Notes · History

24 · British Policies, Land Revenue Systems & Economic Impact

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

14 min read10 sections

24 · British Policies, Land Revenue Systems & Economic Impact

📌
Sub-topics: Administrative & social policies · Labour laws · Land revenue systems (Izaradari, Permanent Settlement, Ryotwari, Mahalwari) · Policy towards princes · Economic impact · Drain theory · Stages of colonialism.

1. Administrative policies after 1857

The pre-1857 aim of modernising India gave way to reactionary policies, on the plea that Indians were unfit to govern themselves.
  • Divide and rule — princes vs people, region vs region, caste vs caste, Hindus vs Muslims. After initial repression of Muslims (post-1857), from 1870 educated upper/middle-class Muslims were used against nationalism through competition for scarce jobs and education.
  • Hostility to educated Indians — from 1885 the government opposed those demanding participation.
  • Alliance with zamindars and princes — hailed as “natural leaders”; Awadh taluqdars got lands back; protected against peasants.
  • Withdrawal from social reform — sided with orthodoxy; encouraged caste and communal consciousness.
  • Neglect of social services — huge spending on army, administration and wars; little on education, health, sanitation, infrastructure; what existed served elites and towns.
  • Restrictions on the press — Metcalfe freed the press (1835); Lytton’s Vernacular Press Act (1878), repealed by Ripon (1882); renewed curbs 1908, 1910 (see page 25).
  • White racism — exclusion from higher services, railway compartments, parks, hotels, clubs; beatings and murders passed off as accidents. Elgin: “we could only govern by maintaining the fact that we were the dominant race”. Charles Wood: where one race rules another, the mildest form of government is despotism. Anil Seal: nomination, representation, election were all means of enlisting Indians for imperial ends.

Labour legislation

  • Miserable factory and plantation conditions. Ironically, the first demand for factory regulation came from Lancashire textile capitalists (fearing cheap Indian competition) → first commission 1875.
  • Indian Factory Act 1881 (Ripon): child labour (7–12 years) — no employment under 7; max 9 hours for children; 4 holidays a month; fencing of dangerous machinery.
  • Indian Factory Act 1891 (Lansdowne): child age limits raised to 9–14; children’s hours 7; women max 11 hours with 1½-hour break; weekly holiday for all; men’s hours unregulated.
  • Not applied to British-owned tea and coffee plantations; penal contract laws made breach of contract a criminal offence (planters could arrest labourers). More laws in the 20th century under nationalist pressure.

2. Land revenue systems ⭐⭐⭐

The aim was to extract maximum revenue with little care for cultivators.

A. Hastings’ Izaradari (farming) system

  • After the 1769–70 Bengal famine, Warren Hastings auctioned the right to collect revenue to the highest bidders (revenue “farmers”) — quinquennial (5-year) settlement (1772), made annual in 1777.
  • Results: extortion; bids far above capacity; hereditary zamindars (treated as mere tax-gatherers) ousted; corruption; impoverishment; expected surplus never came.

B. Permanent Settlement (Zamindari) — 1793 ⭐

  • Philip Francis proposed it in 1776; Cornwallis (a British landed aristocrat) sent with instructions; committee of Cornwallis, Sir John Shore, James Grant.
  • Logic: zamindars as owners would improve land like English landlords; easier to collect from a few zamindars.
  • Area: ~19% of British India — Bengal, Bihar 🟣, extended to Orissa, Banaras, northern Madras.
  • Features:
    • Zamindars given proprietary rights.
    • Decennial (10-year) settlement 1790, made permanent 1793.
    • Fixed revenue paid by zamindars; ryots became tenants.
    • Zamindar kept 1/10 to 1/11 of the revenue; the rest (10/11) to the Company.
    • Land saleable, mortgageable, heritable; “Sunset Law” (1794) — if not paid by sunset of a fixed date, zamindari auctioned.
    • Regulations of 1793, 1799 (Haftam), 1812 let zamindars seize tenants’ property for unpaid rent without court sanction.
  • Shortcomings: revenue fixed very high → many zamindaris sold → absentee landlordism (merchants, officials bought them; by 1815 half of Bengal’s land changed hands); sub-infeudation — patni taluqs leased permanently to patnidars; pattas (written agreements) never issued → peasants at zamindars’ mercy and in moneylenders’ grip — serfdom; zamindars didn’t invest; government couldn’t raise revenue later.

