of India’s constitutional progress… is the attainment of Dominion Status”; promised a Round Table Conference after the Simon Report. No time frame — nothing new.
  • Delhi Manifesto — 2 November 1929 (conference of national leaders) set conditions for attending the RTC: (1) RTC should frame a constitution for dominion status (act as a constituent assembly) and the principle be accepted immediately; (2) Congress majority at the RTC; (3) general amnesty and conciliation.
  • Dec 1929: Gandhi, Motilal and others met Irwin (just after a bomb attempt on his train) — Irwin rejected the demands.

Lahore session (Dec 1929) — Purna Swaraj ⭐⭐

  • President Jawaharlal Nehru (chosen with Gandhi’s backing though 15 of 18 PCCs opposed) — to mark the independence goal and honour the youth upsurge.
  • Nehru: “We have now an open conspiracy to free this country…”; “I am a socialist and a republican…”
  • Decisions:
      1. Boycott the RTC;
      1. Complete independence (Purna Swaraj) the goal;
      1. CWC authorised to launch civil disobedience incl. non-payment of taxes; legislators to resign;
      1. 26 January 1930 fixed as the first Independence (Swarajya) Day.
  • Midnight, 31 December 1929: Nehru hoisted the new tricolour on the banks of the Ravi, amid “Inquilab Zindabad”.

Independence Pledge — 26 January 1930 (drafted by Gandhi)

Inalienable right to freedom; British rule has ruined India economically (high revenue, destroyed village industries, manipulated customs, currency and exchange), politically (no real power, no free association), culturally (education tore us from our roots), spiritually (compulsory disarmament made us unmanly); submission is a crime against man and God; prepare by withdrawing cooperation and through non-payment of taxes.

2. Gandhi’s Eleven Demands (ultimatum: 31 January 1930) ⭐

Type
Demands
General interest
1. Cut army and civil service expenditure by 50% · 2. Total prohibition · 3. Reform the CID · 4. Change the Arms Act (popular control of licences) · 5. Release political prisoners · 6. Accept the Postal Reservation Bill
Bourgeois (business)
7. Rupee–sterling ratio to 1s 4d · 8. Textile protection · 9. Reserve coastal shipping for Indians
Peasant
10. Cut land revenue by 50% · 11. Abolish salt tax and government salt monopoly
No response → CWC gave Gandhi full powers; by end-February he chose salt.

Why salt?

  • Gandhi: apart from water, nothing by taxing which the government reaches the starving millions — “the most inhuman poll tax”.
  • Linked swaraj with a concrete, universal grievance of the rural poor, with no socially divisive implication (unlike a no-rent campaign).
  • Small but psychologically important income through self-help (like khadi); let townspeople identify symbolically with mass suffering.

3. Dandi March — 12 March to 6 April 1930 ⭐⭐⭐

  • 2 March 1930: Gandhi wrote to Irwin about his plan.
  • 12 March: left Sabarmati Ashram with 78 ashram members; ~240 miles (385 km) through Gujarat villages.
  • 6 April 1930: broke the salt law by picking up salt at Dandi — symbol of refusing to live under British laws.
  • Instructions: break salt law everywhere; picket liquor and foreign cloth shops; refuse taxes if strong enough; lawyers quit practice; boycott courts; officials resign; strict truth and non-violence; obey local leaders after Gandhi’s arrest.
  • ~300 village officials in Gujarat resigned.
  • Nehru arrested (April 1930) → demonstrations in Madras, Calcutta, Karachi.
  • Gandhi arrested 4 May 1930 (before leading a raid on Dharasana Salt Works) → protests in Bombay, Delhi, Calcutta and fiercest in Sholapur.
  • After his arrest the CWC sanctioned: no-revenue in ryotwari areas; no-chowkidari-tax in zamindari areas; forest law violation in the Central Provinces.

