Notes · History

07 · Socio-Religious Reform: Features, Women & Caste

Short, exam-focused revision notes. Read a section, then test yourself with a quiz.

8 min read6 sections

07 · Socio-Religious Reform: Features, Women & Caste

📌
Sub-topic: Socio-religious reform movements — general features, the struggle for women’s rights (laws with years) and against caste. Organisations & founders are on page 08.

1. Why reform? (Factors)

The 19th-century awakening (often loosely called the “Indian Renaissance”) was occasioned by colonial rule but not created by it.
  1. Impact of British rule — unlike earlier invaders who were absorbed, the British arrived when Europe was transformed by science, while India appeared stagnant and decadent.
  1. Religious ills — superstition, magic, idolatry, polytheism; priests’ monopoly over scriptures.
  1. Plight of women — female infanticide, child marriage, polygamy (Bengal’s Kulinism — old men marrying young girls), sati (which Rammohan called “murder according to every shastra”), miserable widowhood.
  1. Caste — ritual hierarchy, untouchability; caste-consciousness also among Muslims, Christians, Sikhs; blocked mobility and national unity.
  1. Reaction to Western culture — attempt to reinvigorate tradition against colonial cultural dominance.
  1. New awareness — realisation that India was colonised because of internal weaknesses; some Bengali youth went to the other extreme (drinking wine, eating beef to shock orthodoxy).
  1. Later: rise of nationalism and democracy, new economic forces, education, awareness of the world.

2. Social and ideological bases

  • Social base: the new middle class and intellectuals (both traditionally and Western educated). Unlike Europe’s middle class, they came not from trade/industry (controlled by the British) but from government service, law, education, journalism, medicine, often with some intermediate land tenures.
  • Ideology: rationalism, religious universalism, humanism (and secularism).
    • Rationalism: Rammohan Roy — causality and demonstrability as the test of truth. Akshay Kumar Dutt: “rationalism is our only preceptor”; used medical opinion against child marriage. Brahmo Samaj rejected the infallibility of the Vedas; Syed Ahmed Khan said religious tenets are not immutable. Vivekananda: religion must justify itself by the method of science.
    • Universalism: Rammohan saw religions as national forms of universal theism (Vedic monotheism, Christian unitarianism); Syed Ahmed Khan — all prophets had the same din.
    • Humanism: humanity can progress; individual’s right to interpret scriptures; attack on priestly domination.
  • Focus on this world, not salvation. The movements covered the whole culture — vernacular languages, alternative education, Indian art and literature, dress and food, Indian medicine, pre-colonial technology.
  • Neither total revival of the past nor total break — the past used as an aid.

Two streams

Reformist
Revivalist
Brahmo Samaj, Prarthana Samaj, Aligarh Movement
Arya Samaj, Deoband Movement
Both appealed to the “lost purity” of religion; they differed only in how much they relied on tradition vs reason and conscience.

Direction of social reform

  • Social reform was tied to religious reform because evils like untouchability and gender inequality drew legitimacy from religion; later it became secular.
  • Base widened from upper castes/middle classes to the lower strata.
  • Agents: Social Conference, Servants of India Society, Christian missionaries, individuals (Phule, Gopalhari Deshmukh, K.T. Telang, B.M. Malabari, D.K. Karve, Sri Narayana Guru, E.V. Ramaswami Naicker, B.R. Ambedkar); in the 20th century the national movement took over.
  • Media: Indian languages, novels, plays, poetry, press, and (1930s) cinema.
  • Two-point agenda: (1) betterment of women; (2) removal of untouchability.

3. Struggle for women’s emancipation ⭐⭐

Women had no identity apart from men; purdah, early marriage, no widow remarriage, sati; Hindu women had no inheritance or divorce rights; Muslim women inherited half a man’s share and had unequal divorce rights; polygamy common in both. Reformers argued that true religion did not sanction women’s inferior status, and that a nation whose women are in ignorance cannot progress.