C. Ryotwari System ⭐

  • Devised by Thomas Munro and Captain Alexander Read in Baramahal (1792); introduced by Munro as Governor of Madras (1820). Chosen because, with no intermediaries, it yielded the most revenue.
  • Tax ~⅓ of gross produce (≈ the whole economic rent), demanded regardless of yield or prices; arbitrary “putcut” assessments without surveys; coercion and torture → debt.
  • Madras Torture Commission Report (1855) exposed coercion and corruption → scientific survey; revenue at half of net value, 30-year settlement (reformed system 1864); prosperity interrupted by famines (1865–66, 1876–78).
  • Bombay: direct collection from 1813–14 (Gujarat); after 1818, ryotwari on the Madras pattern under Elphinstone (Governor 1819–27, Munro’s disciple); survey 1824–28 — demand 55% of net produce; faulty surveys, over-assessment, fields deserted. Wingate and Goldsmid (c. 1836) improved it — assessment by soil and location; covered most of the Deccan by 1865.
  • Extended to Berar, East Bengal, parts of Assam, Coorg; ~51% of British India.
  • Influenced by Utilitarian ideas and David Ricardo’s theory of rent.
  • Features: ryot owner/occupant, could sublet, transfer, sell; paid directly to government; 45–55% of estimated produce; not fixed — revised periodically; forced to cultivate; confiscation on default.
  • Shortcomings: over-assessment; inflexible, torture; corruption; non-cultivating landlords registered as owners (cultivators reduced to tenants/bonded labour); land lost value.

D. Mahalwari System ⭐

  • Proposed 1819 by Holt Mackenzie; formalised by Regulation VII of 1822; broke down (complex surveys, high demand, harsh collection, depression of 1828).
  • Regulation IX of 1833 (Bentinck) simplified assessment; Robert Merttins Bird — “Father of Land Settlements in Northern India” — supervised; state share 66% of rental value, 30-year settlement; Dalhousie (1855) cut it to 50% (Saharanpur Rules).
  • A “modified zamindari”: the village headman (lambardar) linked cultivators and government but lacked zamindar’s rights. Names: “mauzawar” (NWP), “malguzari” (CP). Dual: settlement with the community and with individual landlords.
  • Area: ~30% — NWP (UP), Central Provinces, Punjab.
  • Features: mahal (village or group of villages) as the unit; revenue on mahal produce; village community owner, individual rights for cultivators; headman collected; periodic revision; average rents by soil class.
  • Shortcomings: recording every right practically impossible; guesswork and manipulation; ruined village communities; land passed to moneylenders and merchants; dispossession → fed the 1857 revolt; collection cost exceeded revenue (from Company’s view).
System
Year
Architect
Areas
Share of British India
Pays to govt
Izaradari
1772
Warren Hastings
Bengal
—
Revenue farmers
Permanent / Zamindari
1793
Cornwallis (Shore, Grant)
Bengal, Bihar, Orissa, Banaras, N. Madras
~19%
Zamindar
Ryotwari
1820
Munro & Read; Elphinstone (Bombay)
Madras, Bombay, Berar, Assam, Coorg, E. Bengal
~51%
Ryot
Mahalwari
1822 / 1833
Holt Mackenzie; R.M. Bird, James Thomason
NWP, CP, Punjab
~30%
Village headman/community

Overall impact of land systems

  • All disastrous — too high revenue; defaults and seizures; lifelong peasant debt.
  • New private property in land benefited not cultivators but moneylenders and middlemen; land became saleable, mortgageable, alienable (to protect revenue).
  • Village split into landowners vs landless; village stability broken; artisans became landless labourers.
  • Courts, lawyers and formal procedure replaced custom.
  • Absentee landlordism; subletting; forced commercialisation of agriculture.

3. Social and cultural policy

  • Till 1813: non-interference. After 1813, change because of the Industrial Revolution (India as a market needing partial modernisation), the intellectual revolution and the French Revolution. New thought — Bacon, Locke, Voltaire, Rousseau, Kant, Adam Smith, Bentham; Wordsworth, Byron, Shelley, Dickens — marked by rationalism, humanism, doctrine of progress.
  • Three schools among administrators:
    • Conservatives — minimal, cautious change; respected Indian culture: Warren Hastings, Edmund Burke; later Munro, Metcalfe, Elphinstone.
    • Paternalistic imperialists (after 1800) — harsh critics of Indian culture, justified subjugation.
    • Radicals (after 1820) — humanist and rational; India can improve; introduce Western science and literature; backed by Rammohan Roy.
  • Overall: “colonial modernisation” — partial, within limits set by exploitation.
  • Christian missionaries supported Radicals (to undermine native beliefs), imperialists (order needed), and capitalists (converts as customers).
  • After 1858 even hesitant modernisation was abandoned; Britain sided with orthodox elements, encouraged caste and communalism.