4. CDM in different regions ⭐⭐

Region
Leaders / events
Tamil Nadu
C. Rajagopalachari — Trichinopoly → Vedaranyam salt march (April 1930); picketing; anti-liquor; police broke the Choolai Mills strike; weavers attacked liquor shops at Gudiyattam; peasant riots at Bodinayakanur
Malabar
K. Kelappan (of Vaikom fame) — salt marches; P. Krishna Pillai defended the flag on Calicut beach (Nov 1930)
Andhra
District marches (Godavari, Krishna, Guntur); sibirams (military-style camps) as HQs; Kamma and Raju cultivators; less mass support than 1921
Orissa
Gopabandhu Choudhuri — coastal Balasore, Cuttack, Puri
Assam
Weak (Assamese–Bengali, Hindu–Muslim tensions); student strike against the Cunningham Circular (May 1930); Chandraprabha Saikiani urged Kacharis to break forest laws
Bengal
Factions (Subhas Bose vs J.M. Sengupta); communal riots (Dacca, Kishoreganj); yet largest number of arrests and most violence; Midnapore, Arambagh (salt, chowkidari tax); Chittagong raid
Bihar 🟣
Champaran and Saran first to start salt satyagraha; salt-making mostly symbolic (land-locked); Nakhas Pond, Patna under Ambika Kant Sinha; soon replaced by a powerful no-chowkidari-tax agitation; foreign cloth and liquor sales fell by Nov 1930; administration collapsed in parts like Barhee (Munger). Chotanagpur: Bonga Majhi and Somra Majhi (Hazaribagh) — Gandhian, Sanskritising reform; small landlords and better-off tenants joined; big zamindars loyal
Peshawar / NWFP
Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan (“Badshah Khan”, “Frontier Gandhi”) — Pashto monthly Pakhtoon; volunteers Khudai Khidmatgars (“Red Shirts”), non-violent. Arrests on 23 April 1930 → Peshawar in crowd control for a week; martial law; soldiers of the Garhwal Rifles (under Chandra Singh Garhwali) refused to fire on unarmed crowds. 92% Muslim province — alarmed the British
Sholapur
Fiercest response to Gandhi’s arrest: textile strike from 7 May; burnt liquor shops, railway and police stations, courts; a virtual parallel government till martial law (after 16 May)
Dharasana
21 May 1930: Sarojini Naidu, Imam Sahib, Manilal Gandhi led a non-violent raid; brutal lathi charge (2 dead, 320 injured), reported by US journalist Webb Miller. Copied at Wadala (Bombay), Sanikatta (Karnataka), Andhra, Midnapore, Balasore, Puri, Cuttack
Gujarat
No-tax campaign in Anand, Borsad, Nadiad (Kheda), Bardoli (Surat), Jambusar (Bharuch); villagers migrated to Baroda state territory for months
Maharashtra, Karnataka, CP
Forest law defiance (grazing, timber)
United Provinces
No-revenue (zamindars) turned into no-rent (tenants) campaign; peak Oct 1930 in Agra, Rae Bareli
Manipur & Nagaland
Rani Gaidinliu (aged 13), follower of cousin Haipou Jadonang (hanged 1931): “We are free people, the white men should not rule over us”; captured Oct 1932, life sentence; freed in 1946/47 by the Interim Government (Nehru called her “Rani”)
Forms of mobilisation: prabhat pheris, vanar senas (children), manjari senas (girls), secret patrikas, magic-lantern shows.
Impact: foreign cloth imports fell; loss of liquor, excise and land revenue; Assembly elections largely boycotted.

Participation

  • Women — the most liberating experience; true entry into public life (picketing liquor, opium, cloth shops).
  • Students and youth — prominent in boycotts.
  • Muslims — far below 1920–22 (League appeals, government encouragement of communalism), but overwhelming in NWFP; significant in parts of Bengal; Muslim weavers in Bihar 🟣, Delhi, Lucknow.
  • Merchants and petty traders — very enthusiastic (Tamil Nadu, Punjab).
  • Tribals — CP, Maharashtra, Karnataka. Workers — Bombay, Calcutta, Madras, Sholapur. Peasants — UP, Bihar, Gujarat.

Government response

  • Dilemma: “damned if you do, damned if you don’t”; vacillation, then ordinances, gagging of press, bans; CWC declared illegal only in June 1930; lathi charges and firings; ~90,000 jailed.
  • Simon Report (May 1930) with no mention of dominion status upset even moderates.
  • July 1930: Irwin proposed an RTC; Tej Bahadur Sapru and M.R. Jayakar allowed to mediate. Aug 1930: Motilal and Jawaharlal met Gandhi in Yerawada Jail — demanded right of secession, national government controlling defence and finance, tribunal on British financial claims. Talks broke down.