Legislative & administrative milestones

Year
Measure
Who/Why
1795, 1804
Bengal Regulations declared female infanticide illegal (= murder)
Practised by upper-class Bengalis and Rajputs
1829
Regulation XVII of the Bengal Code — sati illegal, punishable as culpable homicide
William Bentinck, after Rammohan Roy’s campaign (from 1818); extended to Madras and Bombay in 1830
1856
Hindu Widows’ Remarriage Act — widow remarriage legal, children legitimate
Ishwar Chandra Vidyasagar (cited Vedic texts); GG Dalhousie/Canning
1870
Compulsory registration of births, verification of female children
Against infanticide
1872
Native Marriage Act (Civil Marriage Act) — against child marriage
Limited: not applicable to Hindus, Muslims and other recognised faiths (Brahmo marriages)
1891
Age of Consent Act — no marriage of girls below 12
B.M. Malabari; spurred by the Rukhmabai case; opposed by Tilak
1929 (in force 1930)
Child Marriage Restraint Act / Sarda Act — age 18 (boys), 14 (girls)
Harbilas Sarda (Arya Samajist, MLA from Ajmer-Merwara)
1937
Hindu Women’s Right to Property Act
AIWC effort
1978
Child Marriage Restraint (Amendment) Act — 18 (girls), 21 (boys)
Free India
(Earlier attempts to curb sati: Portuguese/Dutch/French in their areas; Akbar (1582) ordered that no widow be coerced; Albuquerque in Goa.)

Widow remarriage

  • Vishnu Shastri Pandit — Widow Remarriage Association (1850s).
  • Karsandas Mulji — Satya Prakash in Gujarati (1852).
  • D.K. Karve (western India) — married a widow himself (1893); widows’ home in Poona; secretary of the Widow Remarriage Association.
  • Veerasalingam Pantulu (Madras/Andhra).
  • Also: B.M. Malabari, Narmad, Justice M.G. Ranade, K. Natarajan, Jyotiba and Savitribai Phule.

The Rukhmabai case (1884–88)

Rukhmabai Raut, married at 11 to Dadaji Bhikaji, stayed with her step-father Sakharam Arjun and studied. 12 years later Dadaji sued for restitution of conjugal rights (Dadaji Bhikaji vs Rukhmabai, 1884). Justice Robert Hill Pinhey ruled for her (married in “helpless infancy”); overturned in 1887 by Chief Justice Charles Sargent and Justice Farran. She said she would rather go to jail; reportedly Queen Victoria’s intervention set aside the sentence. Rukhmabai Defence Committee (Malabari, Ramabai Ranade). She became one of India’s first practising women doctors (Chief Medical Officer, Surat). The case led to the Age of Consent Act 1891.

Education of women

Year
Milestone
1819
Calcutta Female Juvenile Society — Christian missionaries (first)
1848
Jyotiba & Savitribai Phule — first girls’ school at Bhidewada, Pune; Savitribai = first woman teacher of modern India (with Fatima Sheikh, Sagunabai)
1849
Bethune School, Calcutta — by J.E.D. Bethune; Vidyasagar its secretary
1850s
Vidyasagar ran ~35 girls’ schools in Bengal
1854
Wood’s Despatch stressed female education (Dalhousie: “frank and cordial support”)
1863
Alexandra Society for Parsi girls
1887
Cornelia Sorabji — first woman graduate of Bombay University (later first woman barrister)
1880s
Dufferin hospitals for women
1914
Women’s Medical Service
1916
Indian Women’s University (SNDT) by D.K. Karve; Lady Hardinge Medical College, Delhi
In Bombay: Jagannath ‘Nana’ Shankarsheth (School Society → Bombay Native Institution 1824 → Board of Education 1840 → Elphinstone Institution 1856; gave space for Dr Wilson’s girls’ school at Girgaum) and Bhau Daji Lad (first Indian president of the Students’ Literary and Scientific Society). Phule’s schools were an indigenous non-Brahmin effort without official help.

Women in public life

  • Swadeshi, anti-partition and Home Rule movements liberated women; after 1918 they faced lathis and jail, joined trade unions, kisan and revolutionary movements.
  • Sarojini Naidu — Congress President (1925, Kanpur), Governor of the United Provinces (1947–49).

Women’s organisations

Organisation
Year
Founder
Note
Arya Mahila Samaj
1882
Pandita Ramabai Saraswati
Pleaded before the Hunter (Education) Commission → medical education for women (Lady Dufferin College)
Ladies Social Conference (Bharat Mahila Parishad)
1904, Bombay
Ramabai Ranade
Under the National Social Conference
Bharat Stree Mahamandal
1910, Allahabad
Sarla Devi Chaudhurani
First major all-India women’s body founded by a woman; men working for women lived “under the shade of Manu”
National Council of Women in India
1925
Mehribai Tata
Branch of the International Council of Women; Cornelia Sorabji, Tarabai Premchand, Shaffi Tyabji, Maharani Sucharu Devi
All India Women’s Conference (AIWC)
1927
Margaret Cousins
First session at Fergusson College, Pune; egalitarian; members incl. Sarojini Naidu, Kamaladevi Chattopadhyay, Maharani Chimnabai Gaekwad, Lady Dorab Tata

4. Struggle against caste ⭐

Caste (chaturvarna and countless sub-castes) decided education, property, occupation, dining, marriage, dress, residence, water sources and temple entry. Untouchables suffered the worst disabilities.