4. Policy towards princely states

  • Two aims: keep them as bulwarks of the empire and subordinate them completely — “subordinate union”.
  • After 1857: annexation abandoned (“depose or punish but not annex”); territorial integrity guaranteed; right to adopt heirs respected.
  • 1876 (Royal Titles Act): Queen became Kaiser-i-Hind (Empress of India, proclaimed at the Delhi Durbar 1877) — ending the fiction of equality. Curzon: princes rule as agents of the Crown. Paramountcy allowed interference via Residents and control of ministers.
  • Modern communications aided interference; British suppressed democratic movements in states but helped modern administration. F.G. Hutchins: “The British and the princes needed one another; India’s need for either was highly doubtful.”

5. Foreign policy

Aims: protect the Indian empire; expand British commerce; keep rival European powers (Russia, France) away. Led to conflicts beyond natural frontiers (see page 04). “While the interests served were British, the money spent and the blood shed was Indian.”

6. Economic impact of British rule ⭐⭐

Unlike earlier invaders, the British restructured India’s economy into a colonial economy serving Britain and drained wealth as tribute.

A. Deindustrialisation — ruin of artisans

  • One-way free trade after the Charter Act 1813: cheap machine-made British goods flooded India; Indian textiles faced ~80% tariffs in Britain; after 1820 European markets virtually closed. Railways carried British goods to remote areas. India turned from net exporter to net importer.
  • No modern industrialisation to absorb displaced artisans; loss of princely patrons.
  • Ruralisation — cities declined; artisans moved to farming → pressure on land.
  • Bentinck: “the bones of the cotton-weavers are bleaching the plains of India”. D.H. Buchanan: the self-sufficient village’s armour was pierced by the steel rail. Tharoor: India’s share of world manufacturing exports fell from 27% to 2%.

B. Impoverishment of peasantry

Transferable land → insecurity; no investment in productivity; zamindars’ evictions, illegal dues, begar; moneylender-cum-grain-merchant forced cheap sales and manipulated courts — the peasant bore the triple burden of government, zamindar and moneylender; became landless.

C. Intermediaries and absentee landlords

By 1815 half of Bengal’s land in new hands; land-grabbing and sub-infeudation; new zamindars loyal to the British and opposed to nationalism.

D. Stagnation of agriculture

No means or incentive to invest; fragmentation; little government spending on agriculture or education → low productivity.

E. Famine and poverty

Famines were products of poverty, not just scarcity — ~2.8 crore died in famines between 1850 and 1900.

F. Commercialisation of agriculture

  • Late 19th c.: cotton, jute, groundnut, oilseeds, sugarcane, tobacco, spices, fruits; plantations (tea, coffee, rubber, indigo) mostly European-owned.
  • Drivers: money economy, contract replacing custom, unified market, railways and roads, British finance capital.
  • For peasants a forced process (no surplus to invest); exposed to world price swings — the American Civil War cotton boom (1860s) benefited intermediaries; the 1866 slump brought debt, famine, and the Deccan riots (1875).

G. Destruction of industry and late modern industry

  • Textiles paid for out of Bengal revenue at low rates.
  • Ship-building crushed (Surat, Malabar, Bengal, Masulipatnam): 1813 law barred ships under 350 tonnes from India–Britain routes; 1814 law denied Indian-built ships “British-registered” status for trade with America and Europe.
  • Steel (Tatas) hampered — forced to make high-grade steel for British use; barred from British markets.
  • Indian traders, moneylenders, bankers prospered only as junior partners of British capital; a healthy independent industrial bourgeoisie was retarded.
  • Modern industry: first cotton mill, Bombay, 1853 (Cowasjee Nanabhoy Davar); first jute mill, Rishra (Bengal), 1855 (foreign); most industries foreign-owned under British managing agencies.
  • Foreign capital came for high profits, cheap labour and raw materials, ready markets, state help, export demand (tea, jute, manganese).
  • Indian-owned: cotton and jute (19th c.), sugar, cement (20th c.); handicaps — credit, no tariff protection, unequal competition, British opposition.
  • Lopsided growth: heavy industry and power neglected; regional disparities; no technical education. Socially: rise of industrial capitalists and working class.

7. Nationalist critique and the Drain Theory ⭐⭐⭐

  • After the 1860s, disillusionment with British rule’s promise of modernisation.
  • Dadabhai Naoroji, “Grand Old Man of India” — Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (1901; earlier paper “Poverty of India”, 1867/1876).
  • Others: M.G. Ranade, R.C. Dutt (The Economic History of India, 1901–03), G.K. Gokhale, G. Subramania Iyer, Prithwishchandra Ray, G.V. Joshi.
  • Essence of colonialism: India as a supplier of foodstuffs and raw materials, a market for British manufactures, and a field for British capital investment. Demanded an independent economy based on modern industry with Indian, not foreign, capital (foreign capital suppresses Indian capital, drains wealth and creates vested interests for continued rule).
  • Poverty is man-made and removable → a national issue; development = industrialisation.
  • Trade and railways: trade pattern unfavourable; railways brought a commercial not industrial revolution and helped foreign goods; G.V. Joshi — railway spending was “an Indian subsidy to British industries”.
  • One-way free trade ruined handicrafts; taxes burdened the poor, spared British capitalists; demanded lower land revenue, abolition of salt tax, income tax and excise on the rich.