5. Gandhi-Irwin Pact (Delhi Pact) — 5 March 1931 ⭐⭐

  • 25 Jan 1931: Gandhi and CWC released unconditionally. The pact placed the Congress on an equal footing with the government.
Irwin agreed to:
  1. Release of political prisoners not convicted of violence;
  1. Remission of uncollected fines;
  1. Return of confiscated lands not yet sold to third parties;
  1. Lenient treatment of officials who had resigned;
  1. Right to make salt in coastal villages for personal use (not sale);
  1. Right to peaceful picketing;
  1. Withdrawal of emergency ordinances.
Irwin refused: (1) public inquiry into police excesses; (2) commutation of Bhagat Singh and comrades’ death sentences.
Gandhi agreed: (1) suspend CDM; (2) attend the next RTC on the basis of federation, Indian responsibility, and reservations and safeguards (defence, external affairs, minorities, financial credit).

Was it a retreat?

No — mass movements are short-lived; masses’ capacity for sacrifice is limited; exhaustion visible after Sept 1930 (esp. shopkeepers, merchants). Youth disappointed; Gujarat peasants upset (lands returned only under the 1937 Congress ministry). But many rejoiced that the government had to treat Gandhi as an equal; released prisoners got heroes’ welcomes.

CDM vs NCM

CDM (1930–34)
NCM (1920–22)
Goal: complete independence
Remedy Punjab & Khilafat wrongs; vague swaraj
Violation of law from the start
Non-cooperation with foreign rule
Fewer intelligentsia protests (lawyers, students)
Many lawyers/students quit
Muslim participation much lower
Massive Muslim participation
No major labour upsurge
Labour unrest
Massive peasant and business participation
—
~3 times more arrests; Congress organisationally stronger
—
💬
Brailsford: Dandi was the “kindergarten stage of revolution”. Ellen Wilkinson: “Gandhi was the best policeman the British had in India.” Sarojini Naidu at Dharasana: Gandhi’s body is in jail but his soul is with you.

6. Karachi Session — March 1931 ⭐⭐

  • Special session (president Vallabhbhai Patel) held 29 March 1931, six days after Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev, Rajguru were hanged (23 March); Gandhi met black flags from the Naujawan Bharat Sabha.
  • Resolutions: disapproved political violence but admired the martyrs’ bravery; endorsed the Gandhi-Irwin Pact; reiterated Purna Swaraj.
  • Resolution on Fundamental Rights (drafted by Nehru): free speech and press; association; assembly; universal adult franchise; equal rights regardless of caste, creed, sex; religious neutrality of the state; free and compulsory primary education; protection of minority cultures, languages, scripts.
  • Resolution on National Economic Programme: big cuts in rent and revenue; exemption for uneconomic holdings; relief from rural debt; control of usury; living wage, limited hours, protection of women workers; right of workers and peasants to form unions; state ownership/control of key industries, mines, transport.
  • First time Congress spelt out what swaraj means for the masses — “political freedom must include economic freedom of the starving millions”. Remained Congress’s basic programme.