Factors that weakened caste

  1. British rule (unintentionally) — private property in land and its free sale; break-up of village autarky; new jobs in commerce/industry; urbanisation and transport; equality before law; caste panchayats lost judicial powers; services open to all; secular education.
  1. Reform movements — Brahmo, Prarthana, Arya Samaj, Ramakrishna Mission, Theosophists, Social Conference spread education among untouchables, fought bans on temples/tanks; attacked hereditary caste and the karma theory (Arya Samaj: rebuild four varnas by merit; lowest castes may study the Vedas).
  1. National movement — liberty and equality; mass participation diluted caste; Congress ministries (1937) gave free education to Harijans; Travancore, Indore, Dewas opened state temples. Gandhi: Shastras don’t sanction untouchability; founded the All India Harijan Sangh (1932).
  1. Awakening among lower castes:
      • Jyotiba Phule (Mali caste) — against Brahminical domination; education for lower castes and girls.
      • Gopal Baba Walangkar — pioneer of Dalit uplift (Raigad); Anarya Dosh-Parihar Mandali; first Dalit to start a newspaper, Vital Vidhvansak.
      • Kisan Faguji Bansod — uplift within Hinduism; press publishing Dalit journals.
      • B.R. Ambedkar — Mooknayak (1920); Bahishkrit Hitakarini Sabha (1924) — motto “Educate, Agitate, Organise”; Bahishkrit Bharat (1927); Mahad Satyagraha (March 1927) — led ~2,500 untouchables to drink from the Chavdar tank; burnt the Manusmriti there in Dec 1927; All India Scheduled Castes Federation (1942). Others formed the All India Depressed Classes Association (1920s). Result: special representation in the GoI Act 1935.
      • Maharaja of Kolhapur (Shahu) encouraged the non-Brahmin movement, which spread south (Kammas, Reddis, Vellalas, Muslims).
      • Self-Respect Movement (1920s) — E.V. Ramaswamy Naicker.
      • Sri Narayana Guru (Kerala): “one religion, one caste, one God for mankind”; disciple Sahodaran Ayyappan changed it to “no religion, no caste, no God for mankind”.
  1. Constitution of free India — abolished untouchability; bans restrictions on wells, tanks, ghats, hotels, etc.; Directive Principles for social justice. (British rule could not go far — feared orthodox reaction; social uplift needs economic and political freedom.)

🧠 Memory box

  • Women-law ladder: Infanticide 1795/1804 → Sati 1829 → Widow Remarriage 1856 → Civil Marriage 1872 → Age of Consent 1891 (12 yrs) → Sarda 1929/30 (14/18) → Amendment 1978 (18/21).
  • Person → law: Rammohan–Sati · Vidyasagar–Widow Remarriage · Malabari–Age of Consent · Harbilas Sarda–Child Marriage.
  • Women’s bodies: Ramabai (Pandita) → Arya Mahila Samaj; Ramabai Ranade → Ladies Social Conference; Sarla Devi → Bharat Stree Mahamandal 1910; Margaret Cousins → AIWC 1927.
  • Ambedkar papers: Mooknayak (1920) → Bahishkrit Bharat (1927); later Janata, Prabuddha Bharat.

🎯 Exam traps

  • ⚠️ The 1829 sati ban first applied to Bengal Presidency only; Madras & Bombay in 1830.
  • ⚠️ Bethune School was founded by J.E.D. Bethune; Vidyasagar was its secretary.
  • ⚠️ Pandita Ramabai (Arya Mahila Samaj, Sharada Sadan) ≠ Ramabai Ranade (wife of M.G. Ranade; Seva Sadan Poona, Ladies Social Conference).
  • ⚠️ Age of Consent Act 1891 = 12 years; Sarda Act = 14 years for girls.
  • ⚠️ The Native Marriage Act 1872 did not apply to Hindus and Muslims.