Economic drain

Definition: the part of India’s national product not available for Indians’ consumption but transferred to Britain for political reasons, without adequate economic return.
Components:
  1. Salaries and pensions of British civil and military officials (“Home Charges”);
  1. Interest on loans taken by the Government of India abroad;
  1. Profits on foreign investment;
  1. Stores bought in Britain for civil and military departments;
  1. Payments for shipping, banking, insurance (which stunted Indian enterprise).
  • Drain checked capital formation in India and fed British growth; the surplus returned as finance capital, draining more.
  • Estimates: more than total land revenue, or half of total government revenue, or one-third of total savings (~8% of national product).
  • The idea was easily grasped by peasants; it undermined the moral claim of British rule and fuelled nationalism in the Moderate “seed-time” (1875–1905); by 1905 Dadabhai was demanding self-rule.
💬
John Sullivan: British rule acts like a sponge — sucking up from the Ganges and squeezing out on the Thames. · R.C. Dutt: taxation should return as fertilising rain, but India’s falls on other lands. · Dadabhai: under British rule the Indian “starves in peace and perishes in peace, with law and order”. · Sir George Wingate: taxes spent abroad are “absolute loss”. · Sachchidanand Sinha 🟣 on the “White Man’s Burden” being dictated by the Chamber of Commerce. · Angus Maddison: a substantial outflow lasting 190 years.

8. Stages of colonialism (R. Palme Dutt) ⭐

Stage
Period
Dominant features
I. Mercantilism / Monopoly trade and direct appropriation
1757–1813
Monopoly of Indian trade; direct seizure of revenue; no basic changes in administration, law, transport, production, education or culture (only military and top revenue machinery); drain = 2–3% of Britain’s national income, financing its industrial revolution; Indian textile exports actually rose but weavers were ruined by Company compulsion
II. Free trade colonialism (industrial capital)
1813 – 1860s
India as a market for British manufactures and source of raw materials (cotton, food); import duties removed; free entry for British capital in plantations, mining, trade, transport; Permanent and Ryotwari settlements to create capitalist agriculture; administration reached villages; criminal and contract law overhauled (personal law untouched); modern education for cheap clerks and loyalty; India took 10–12% of British exports and ~20% of its textiles; railway stores imported after 1850; Indian army used for imperial expansion
III. Finance imperialism / foreign investment and competition for colonies
1860s onwards
Britain’s supremacy challenged (Europe, USA, Japan); science-led industry (oil, electricity); unified world market; reactionary consolidation under Lytton, Dufferin, Lansdowne, Curzon; British capital into railways, government loans, trade, plantations, coal, jute, shipping, banking; self-government idea dropped (revived after 1918) — permanent “trusteeship”, Indians a “child people” — “White Man’s burden”

🧠 Memory box

  • Land systems “Z-R-M = 19-51-30”: Zamindari 19%, Ryotwari 51%, Mahalwari 30%.
  • People: Cornwallis–Permanent · Munro & Read–Ryotwari · Elphinstone–Bombay ryotwari · Holt Mackenzie & R.M. Bird–Mahalwari · Wingate & Goldsmid–Bombay survey.
  • Years: Izara 1772 → Decennial 1790 → Permanent 1793 → Sunset Law 1794 → Ryotwari 1820 → Mahalwari 1822 → Reg IX 1833 → Torture Commission 1855.
  • Factory Acts: 1881 (children 7–12, 9 hrs) → 1891 (9–14, 7 hrs; women 11 hrs; weekly holiday).
  • Drain: Home charges + interest + profits + stores + services.

🎯 Exam traps

  • ⚠️ Permanent Settlement covered Bengal and Bihar (and Orissa, Banaras, N. Madras) — not Punjab or Bombay.
  • ⚠️ Ryotwari covered the largest area (~51%).
  • ⚠️ “Father of land settlements in N. India” = R.M. Bird.
  • ⚠️ Poverty and Un-British Rule in India = Dadabhai Naoroji (1901); Economic History of India = R.C. Dutt.
  • ⚠️ First cotton mill: Bombay 1853; first jute mill: Rishra 1855.
  • ⚠️ The first demand for factory laws came from Lancashire mill-owners.