7. The Round Table Conferences ⭐⭐

ㅤ
First RTC
Second RTC
Third RTC
Dates
12 Nov 1930 – 19 Jan 1931 (opened by King George V; chaired by Ramsay MacDonald)
7 Sept – 1 Dec 1931
17 Nov – 24 Dec 1932
Viceroy
Irwin
Willingdon
Willingdon
British govt
Labour (MacDonald)
National Government (Conservative-dominated, MacDonald PM; Secretary of State Samuel Hoare)
National Government
Congress
Boycotted (CDM on)
Gandhi sole representative (with Sarojini Naidu, Malaviya, Rangaswami Iyengar present)
Absent
Others
Princes (Alwar, Baroda, Bhopal, Bikaner, Patiala — Chancellor of Chamber of Princes, etc.); League (Aga Khan III led British-Indian delegation, Mohammad Ali Jauhar, Shafi, Jinnah, Fazlul Huq…); Hindu Mahasabha (Moonje, Jayakar); Sikhs; Parsis; women; Liberals (Sapru, Sastri, Chintamani); Ambedkar; Justice Party; Labour (N.M. Joshi); Christians, Anglo-Indians, Europeans; landlords from Bihar, UP, Orissa
Similar + Muhammad Iqbal, G.D. Birla, Purshottamdas Thakurdas, V.V. Giri, Sarojini Naidu
Few: Aga Khan, Ambedkar, Iqbal, Jayakar, Sapru, Hydari etc.
Outcome
Agreement that India would be a federation; safeguards on defence and finance; realisation that Congress participation was essential
Deadlock on minorities (Muslims, depressed classes, Christians, Anglo-Indians formed a “Minorities’ Pact”); princes cool on federation. MacDonald announced: two Muslim-majority provinces — NWFP and Sindh; an Indian Consultative Committee; three expert committees (finance, franchise, states); threat of a unilateral Communal Award. Gandhi returned 28 Dec 1931 empty-handed
White Paper (March 1933) → Joint Select Committee (Linlithgow) → draft Bill Feb 1935 → GoI Act 1935 (passed Aug 1935)
Why little was expected from the 2nd RTC: Irwin replaced by Willingdon; Conservative-dominated government; Churchill and the right wing objected to negotiating with Congress as an equal; British angered by revolutionary killings; loyalist and communal delegates used to neutralise Gandhi’s claim that Congress alone represented India. Gandhi demanded immediate responsible government at centre and provinces; said untouchables are Hindus, not a minority; no separate electorates or special safeguards needed.

8. CDM — second phase (1932–34)

  • Truce period (Mar–Dec 1931): UP rent agitation; repression of Khudai Khidmatgars in NWFP; Bengal ordinances; Hijli jail firing (Sept 1931).
  • British resolved: no chance for Gandhi to build momentum; win loyalists not Congress; stop rural consolidation.
  • 29 Dec 1931 CWC resumed CDM; Willingdon refused to meet Gandhi (31 Dec); Gandhi arrested 4 January 1932.
  • “Civil Martial Law”: Congress banned at all levels; arrests; confiscations; ashrams occupied; harsh on women; press gagged.
  • Response: ~80,000 jailed in four months; picketing, flag hoisting, no-chowkidari tax, salt, forest satyagraha, a secret radio transmitter near Bombay; upsurges in Kashmir and Alwar.
  • Could not be sustained (no time to build tempo; masses unprepared). Withdrawn April 1934 (officially May 1934). People “had won freedom in their hearts”.

9. Communal Award (16 August 1932) ⭐⭐

  • Announced by PM Ramsay MacDonald on the basis of the Indian Franchise (Lothian) Committee, after Indian delegates failed to agree on minorities.
  • Provisions:
    • Separate electorates for Muslims, Europeans, Sikhs, Indian Christians, Anglo-Indians, depressed classes, women, and even Marathas (7 seats in Bombay); for depressed classes for 20 years.
    • Provincial seats distributed on a communal basis; existing seats doubled.
    • Weightage for Muslims where in minority.
    • 3% seats for women in all provinces except NWFP.
    • Depressed classes recognised as a minority, with a double vote (one in separate, one in general electorate); ~78 reserved seats.
    • Seats for labour, landlords, traders, industrialists.
  • Congress: opposed separate electorates but would not change the Award without minorities’ consent — “neither accept nor reject”. All nationalists opposed separating depressed classes from Hindus.
  • Background: Ambedkar had demanded separate electorates (Simon Commission, 2nd RTC); Gandhi rejected Ambedkar’s compromise, called himself the representative of the oppressed.

