Sub-topics: Simon Commission (1927–30) · Lee, Muddiman, Linlithgow commissions · Ambedkar’s memorandum · Nehru Report (1928) · Delhi Proposals · Jinnah’s 14 Points (1929).
1. Appointment of the Simon CommissionOther inquiries of the 1920s2. Indian response ⭐⭐Dr Ambedkar before the Commission (Oct 1928)Impact3. Simon Commission Report (May 1930, two volumes)4. The Nehru Report (August 1928) ⭐⭐RecommendationsCommunal responsesJinnah’s amendments — All Parties Convention, Calcutta (Dec 1928)Jinnah’s Fourteen Points (March 1929) ⭐Reaction of young Congressmen🧠 Memory box🎯 Exam traps
1. Appointment of the Simon Commission
- The GoI Act 1919 provided for a commission after 10 years to review the reforms.
- Indian Statutory Commission (“Simon Commission”), announced 8 November 1927 by PM Stanley Baldwin’s Conservative government — 7 members, all white (4 Conservatives, 2 Labour, 1 Liberal), chaired by Sir John Simon; members included Clement Attlee (future PM).
- Appointed two years early because the Conservatives feared losing to Labour and didn’t want India left in “irresponsible Labour hands”.
- Secretary of State Lord Birkenhead was responsible; he kept saying Indians could never agree on a constitution (the “Birkenhead challenge”).
Other inquiries of the 1920s
Body | Year | Purpose / outcome |
Lee Commission (Royal Commission on the Superior Civil Services) | 1923–24 | Service conditions and recruitment of Europeans and Indians; recommended immediate setting up of a Public Service Commission (set up 1926) |
Muddiman Committee (Reforms Enquiry Committee) | 1924 | Working of the 1919 constitution; majority: minor changes; minority (Indian non-officials): abolish dyarchy, democratise |
Linlithgow Commission (Royal Commission on Agriculture) | 1926 (report 1928) | Agrarian and rural economy; e.g., improve cattle by importing better foreign bulls |
2. Indian response ⭐⭐
- Anger at the all-white composition — foreigners deciding India’s fitness for self-government violated self-determination and insulted Indian self-respect.
- Congress, Madras session (Dec 1927), president M.A. Ansari: boycott the commission “at every stage and in every form”; Nehru got a snap resolution passed declaring complete independence as the Congress goal.
- Supported boycott: Liberals, Hindu Mahasabha, majority of the Muslim League under Jinnah (Calcutta session 1927). Did not boycott: League faction under Muhammad Shafi (Lahore session), Unionists (Punjab), Justice Party (south).
- Commission landed at Bombay, 3 February 1928 — countrywide hartal; black flags and “Simon Go Back” wherever it went (slogan credited to Yusuf Meherally; some say Lajpat Rai).
- A new generation of youth got its first taste of politics; Nehru and Subhas Bose emerged as youth leaders; radical/socialist groups grew — Punjab Naujawan Bharat Sabha, Workers’ and Peasants’ Parties, Hindustani Sewa Dal (Karnataka).
- Repression: Nehru and G.B. Pant beaten at Lucknow; Lala Lajpat Rai struck at Lahore (30 Oct 1928), died 17 November 1928 — “the blows which fell on me today are the last nails in the coffin of British imperialism”.
Dr Ambedkar before the Commission (Oct 1928)
- Appointed by the Bombay Legislative Council to work with it; argued for universal adult franchise (men and women), provincial autonomy, dyarchy at the centre.
- Memorandum for the Bahishkrit Hitakarini Sabha: depressed classes are a distinct, independent minority needing more protection than any other; representation on the same basis as Muslims; reserved seats if adult franchise is given, otherwise separate electorates; safeguards on education and services.
- The report gave reserved seats, but candidates needed the governor’s certificate of competence — Ambedkar was displeased.
Impact
- Stimulated radical forces demanding complete independence and socialist reforms; gave the Congress a mass issue.
- The Birkenhead challenge was accepted — brief hope of Indian unity (Nehru Report).
3. Simon Commission Report (May 1930, two volumes)
- Abolish dyarchy; representative government with autonomy in provinces; governor to keep discretionary powers for internal security and protection of communities; bigger provincial councils.
- Rejected parliamentary responsibility at the centre; GG to appoint cabinet; Government of India to control High Courts.
- Retain (and extend) separate electorates until communal tension eased; no universal franchise.
- Federation accepted in principle but not soon; a Consultative Council of Greater India (British provinces + princely states).
- Local legislatures for NWFP and Baluchistan with representation at the centre.
- Separate Sindh from Bombay; separate Burma from India.
- Indianise the army but retain British forces.