Gandhi’s fast and the Poona Pact (24 September 1932) ⭐⭐

  • Gandhi saw separate electorates for depressed classes as an attack on unity; it would perpetuate untouchability rather than eradicate it. He wanted joint electorate (ideally universal franchise), with no objection to more reserved seats.
  • Began a fast unto death on 20 September 1932 in Yerawada Jail.
  • Negotiators: B.R. Ambedkar, M.C. Rajah, Madan Mohan Malaviya (also Rajendra Prasad, Rajagopalachari).
  • Poona Pact signed by Ambedkar on 24 Sept 1932: separate electorate abandoned; reserved seats for depressed classes in provincial legislatures raised from 71 to 147; 18% of general seats in the Central Legislature. Accepted by the government as an amendment to the Award.
Critique (Dalit perspective): made depressed classes tools of caste-Hindu parties; genuine leaders lost to “stooges” backed by caste Hindus; subordinated them within the Hindu order. The Scheduled Castes Federation later demanded restoration of separate electorates; Ambedkar denounced the pact till 1947.

Gandhi’s Harijan campaign (1932–34)

  • In jail: All India Anti-Untouchability League (Sept 1932) → renamed Harijan Sevak Sangh; weekly Harijan (Jan 1933).
  • Released Aug 1933; moved to Wardha (vowed not to return to Sabarmati until swaraj).
  • Harijan tour (Nov 1933 – July 1934) — 20,000 km; fasts on 8 May and 16 Aug 1934.
  • Opposed by orthodox Hindus (sanatanis); government helped them by defeating the Temple Entry Bill (Aug 1934).
  • Themes: indictment of Hindu society; temples open to untouchables; caste Hindus must do penance; “Hinduism dies if untouchability lives”; Shastras don’t sanction it.
  • Did not mix the campaign with inter-dining/inter-caste marriage; distinguished abolishing untouchability from abolishing caste (unlike Ambedkar, who wanted annihilation of caste). Internal reform among Harijans too (education, hygiene, no beef/carrion/liquor).
  • Effect: carried nationalism to Harijans (mostly agricultural labourers).

Gandhi vs Ambedkar (key contrasts)

  • Symbolic parallels: burning foreign cloth ↔ burning Manusmriti; salt at Dandi ↔ water at Mahad.
  • Gandhi: freedom must be wrested; Ambedkar expected it to be bestowed.
  • Ambedkar favoured parliamentary democracy and institutions; Gandhi distrusted parliamentarism.
  • Ambedkar rigid in principles (liberal); Gandhi flexible except on non-violence.
  • Ambedkar highlighted India’s disunity; Gandhi its unity (Hind Swaraj — India a nation before British rule).

🧠 Memory box

  • 1929–31 chain: 31 Oct Irwin Declaration → 2 Nov Delhi Manifesto → Dec Lahore (Nehru) → 31 Dec flag on Ravi → 26 Jan 1930 Independence Day → 31 Jan 11 demands deadline → 2 Mar letter → 12 Mar–6 Apr Dandi → 23 Apr Peshawar → 4 May Gandhi arrested → 21 May Dharasana → Nov 1st RTC → 5 Mar 1931 Pact → 23 Mar executions → 29 Mar Karachi → Sept 2nd RTC → 4 Jan 1932 arrest → 16 Aug Award → 20 Sept fast → 24 Sept Poona Pact → Nov 3rd RTC → Apr 1934 CDM withdrawn.
  • RTC Congress presence: 0 – 1 (Gandhi) – 0.
  • 11 demands split: 6 general + 3 bourgeois + 2 peasant.
  • Poona Pact numbers: 71 → 147 provincial seats; 18% central.

🎯 Exam traps

  • ⚠️ Dandi March: 78 followers, 12 March–6 April 1930, ~240 miles, from Sabarmati.
  • ⚠️ Dharasana raid led by Sarojini Naidu (after Gandhi’s arrest), with Imam Sahib and Manilal.
  • ⚠️ Vedaranyam march = Rajagopalachari; Calicut/Payyanur = Kelappan.
  • ⚠️ Gandhi-Irwin Pact did not secure commutation for Bhagat Singh.
  • ⚠️ Karachi 1931 president = Vallabhbhai Patel; Fundamental Rights + Economic Programme.
  • ⚠️ In Bihar CDM, salt satyagraha gave way to no-chowkidari tax; first districts Champaran & Saran.
  • ⚠️ Communal Award (Aug 1932) was by Ramsay MacDonald; Poona Pact signed by Ambedkar (and Malaviya for caste Hindus).