- By the time it came out it was irrelevant — overtaken by events (CDM, RTC). It did, however, feed into the 1935 Act.
4. The Nehru Report (August 1928) ⭐⭐
- All Parties Conference (Feb 1928) appointed a committee under Motilal Nehru — the first major Indian attempt to draft a constitution.
- Members: Tej Bahadur Sapru, Subhas Chandra Bose, M.S. Aney, Mangal Singh, Ali Imam 🟣, Shuaib Qureshi, G.R. Pradhan (Jawaharlal Nehru secretary).
- Unanimous except one point: majority wanted dominion status; a section wanted complete independence (given freedom of action).
Recommendations
- Dominion status like self-governing dominions (angered the young militants).
- No separate electorates — joint electorates with reservation for Muslims at the centre and in provinces where they are a minority (not in Punjab and Bengal), in proportion to population, with right to contest more seats.
- Linguistic provinces.
- 19 fundamental rights incl. equal rights for women, right to form unions, universal adult suffrage.
- Responsible government at centre and provinces:
- Parliament: House of Representatives of 500 (adult suffrage, 5-year term) and a Senate of 200 (elected by provincial councils, 7 years); Governor-General (appointed by Britain, paid from Indian revenues) acting on advice of an executive council responsible to Parliament.
- Provinces: 5-year councils; governor acting on advice of the provincial executive council.
- Full protection of Muslims’ cultural and religious interests.
- Complete separation of state and religion.
- Confined to British India; princely states to join later on a federal basis.
Communal responses
Delhi Proposals (Dec 1927) — Muslim leaders at Delhi (accepted by the Madras Congress):
- Joint electorates with reserved seats for Muslims;
- One-third representation in the Central Legislative Assembly;
- Representation in Punjab and Bengal in proportion to population;
- Three new Muslim-majority provinces — Sindh, Baluchistan, NWFP.
Hindu Mahasabha opposed new Muslim provinces and reservation for Muslim majorities in Punjab and Bengal; demanded a strictly unitary structure. The League left the conference. Motilal was caught in between.
Concessions to Hindu communalists in the report: joint electorates with reservation only where Muslims are a minority; Sindh separated only after dominion status and with weightage to Hindus; broadly unitary structure (residual powers with the centre).
Jinnah’s amendments — All Parties Convention, Calcutta (Dec 1928)
- One-third Muslim seats in the central legislature;
- Reservation in Bengal and Punjab in proportion to population until adult suffrage;
- Residual powers to provinces. Not accepted → Jinnah called it the “parting of the ways” and returned to the Shafi faction.
Jinnah’s Fourteen Points (March 1929) ⭐
- Federal constitution with residual powers to provinces.
- Provincial autonomy.
- No constitutional amendment by the centre without the states’ concurrence.
- Adequate Muslim representation in all legislatures without reducing a Muslim majority to minority or equality.
- Adequate Muslim share in services and local bodies.
- One-third Muslim representation in the central legislature.
- One-third Muslims in central and provincial cabinets.
- Separate electorates.
- No bill to pass if three-fourths of a minority community oppose it.
- No territorial redistribution affecting Muslim majorities in Punjab, Bengal, NWFP.
- Separate Sindh from Bombay.
- Constitutional reforms in NWFP and Baluchistan.
- Full religious freedom for all.
- Protection of Muslim religion, culture, education, language.
These became the basis of all future League propaganda.
Reaction of young Congressmen
Jawaharlal Nehru and Subhas Bose called dominion status a step backward and set up the Independence for India League (1928). The Calcutta Congress (Dec 1928) (president Motilal Nehru) gave the government one year to accept the Nehru Report (dominion status), failing which it would demand complete independence and launch civil disobedience → Lahore 1929.
🧠 Memory box
- “8-3-30-17”: announced 8 Nov 1927 → landed 3 Feb 1928 → Lajpat Rai hit 30 Oct 1928 → died 17 Nov 1928.
- Nehru Report = Dominion status + joint electorates + 19 rights + linguistic provinces + unitary tilt.
- Jinnah: Calcutta amendments (3) → 14 Points (Mar 1929) → “parting of the ways”.
- Delhi Proposals (Dec 1927) had 4 points incl. one-third seats and three new provinces.
🎯 Exam traps
- ⚠️ Simon Commission had no Indian member; Attlee was a member.
- ⚠️ Madras 1927 (Ansari) = boycott + first independence resolution; Lahore 1929 = Purna Swaraj as formal goal.
- ⚠️ Nehru Report was drafted by Motilal Nehru (Jawaharlal was secretary).
- ⚠️ Nehru Report wanted joint electorates; Jinnah’s 14 Points wanted separate electorates.
- ⚠️ Simon Report recommended separating Burma and Sindh, and no responsible government at the centre.